Record rain in Brevard County exposes a failure of planning

By Daniel Okafor · Reporting from New York ·

Record rain dropped 28 inches on Brevard County and broke a 70-year river record, forcing rescues and proving Florida cannot build stable cities on reclaimed swamps.

Central Florida is underwater because the state built cities on land that belongs to the water. WESH said that parts of Brevard County received 28 inches of rain. CBS News said the St. Johns River reached a new highest level over 18 feet, breaking a record set 70 years ago. This is not a surprise of nature. It is the result of a long-term decision to treat reclaimed swamps as stable real estate.

The cost of living in Zone A

The water does not care about property lines. Spectrum News 13 said that in the Glen Oaks neighborhood of New Smyrna Beach, Glen Circle road saw up to 4 feet of water. FEMA designates this area as Flood Zone A. This means there is a 26% chance of flooding over the life of a mortgage.

Lance Meeler lives here. He reported damage to his feed and equipment. He has 200 chickens in the back. They are completely underwater. He had to walk his horse and donkey out of the flood because the water was too deep.

Robert Spinning lives on a block that is entirely underwater. CBS News said he is worried to death. He does not have flood insurance. He cannot afford it.

Mel Rodriguez has lived in the neighborhood for 25 years. He believes nearby development to the southwest made the flooding worse. He noted a home has seen water intrusion three times in four years.

The state will argue that this rainfall was an anomaly. They will point to the sheer volume of water as an act of God. But the record shows the St. Johns River is one of the slowest-draining rivers in the county. The geography is the constant. The development is the variable.

A state in rescue mode

The government is now spending millions to fix what the land cannot handle. WESH said Governor Ron DeSantis deployed the Florida National Guard and Florida State Guard. He sent more than 200 Florida Highway Patrol troopers and 235 Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission officers.

FOX Weather said that state personnel conducted nearly 200 rescues. They deployed 20,000 sandbags. In Broward County, FWC responders rescued more than 90 residents from a flooded apartment complex. One officer transported an infant who had stopped breathing after the rescue vehicle became stuck in floodwaters.

Brevard County conducted more than 160 water rescues as of Friday night. The worst flooding hit Cocoa, Rockledge, and Merritt Island. In Palm Bay, floodwaters wiped away part of the Port Malabar Boulevard Bridge. This happened for the second time this month. A reopening ceremony for that same bridge was held on Monday.

The swamp always returns

The city of Palm Coast is a case study in this failure. WESH said Mayor Mike Norris declared a local state of emergency. Palm Coast was developed in 1969 over swamp and pine forest. It relies on 46 miles of freshwater canals and 23 saltwater canals to keep the land dry.

When the rain does not stop, the canals overflow. This is the same mechanism as the 2017 Texas floods. In both cases, slow-moving tropical systems dropped unprecedented rainfall that overwhelmed drainage systems and triggered thousands of water rescues.

The ground is now saturated. FOX Weather said November is the wettest on record for Melbourne. The city has seen over 17 inches of rain this month.

The result is always the same. The water goes where it used to be.

The St. Johns River is forecast to remain at record height through next Tuesday. This will isolate riverside communities and cut off secondary roads. Municipalities like Oviedo have already declared emergencies to secure FEMA reimbursement for sandbag operations.

The cost of this disaster will be measured in multi-million dollar recovery bills. These costs will strain municipal budgets long before federal money arrives. The St. Johns River will stay in major flood stage because the basin is too flat to drain. The city of Palm Coast will face prolonged strain because its 1969 design cannot handle 28 inches of rain. The state is not fighting a storm. It is fighting the map.

Sources

  1. WESH: More rain Saturday after days of flooding along Central Florida coast
  2. FOX Weather: River flooding threatens parts of Florida coast while torrential storms begin to ease after days of heavy rain
  3. Spectrum News 13: New Smyrna Beach neighborhood sees up to 4 feet of standing water
  4. CBS News: Record flooding in central Florida prompts hundreds of water rescues
  5. Asharq Al-Awsat: شمال شرقي فلوريدا يواجه خطر الفيضانات بعد عواصف اجتاحت مناطق ساحلية