Cincinnati Zoo failed Fiona by leaving a gap for a fatal hat

By Daniel Okafor · Reporting from New York ·

A visitor's hat flew into the Cincinnati Zoo habitat and killed Fiona the hippo, a tragedy caused by a preventable gap in the enclosure's design.

The Cincinnati Zoo is wrong. It claims the death of Fiona was a terrible accident, but the facts show a failure of security. A 2,400-pound animal died because the zoo left a gap in its wall. That gap allowed a visitor's hat to enter the habitat and become a lethal object. The zoo now focuses on the impossibility of the cure. It should focus on the possibility of the cause.

A ceiling fan and a gap

The hat did not walk into the enclosure. A visitor tossed a knit cap into the air, according to CNN. A ceiling fan caught the hat and flung it through a small opening. This opening sat above viewing windows. The hat landed in the habitat and Fiona swallowed it.

Michelle Curley, a spokesperson for the zoo, said the event was a fluke. She said the zoo probably could not make it happen again if they tried. This is the wrong metric for animal safety. A zoo does not secure its animals based on the odds of a fluke. It secures them against the reality of human behavior. People toss things and fans move air. Gaps let objects through.

The zoo knew Fiona was a symbol of resilience. In 2017, she proved she could survive the odds. She weighed only 29 pounds at birth. That weight was about half the previous lowest recorded birth weight for her species. The public rooted for her then, and they rooted for her again this month. But the zoo failed to protect the animal the world loved from a piece of wool.

Laparoscopic removal was impossible

Fiona swallowed the hat 11 days before she died. Her appetite declined a few days later. The zoo staff tried to encourage her to eat to push the hat through her system. When that failed, they turned to veterinary interventions.

The team used enemas and IV fluids. They borrowed a vibration table from a horse farm to shake the obstruction loose, according to KOB 4. Dr. Mike Wenninger, the zoo's director of animal health, used a scope and an ultrasound to find the hat. He found that upper and lower GI endoscopies could not reach the object.

A necropsy later revealed the exact location of the hat. The hat lay 25 feet beyond the final stomach compartment and 50 feet from the end of her intestines. Dr. Wenninger said the anatomy made laparoscopic removal impossible. He stated that open incision surgery would have been a death sentence for a hippo of her size. The zoo provided supportive care, but the hat remained lodged in the middle of her small intestine. Fiona died during recovery from her final procedure.

Was this a unique tragedy?

The zoo acts as if this event was a unique tragedy. It was not. The Cincinnati Zoo has a long record of animals swallowing things they should not. In 1923, a zoo animal named Zeekoe died at the same zoo after swallowing a tennis ball.

This is the Death of Zeekoe. It shares the exact same mechanism as Fiona's death: a zoo animal dies from an intestinal obstruction caused by swallowing a foreign object. The tennis ball of 1923 and the knit cap of 2026 are the same mistake. The only difference is the tool that delivered the object.

The zoo has a history of reacting to deaths rather than preventing them. The Death of Harambe in 2016 sparked a global debate over zoo safety and visitor interaction. That incident forced the zoo to upgrade barriers in Gorilla World. The zoo learned that humans will breach perimeters. It failed to learn that humans will toss objects.

Dave Jenike, the zoo director, said he was in shock. He said the zoo did not expect this outcome. Shock is a natural response to loss, but it is a poor excuse for a design flaw. The zoo's animal care team may have been heroic in the final days. But heroism in the clinic is no substitute for diligence in the habitat.

The facts of the necropsy prove that no amount of medical care could have saved Fiona. The hat was too deep. The animal was too large. The verdict is not found in the medical charts, but in the small opening in the wall. The zoo's "impossible" surgery was only necessary because the "impossible" accident was allowed to happen.

The Cincinnati Zoo will now likely install physical barriers around Hippo Cove to prevent visitors from tossing objects near the viewing glass. This is the only logical step. The zoo must stop treating the habitat as a secure box and start treating it as a place where a ceiling fan can kill a hippo. Until the gaps are closed, the zoo is not managing a sanctuary; it is managing a series of risks.

Sources

  1. BBC: Removal of hat inside Fiona the hippo was 'impossible', Cincinnati Zoo says
  2. WVXU: Beloved Cincinnati Zoo hippo Fiona has died
  3. KOB 4: Exam shows that the hat Fiona the hippo ate was deep in her small intestine
  4. WLWT: Post-mortem exam sheds new light on Fiona the hippo’s death
  5. CNN: Why surgery wasn’t an option to save Fiona the hippo