San Francisco's 'unprecedented' tides are a failure to adapt

By Imani Sutton · Reporting from Atlanta ·

Mayor Daniel Lurie warns of historic flooding this Thanksgiving, but treating predictable climate trends as a surprise ignores the cost of failing to upgrade the city's infrastructure.

San Francisco is acting like the ocean is a surprise guest. Mayor Daniel Lurie says the city faces tides the National Weather Service has "never seen before in recorded history." He wants people to stock up on supplies. He wants them to stay home. This is not a freak accident. It is a bill coming due. According to the San Francisco Chronicle, the peak tides hit during Thanksgiving week. They also hit during Christmas week and the week of Jan. 17.

The city is treating a systemic failure as a one-off emergency. When a leader calls a flood "unprecedented," they are not just describing the water. They are shielding the city from the blame of not being ready. This is a political trick. It turns a predictable climate trend into a sudden disaster. It tells citizens that risk is an act of God rather than a failure of city engineering.

The physics of a predictable flood

The science here is simple. The moon is at a cyclical peak. The sun is in a specific spot. El Niño is warming the Pacific. This creates "syzygy tides," or king tides. The San Francisco Chronicle notes that warmed water expands. Melting ice from climate change adds more volume. This uses the same mechanism as the 1982–1983 El Niño. That event was one of the strongest El Niño events since records were kept.

We are not starting from the same place we were in 1983. Baseline sea levels are higher now. We have decades of warming in the tank. Relying on the "recorded history" of San Francisco is a gamble. The water does not care about the record books. It only cares about the current volume.

The city's "system" for handling this is mostly a series of warnings. AP News reports that flooding of up to 2 feet is likely in low-lying areas. This is a request for the citizen to absorb the risk. The city asks you to "reconsider travel." It asks you to buy extra food. It does not tell you how it will keep the salt water out of the SFMTA light rail tunnels.

The myth of the temporary barrier

Some officials argue that we have the situation under control. In Marin County, Deputy Director of Emergency Management Quinn Gardner says they have "conducted extensive outreach." KCRA reports that the county installed flood barriers on public and private land. They want to "slow and minimize" the water. This is the strongest case for the status quo. It argues that temporary walls and warnings are a sufficient defense.

It is wrong. Earlier this year, similar tides submerged Marin County areas under 2 feet of water. They flooded homes and cars. A temporary wall is just a delay. You cannot "outreach" your way out of a rising ocean.

In Marin County, king tides are expected to reach up to 7.5 feet. In Humboldt Bay, tides could rise to 10 feet. These are not numbers that a few sandbags can fix. When the water hits those levels, the barriers do not protect the community. They just decide which street floods first.

Who pays for the surprise

The real load of this event will not be felt by the people writing the press releases. It will be felt by the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission. They will be the ones running the pumps. They will be the ones fighting salt-water intrusion on the Embarcadero. The city's infrastructure is a sieve.

The "unprecedented" label is a way to avoid the cost of permanent adaptation. If the tides are "unseen," the city cannot be blamed for not building better sea walls. It allows the municipal government to treat every flood as a new surprise. This keeps the budget for permanent fixes from ever being approved.

The cost is shifted to the people in the low-lying zones. They pay in ruined cars. They pay in moldy drywall. They pay in the stress of a Thanksgiving spent wondering if their street is a river. The city's emergency operations center is open, but the real work is missing.

The "unprecedented" label is a lie. The 1982–1983 El Niño gave us the map. Climate change gave us the volume. The SFMTA tunnels and Embarcadero will see salt-water intrusion because the city chose temporary barriers over permanent upgrades. San Francisco residents must stop listening to the surprise narrative and start demanding a budget for real sea walls.

Sources

  1. San Francisco Chronicle: Monster king tides are set to flood the Bay Area. Here are days and times they’ll be highest
  2. AP News: San Francisco braces for massive tides. Mayor urges residents to reconsider travel
  3. KCRA: California prepares for historic high tides during Thanksgiving week
  4. G1 Globo: Cidade nos EUA se prepara para marés gigantescas; prefeito pede que moradores estoquem comida e reconsiderem viagens