Saudi Arabia sabotages the Cop31 climate summit in Antalya

By Sophie Naimi · Reporting from Paris ·

As petrostates and weak co-conveners strip fossil fuels from the Antalya text, rich nations abandon vulnerable islands to protect oil profits and default on climate finance.

A summit hijacked by petrostate power and weak co-hosts

The United Nations climate summit in Antalya, Turkey, has ground to a halt. It is not because planetary physics are mysterious. It is because the men who profit from burning the planet refuse to read the meter. As reported by the Guardian and the BBC, Cop31 overran its scheduled Friday evening end date. It plunged into a bleak Saturday overtime while negotiators wrestle with a draft text systematically stripped of any explicit mention of coal, oil, and gas. A coalition of approximately 130 countries insisted on keeping a reference to the transition away from fossil fuels. But Saudi Arabia and other oil-rich nations led a relentless push to excise the root cause of our warming world entirely from the cover decision.

To understand why this summit is unravelling, you must follow the money and the emissions. The Guardian notes that a first draft of the agreed outcome included a resolution on transitioning away from fossil fuels. That language vanished from a revised draft published on Thursday. By Sunday morning, a third draft merely recalled the deal established at Cop28 in Dubai three years ago. As Mohamed Adow of the Power Shift Africa thinktank told the BBC, rich countries spent two weeks finding reasons not to deliver promised financial support. Delegates are left fighting to stop governments from retreating entirely from prior commitments. This is the bitter fruit of 2015. Global climate summits then first wrestled with binding language on emissions reductions, only to dilute targets to appease fossil-fuel-producing states. The pattern repeated in Glasgow's halls during COP26.

Turkey’s Environment Minister Murat Kurum and Australia's Climate Change and Energy Minister Chris Bowen are the co-conveners steering this wreckage. Neither man brought a tradition of climate ambition to the table. Dossier records show Bowen’s deep-seated career ties to liquefied natural gas expansion and bilateral carbon capture cooperation with oil states. This ideological alignment explains why Australia’s delegation argued the summit should focus on implementation and clean-energy transitions rather than fighting over fossil fuel language. Meanwhile, as Claudio Angelo of the Observatorio do Clima observed in the Guardian, a weak presidency split between two countries with little tradition in climate diplomacy has proved detrimental to a process victimised by geopolitics.

The erasure of 1.5 degrees and the betrayal of the global south

We are no longer negotiating over preventive medicine; we are arguing over the triage while the ward catches fire. The BBC reports that the latest draft acknowledges for the first time that the world will miss the 1.5C warming goal. We are entering the terrifying era of overshoot. Yet instead of slamming the brakes on emissions, the co-hosts and petrostates engineered a text that opens backdoors for the fossil fuel industry. DW notes that while a voluntary target aims to derive 35% of energy from electricity by 2035, the draft does not stipulate clean power.

Instead, Saudi Arabia pushed hard for carbon capture and storage recommendations. France's Minister of Ecological Transition, Monique Barbut, rightly slammed these as a licence to continue burning oil and gas. As Teresa Anderson of ActionAid International warned in DW, the beneficiaries of these weak targets and unproven capture schemes are fossil fuel, nuclear, data, and CCUS industries. This text helps elites profit while leaving ordinary people in the dark. It echoes the darkest hours of COP27. Rich historic polluters then stonewalled demands for public climate finance and loss-and-damage funds, leaving developing economies drowning in debt and climate disasters.

The financial abandonment of the global south at Antalya has been absolute. PBS and the BBC report that earlier versions included a proposal to increase adaptation money to $120bn by 2035. That figure was quietly stripped out, leaving the Africa Group with no specific funding commitments. Zanetor Agyeman Rawlings, Ghana's Environment Minister and chair of the African Group, told the BBC that developing nations came not to beg, but to claim what is rightfully theirs. Yet rich nations arrived with empty pockets. As Harjeet Singh of the Fill the Fund campaign noted in DW, wealthy delegations spent two weeks demanding ambition while refusing to pay a cent for the transition.

The red lines of survival against the arrogance of delay

Defenders of the status quo and petrostate pragmatists present the opposing case. They argue that pushing rigid phaseout language in a fractured geopolitical landscape guarantees deadlock. They claim voluntary targets and carbon capture offer the only pragmatic path to consensus among nearly 200 nations. This argument is a fraud. It assumes that diplomatic comfort for oil barons can alter thermodynamics. When Tuvalu’s Climate Minister Maina Talia called fossil fuel mentions a non-negotiable red line, he spoke for the physics of survival. Without addressing the root cause, delegates waste their time while rising sea levels force mass displacement across the Pacific.

The historical pattern is a recurring tragedy. Whenever frontline nations demand accountability, fossil fuel producers deploy delay as a weapon. The Australian government's promotion of coal expansions poses an existential threat to low-lying islands. Western negotiators offer zero spirit of solidarity through quiet complicity. On Friday, a desperate protester interrupted Antalya proceedings, shouting that the global south cannot wait while leaders do nothing. That despair is rational. European Union climate commissioner Wopke Hoekstra declared no deal exists if minimum needs are unmet. Yet Saudi Arabia blocks every mention of the fuel killing us. The multilateral architecture wobbles on the edge of irrelevance.

Markets will not price a burning planet in time. European climate policy remains a hollow shell if it abandons the global south to burn for northern comfort. If the Antalya Accords pass without naming the oil and gas driving our ruin, they stand as a monument to cowardice. We must follow the emissions and the money straight to those who profit from delay. The survival of human societies cannot be traded away to protect Riyadh's profits or Canberra's export ledgers.

The Antalya Accords must be rejected for the petrostate bailout they are. Wealthy nations must be held to account for every dollar of adaptation debt they refuse to pay.

Sources

  1. The Guardian: Climate talks stall as countries mull showdown with Saudi Arabia over fossil fuel phaseout | Cop31
  2. BBC: COP31: New draft deal aims to avert collapse of talks at climate summit
  3. PBS: Climate talks in overtime as nations wrestle with response to worsening global warming
  4. BBC: New draft deal aims to avert collapse of talks at COP31 climate summit
  5. DW: COP31: Fossil fuels still missing from draft deal at UN climate summit