Trump's flirtation with Trumpcare ignores the dying poor
By Josie Calloway · Reporting from Pittsburgh ·
Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed's pitch for universal healthcare is a clever lure, but Donald Trump's record of Medicaid cuts proves he is not the savior of the sick.
The quietest patients are always the sickest. Right now, they are the people losing their lifeline. CNN reports that 5.5 million people lost food stamp benefits since July 2025. This happened because of provisions in Donald Trump's "big beautiful bill." In January, Medicaid work requirements begin in most states. That is a death sentence for people who are too sick to work but too poor to pay. While the politicians play a game of branding in Washington, the people in the poorest zip codes are the ones who will pay. Donald Trump is not interested in saving them. He is interested in the gold card.
A gold card for a broken system
Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed is a physician. He knows what happens when a patient has no insurance. He has spent his career fighting for the people the system forgets. As health director for Wayne County, he helped erase millions of dollars in medical debt for residents, according to Newsweek. He knows that medical debt is a parasite. It eats a family's future before the disease even finishes with the body.
El-Sayed is playing a high-stakes game. He pitched a universal healthcare plan to Donald Trump. He suggested calling it "Trumpcare." He even posted mock-ups of gold cards on X. The cards say "Show this card at any doctor, hospital clinic, or pharmacy in the United States." He called Trump "habibi" in a video. He told the president to put his name all over it.
Trump took the bait. He reposted the gold card on Truth Social. He told Fox News that the government could "do tremendous things on healthcare." He said there is a chance to get great healthcare in a bipartisan way. He even admitted that Democrats "have some good points on healthcare."
This is a performance. Trump loves a brand. He loves the idea of a gold card with his name on it. But a gold card is not a clinic. It is not a nurse in a rural ER. It is not a bottle of insulin that does not cost a month's rent. El-Sayed is trying to leverage Trump's ego to save lives. It is a bold move. But the chart does not lie.
The deficit lie and the cost of death
The White House is already pushing back. Spokeswoman Allison Schuster told Fox News Digital that the proposal is a "socialist proposal." She called it "Medicare for None." She claims Trump has already saved Americans well over $1 Billion on prescription drugs.
The most dangerous weapon in the White House arsenal is the balance sheet. The U.S. Council of Economic Advisers analyzed the plan. They claim Medicare for All would increase the federal budget deficit by approximately $47.4 trillion. They say it would destroy access to care by shifting people away from employer-sponsored insurance.
This is the strongest case the opposition makes. They argue that the math is impossible. They say the deficit would swallow the country. They treat healthcare like a corporate ledger.
But as a nurse, I know the cost of the alternative. The cost of "not" providing care is higher. It is paid in ER visits for preventable strokes. It is paid in late-stage cancers that could have been caught early. The CEA's $47.4 trillion figure is a ghost. It does not count the money saved when people stop going bankrupt from a hospital stay. It does not count the productivity of a healthy workforce.
We have seen this fight before. During the Repeal and Replace efforts of 2016-2017, the GOP tried to dismantle the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act. They used the same talk of costs and efficiency. But the real goal was to cut the safety net. The 2018 Michigan gubernatorial election showed that people are hungry for Medicare for All. They are tired of rationing their lives.
A pattern of failed promises
This is not a new dance. The mechanism here is the same as the Health Security Act of 1993. Back then, the Clinton administration proposed a national health program to ensure basic care. Like Trump now, they faced a conservative coalition in Congress.
The pattern is clear. A leader flirts with the idea of universal care to quiet the masses. Then, they pivot to narrow fixes. Trump has already signaled this. He told Fox News he might work with Democrats to cap credit card interest rates. He likes the populist win. He likes the "big" gesture.
But look at the record. Trump and Republicans funded tax cuts with cuts to Medicaid. That is the real policy. The "Trumpcare" gold card is a distraction from the Medicaid cuts that are already codified.
El-Sayed has worked within the system before. In 2020, he served on the Unity Task Force for Healthcare. He knows how to navigate the federal framework. He is trying to move the needle toward a system where nobody rations insulin. He is trying to turn a policy goal into a law, much like the push for the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act.
But Trump is not the man for the job. He is a man of the veto. He posted an image of himself in a red "VETO"-branded hat. He says he will not veto everything, but he holds the power. He will cherry-pick the popular parts of the plan. He will take the credit for a few drug price caps. Then he will let the Medicaid work requirements starve the people in the rural towns.
Donald Trump is an unserious man playing with a serious crisis. He sees a gold card. I see a waiting room full of people who cannot afford to be there. He sees a bipartisan win. I see a system that treats the poor as a deficit to be managed.
The verdict is in the data. You cannot build a healthcare system on the ego of one man. You cannot save the sick by branding the cure. Trump's openness to "Trumpcare" is a mirage. He will not fight the insurance companies. He will not restore the Medicaid cuts. He will use the gold card to hide the fact that the poorest Americans are still being left to die in the dark.
Sources
- NBC News: Abdul El-Sayed catches Trump’s attention with pitch for ‘Trumpcare’
- Newsweek: Trump Shares El-Sayed’s ‘TrumpCare’ Plan, Says He May Work with Democrats
- Fox News: White House blasts 'Trumpcare for All' pitch from far-left El-Sayed who called president 'unserious fool'
- HuffPost: Trump’s Social Media Post Fuels Questions About Potential Medicare-For-All Support
- CNN: Some Democrats want to work with Trump. Here’s where they might agree
- Anadolu Agency: Trump shares Democratic senator-elect's 'TrumpCare' proposal on Truth Social