Thom Tillis halts Trump nominees to protect Senate process

By Adele Rutherford · Reporting from Atlanta ·

By blocking two contentious executive nominees, Senator Thom Tillis proved that Senate procedure remains the only durable barrier standing between the Republic and raw executive will.

Procedure is where power lives

When a nominee before the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee looks at a record of the Capitol attack and says he does not know if it happened, the question is no longer about ideology. It is about whether the nominee can inhabit reality. Michael LoSapio was nominated to lead the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency. According to reporting by HuffPost, he told Sen. Richard Blumenthal (D-Conn.) that he did not know if the Capitol was attacked on Jan. 6, 2021. Asked directly, LoSapio said “No” and stated he “wasn’t involved in politics.” You cannot secure election infrastructure if you cannot acknowledge an insurrection when it sits in the transcript. Sen. Ron Wyden (D-Ore.) put it plainly to HuffPost: “You can’t have an insurrectionist Palantir executive in charge of our nation’s cybersecurity and election security.”

Nor was LoSapio alone in drawing a halt. Sen. Thom Tillis (R-N.C.), a retiring moderate, placed a procedural hold on LoSapio alongside Wyden. He did the same for Eric Ueland, Trump’s nominee to head the Government Accountability Office. Ueland is a longtime conservative operative and former deputy to Russ Vought at the Office of Management and Budget. He stepped straight out of the apparatus that seven states are currently suing for withholding billions in federal money appropriated by Congress. Sen. Gary Peters (D-Mich.) rightly called putting Ueland at the GAO an attempt to “install a fox in the henhouse.” A rule that only works while your people hold power was never a rule. Putting an OMB operative in charge of the independent auditor of congressional spending turns the watchdog into an office pet. Senate Majority Leader John Thune (R-S.D.) will respect these objections. A senior GOP aide told HuffPost that Thune has honored all previous holds and has not filed cloture on individual nominees over member objections. That institutional deference is the quiet machinery that keeps the Senate from turning into a Roman circus.

The executive shortcut and its cost

This friction over personnel is part of a broader executive strategy that bypasses statutory limits whenever the apparatus finds them inconvenient. Consider the Iran-Contra affair, where senior officials of the Reagan administration secretly funneled arms sales proceeds to the Contras to evade the Boland Amendments passed by Congress. The mechanism is identical. When legislative appropriations and oversight stand in the way, the executive branch attempts to route around them through loyalist appointments and unmonitored directives. We saw it again during the 2018 United States federal budget impasse, when withheld funds became a blunt instrument of executive leverage.

We see it now at the Pentagon. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth—whose own confirmation required a tie-breaking vote by Vice President JD Vance—issued a classified memo restricting military cooperation with Canada. Chief Pentagon spokesman Sean Parnell told Free Malaysia Today that the Department of War is refocusing the relationship around American defense priorities. While Parnell insisted the directive does not impact NORAD or NATO cooperation, the unilateral shift has already unsettled Ottawa. Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney rejected recent suggestions of annexation from President Donald Trump. Tony Wright, spokesman for Canada's ministry of national defence, maintained that collaborative work continues despite the noise. When the executive branch treats allied treaties as negotiable menu items, it invites retaliatory trade friction. That friction saw Trump impose tariffs on Canadian goods and cite national security under Section 232 of the Trade Expansion Act of 1962 to restrict industrial machinery imports.

When the stabilization mandate breaks

That same executive impatience is now colliding with the ground realities of the Middle East. There, the U.S.-led Board of Peace for Gaza faces a severe breakdown. Josh Gruenbaum, a senior adviser to the Board of Peace chaired by Donald Trump, told Middle East Eye that it was “frustrating” that “Israel is failing to move forward on the commitments Prime Minister Netanyahu made to President Trump.” The Board was given a mandate in November 2025 by the UN Security Council to establish an international stabilization force as part of a plan to end hostilities and demilitarize Gaza. Yet talks have stalled for months over Hamas weapons handovers and ongoing Israeli attacks, with over 1,600 Palestinians killed since the October 2025 ceasefire. Gruenbaum drew a hard line for Middle East Eye: “If this political leadership is now telling us that they no longer want to honour what they committed to, then just let us know now - and we’re basically going to throw the keys back to the UN to oversee the mandate.” You cannot manage a transitional governance authority if the sovereign partner refuses to execute the security phases it signed.

The legitimacy of our public institutions is a capital stock that spends fast and refills slowly. Every shortcut taken by a President or a nominee eats the principal. Whether it is a GAO nominee tied to withheld appropriations, a CISA pick who cannot recall an insurrection, or a unilateral defense directive that strains our northern border, the answer is the same. We must judge the process by whether its reasoning survives the day our opponents hold the tool. Thom Tillis is retiring in January. By holding the line against unqualified nominees on his way out, he has shown that procedure is still the only thing standing between the Republic and raw will.

Sources

  1. HuffPost: A Republican Senator Just Tanked 2 Of Trump's Most Contentious Nominees
  2. Free Malaysia Today: Pentagon moves to restrict US-Canada defence ties
  3. Middle East Eye: 'Will throw keys back to UN': Trump-appointed Board of Peace adviser says Israel blocking efforts