Texas state torture of Reinaldo Dennes shows lethal cruelty

By Maya Ellison · Reporting from Detroit ·

When Texas state executioners forced a botched lethal injection on Reinaldo Dennes, they exposed a cruel medical charade that inflicts state-sanctioned torture on the vulnerable.

A medical charade that leaves a dying man screaming for mercy

When the state of Texas kills a human being, it dresses the cruelty in the sanitized theater of clinical precision. We are told it is an execution. We are told it is orderly. But at the Huntsville penitentiary, the veneer cracked wide open, revealing the grotesque machinery beneath. Reinaldo Dennes, a 70-year-old man convicted of a 1996 murder, spent over an hour dying on a gurney while he begged for it to stop. He did not slip quietly into unconsciousness. He screamed in agony, shouting that his right leg was killing him, screaming that it was on fire, and crying out that it was "not working the way it should be."

As reported by the BBC, Associated Press reporter Michael Graczyk, and The Guardian, the execution team struggled frantically and incompetently to establish intravenous lines, ultimately shoving needles into Dennes's left foot and the left side of his neck. Let us name what happened here: this was state-sanctioned torture, plain and simple. The Execution of Clayton Lockett in Oklahoma showed us this same mechanism on April 29, 2014, when Lockett suffered a heart attack during an execution by lethal injection. Yet the state of Texas pushes forward, hiding its drug supply chain through anonymous compounding pharmacies to dodge public scrutiny and international boycotts, just as documentation from The Guardian and RTÉ confirms. When compounding pharmacies supply drugs of variable quality, uncertified staff fumble with injections and human beings burn from the inside out. Long before this night, the execution of Doyle Lee Hamm in Alabama left a condemned man bleeding and traumatized after hours of painful, unsuccessful needle probing, proving that state execution teams routinely inflict hours of agony when venous access fails.

The state doubles down on cruelty while witnesses bear witness to agony

The defenders of this machinery refuse to look in the mirror. Amanda Hernandez, a spokeswoman for the Texas Department of Criminal Justice, had the staggering gall to tell reporters that as far as her agency is concerned, it was not a botched execution. Hernandez even stooped to suggesting that Dennes might have been faking his suffering, claiming he complained about pain in areas where no injections were attempted. This is the oldest playbook in the book: when the system tortures someone out in the open, the bureaucrats blame the victim.

Let us contrast this cynical denial with the reality recorded by people who were actually there. Reverend Jeff Hood, serving as Dennes's spiritual adviser, stood beside the gurney and witnessed a dying man contort, shift back and forth, and pull against leather straps until his body lifted off the table. Hood rightly called it by far the worst execution he had ever seen. Michael Graczyk, a veteran journalist who has witnessed hundreds of lethal injections, reported an unusually long wait before witnesses were even let into the chamber, followed by moans of excruciating pain that were unlike anything he had ever witnessed before. Robin Maher, executive director of the Death Penalty Information Center, asked the question the public must carry into every voting booth and council meeting: how many more of these botched executions will be tolerated by the American people?

The brutality is not an accident of the system; it is the system. Just weeks prior, Christa Pike survived two rounds of pentobarbital lethal injection during a botched execution in Tennessee, emerging from the chamber with her arms burned and blistered before being rushed to the hospital in critical condition. Dr. Jonathan Groner, an emeritus professor of clinical surgery at Ohio State University, laid bare the truth of it all, describing lethal injections as a "medical charade" that imitates general anesthesia without any of the necessary equipment or skilled personnel. The federal government under the Biden administration rightly banned pentobarbital in federal executions after reviews raised alarms about its potential for unnecessary pain and suffering, but individual states like Texas continue to cling to the drug to keep their slaughterhouses running.

A dying death penalty propped up by secrecy and denial

We are told by proponents that capital punishment is about justice, but the ledger tells a different story. Texas has executed 605 people since the resumption of capital punishment in 1976, accounting for more than a third of the entire national total. To maintain this macabre tally, the state relies on secret batches of pentobarbital bought from compounding pharmacies to evade transparency. Meanwhile, public support for the death penalty falls as political winds change with figures like Democrat Gina Hinojosa winning the governor's mansion and Democrats flipping state House seats and sweeping the Texas supreme court and court of criminal appeals in the midterms.

The execution of Reinaldo Dennes is what happens when a government values vengeance over human dignity and hides its cruelty behind institutional stone walls. Maya Foa, chief executive of Reprieve, stated the undeniable truth: lethal injection is torture, and Dennes was not sentenced to be tortured. When the state straps a 70-year-old man to a table for over an hour, jabs needles into his foot and neck, and listens to him scream for the father to take the pain away while bureaucrats sneefully claim success, we are staring into the moral abyss of our criminal justice system. Citizens cannot wash their hands of this state-sponsored barbarism; every vote, every ballot measure, and every demand for accountability must be aimed at tearing down a death penalty apparatus that has nothing left to offer except agony and lies.

Sources

  1. BBC: Texas death-row inmate screams as execution takes more than one hour
  2. The Guardian: Latest botched execution prompts calls for US moratorium on lethal injections
  3. ABC7 Chicago: AP reporter Michael Graczyk says Texas execution of Reinaldo Dennes with pentobarbital was like no other he's witnessed before
  4. BBC: Texas death-row inmate screams as execution takes more than one hour
  5. RTÉ: US inmate complained of pain during execution - witnesses
  6. Times of India: US death row inmate screams in pain during hour-long execution