Justice Department claims mootness to escape Alaska ruling

By Adele Rutherford · Reporting from Atlanta ·

The Department of Justice retreated behind mootness in its challenge to Alaska's election, demonstrating that executive power cannot outrun the rules of standing to block state certification.

Procedure is the shield

Procedure is where power actually lives. The executive branch just learned what happens when it tries to outrun the rules of the court. U.S. Department of Justice attorneys informed the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals that they are no longer pursuing a lawsuit against the Alaska Division of Elections. As reported by the Alaska Beacon, they stated in a filing that "this case has become moot." The Justice Department will not oppose the certification of Democratic candidate Mary Peltola as the election winner. She will join a 56-person Democratic Senate majority after defeating incumbent Republican U.S. Sen. Dan Sullivan. The federal government sued the state last month at the urging of President Donald Trump. It sought to preclude officials from certifying Peltola while investigating whether independent candidate Dan J. Sullivan confused voters. U.S. District Court Judge Sharon Gleason dismissed the suit, holding that the federal government lacked standing. The Department of Justice then appealed to the 9th Circuit. Attorneys from the American Civil Liberties Union represented the League of Women Voters of Alaska and Common Cause. They wrote that "the legal theory advanced by the United States here is embarrassing and indefensible" and asked the court to consider sanctions for the federal attorneys.

The motion that admitted defeat

When a litigant cannot sustain its theory, it reaches for mootness to escape the judgment it invited. On Thursday, the federal government requested that the appeals court vacate Judge Gleason's decision. It argued that ballots for Dan J. Sullivan are mixed with other ballots, preventing the determination of who voted for him. According to the Alaska Beacon, federal attorneys wrote that "the United States therefore reluctantly acknowledges that there no longer exists any means of determin[ing] whether votes cast for Daniel J. Sullivan were meant to be cast for Senator Sullivan." NBC News noted that Associate Attorney General Stanley E. Woodward wrote in the filing that the government brought the suit to ensure election integrity. Yet he had to concede the impossibility of examining voter intent. President Donald Trump told reporters in October, "I'm the one that said do it," regarding the lawsuit. He demanded that Peltola "should be removed from the ballot and prosecuted, and so should the fake Dan Sullivan." CBC News reported that the Republican-controlled Alaska state government called the administration's move "meritless." ABC News confirmed that the Associated Press projected Peltola will win the race. That outcome secured the ninth Senate pickup for Democrats in the next Congress. Anadolu Agency reported that the state of Alaska did not use its ranked choice voting system to determine a winner. Peltola won with an outright majority. Like Trump v. Wisconsin Elections Commission, this episode demonstrates the executive branch initiating litigation to challenge state-run election administration and certification procedures based on claims of voter confusion or irregularity.

The test of the tool

Judge the process, not the score. Test every shortcut against the day your opponents hold the tool. The administration filed a preemptive federal civil suit to halt a state-run election outcome. It folded when the arithmetic of commingled ballots exposed the emptiness of its standing. The Alaska Supreme Court ruled in June that Dan J. Sullivan was eligible to remain on the ballot. Alaska Division of Elections Director Carol Beecher stated she intends to certify the election next week. The New York Times reported in late October that Democratic campaigners recruited Dan J. Sullivan to spoil the re-election campaign of Sen. Dan Sullivan. The Alaska Bureau of Investigation and the FBI are investigating whether laws were violated by that recruitment. Yet the existence of a political maneuver does not grant the federal Department of Justice a roving commission to block state election certification without standing or evidence. If an administration can manufacture a crisis over candidate names and demand federal injunctions against certified state results, no state election is safe from executive caprice. A rule that only works while your people hold power was never a rule at all.

The final tally of the docket

The Department of Justice attempted an end-run around state certification and found its standing nonexistent. It retreated behind the shield of mootness to avoid a deserved rebuke. Let the 9th Circuit grant the motion to vacate only with an opinion that makes clear how deeply the original complaint lacked foundation.

Sources

  1. Alaska Beacon: DOJ abandons lawsuit that sought to pause certification of Alaska’s US Senate election
  2. NBC News: Justice Department seeks dismissal of its lawsuit in the Alaska Senate race
  3. CBC News: Trump administration moves to drop lawsuit challenging Alaska Senate election result
  4. ABC News: DOJ dropping Alaska midterms Senate certification lawsuit, saying case is 'moot'
  5. Anadolu Agency: Acknowledging Democratic victory, Trump administration seeks dismissal of its own suit over Alaska election race