The ICJ held Myanmar guilty, but law must bind both sides

By Adele Rutherford · Reporting from Atlanta ·

By finding Myanmar guilty of genocide, the International Court of Justice set a rigorous legal standard that the international community must now be willing to enforce against its own allies.

The process of proof before the politics of reaction

We have lived too long in a theater of legal reactions where every observer reads the headline before cracking the spine of the slip opinion. The International Court of Justice delivered its judgment on Thursday, finding Myanmar responsible for genocide against its Rohingya minority. Before we applaud or condemn the outcome, we must inspect the architecture of the decision itself. Procedure is where power actually lives, and a rule that only works while your friends hold the gavel is not a rule at all.

The case brought by The Gambia centered on the 2017 military clearance operations in Rakhine State. According to the reporting of Al Jazeera, BBC, and The Guardian, the court determined that approximately 10,000 Rohingya were violently killed and more than 700,000 fled to Bangladesh. To reach a finding of state-backed genocide under the Genocide Convention, the judges required proof of specific intent by officials or arms of the state to destroy a substantial part of the group. President Yuji Iwasawa delivered the core holding: genocidal intent was the only reasonable inference that could be drawn from the evidence. That standard of review—the only reasonable inference—is the anvil on which this judgment was forged.

This is the first time an international court has found a state directly guilty of genocide. In earlier matters like Bosnia v. Serbia in 2007, the court found insufficient evidence to attribute mass actions directly to the state outside specific isolated theater commands. Here, the ICJ reviewed the record of indiscriminate killings, the execution of men, widespread sexual violence, extreme violence against children, and the deliberate burning of Rohingya homes. It cataloged an overlap between an anti-Rohingya hate speech campaign and the clearance operations. When a state systematically destroys evidence by burning bodies and bulldozing sites while maintaining discriminatory population policies, the inference of intent hardens into fact.

Dismantling the counter-terrorism defense

Every state accused of atrocity reaches for the same security blanket. Myanmar’s government representative Ko Ko Hlaing told the court in January that the country was not obliged to remain idle and allow terrorists to have free rein. The military crackdown was cast as a pure counterinsurgency response to coordinated attacks by the Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army on more than 30 police posts. This brings us directly to the mechanism shared with the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia. The judicial classification of localized ethnic cleansing as genocide requires dismantling counter-terrorism defenses put forward by state actors.

The ICJ did not ignore the initial militant attacks. It weighed them against the subsequent, disproportionate expanse of state violence. Antonia Mulvey of Legal Action Worldwide observed that the court rejected Myanmar's counter-terrorism defense outright. By establishing that rape and sexual violence constituted independent acts of genocide, the court pierced the sovereign veil. A high-threshold legal determination of genocidal intent rests on the systematic nature of the destruction, not the pretext offered by the uniform. If a state can launder mass displacement through the magic words of counter-terrorism, the Genocide Convention is mere parchment.

The dissent of six judges reminds us that this threshold remains fiercely contested. Yet the majority held that the pattern of state action left no other reasonable conclusion. The parallel to International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia is exact. Ad hoc and international tribunals must systematically dismantle the institutional alibis of sovereign states if international humanitarian law is to survive its own pretensions.

The enforcement gap and the shadow of Gaza

A court is only as strong as the machinery that compels obedience to its orders. As the reporting of BBC and DW notes, the International Court of Justice is not a criminal court and cannot send military officials to prison. It relies entirely on the UN Security Council and political pressure for enforcement. UK Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband moved swiftly, ordering the expulsion of Myanmar’s defense attaché and summoning its charge d'affaires. A cross-party group of MPs called for the resumption of sanctions, while UN human rights chief Volker Türk insisted the decision must translate into real action.

Yet we must test this tool against the day our opponents hold it. Human rights lawyer Philippe Sands KC told BBC Radio 4's World at One that the pending case of South Africa against Israel was the elephant in the room during the Myanmar hearings. If Myanmar had not been found responsible, the Israel case would in effect be over. Israel maintains that the case against it is wholly unfounded, just as Myanmar maintained its innocence. When we cheer an expansive ruling on state intent today, we must ask if we are prepared to accept that exact standard when applied to allies tomorrow. Legitimacy is a capital stock that spends fast and refills slowly.

The ICJ ordered Myanmar to pay proportionate reparations, facilitate safe and voluntary returns, and investigate individual wrongdoing. Whether the military junta complies is doubtful. But the formal legal reality has shifted. When refugees like Mohammed Nowkim speak of justice after decades of waiting, they are pointing to a permanent fracture in the state-sponsored lie.

The International Court of Justice has done its work by reading the record exact and declining the adjective where the holding will do. The international community must now decide whether a rule of law applies when the bailiff has no baton.

Sources

  1. BBC: Myanmar committed genocide against Rohingya minority, top UN court rules
  2. Al Jazeera: UN’s top court finds Myanmar guilty of genocide against Rohingya
  3. The Guardian: ‘Everyone struggled for this justice’: tears in court as Rohingya vindicated in Myanmar genocide ruling
  4. BBC: Myanmar committed genocide against Rohingya minority, top UN court rules
  5. MyJoyOnline: Myanmar committed genocide against Rohingya minority, top UN court rules
  6. DW: Myanmar committed genocide against Rohingya, top UN court rules