Cincinnati Zoo killed Fiona by leaving a gap in her habitat

By Daniel Okafor · Reporting from New York ·

Fiona the hippo died after swallowing a visitor's hat that entered her habitat through a design flaw, proving the Cincinnati Zoo prioritized accessibility over animal safety.

The Cincinnati Zoo is wrong. It failed its most famous resident by leaving a hole in her home. A child's knitted hat should not be a death sentence for a 2,500lb animal. The zoo calls this accident a fluke. But a gap in a habitat is a design choice.

A one-foot gap in the defense

The death began with a visitor who tossed a hat into the air. The Guardian reported that the hat bounced off a ceiling fan. It then fell into the enclosure. WLWT reported that the hat was catapulted through a one-foot gap into the habitat. This gap allowed a foreign object to enter a space where a hippo lives.

Fiona ate the hat. At first, she showed no symptoms. Days later, she lost her appetite. The zoo staff increased her food intake to help the object pass. They monitored her hydration. They offered her a sniff of coffee because she liked the scent. But the hat stayed in her system.

Surgery was not an option

The zoo turned the situation into a medical emergency. On Tuesday, staff sedated Fiona for evaluation. An ultrasound showed her intestines bunching as they tried to push the hat through. The zoo used a 9-foot scope to perform a colonoscopy. The scope did not reach the hat.

On Wednesday, the animal care team used a vibration plate from a horse farm. They hoped the vibrations would encourage the hat to move through her digestive tract. Fiona stood on the platform several times. The zoo consulted human and veterinary specialists. They concluded that surgery was not an option for full-grown hippos. Fiona remained off-exhibit while staff provided fluids, medication, and blood work. She died on Thursday. Dave Jenike, the director of the Cincinnati Zoo, said the medical emergency was "too much to overcome."

The cost of a celebrity

Fiona was more than an animal. She was an economic engine. The Birth of Fiona the hippo in 2017 established her as a symbol of perseverance. She was born six weeks premature. She weighed 29 pounds at birth, less than the lowest recorded birth weight for her species.

Zoo staff and nurses from Cincinnati Children’s Hospital hand-milked her mother because Fiona was too weak to nurse. The world watched. The city built a brand around her. A local brewery created a special beer. Cincy Shirts sold T-shirts to raise money for the zoo. Visitors traveled to Ohio to see her. She inspired books and a mural in downtown Cincinnati. The zoo treated her like a star, but housed her in a flawed enclosure.

Was this a fluke?

The zoo claims this event was an accident they could not repeat. This is the language of a PR department, not a safety audit. The Death of a polar bear at a German zoo shares the same mechanism as this tragedy: a captive animal dies after ingesting a foreign object from a visitor. In 2014, that bear died after swallowing a visitor's jacket. These are not flukes. They are the result of placing wild animals in proximity to humans without absolute barriers.

The Cincinnati Zoo has a record of reacting only after a tragedy. The Shooting of Harambe in 2016 sparked global reaction. After that gorilla was killed to save a boy, the zoo built reinforced barriers around the gorilla yard. They learned that a breach of the perimeter is a failure of the institution. They failed to apply that lesson to the hippo habitat.

The Cincinnati Zoo will likely erect permanent barriers around the hippopotamus enclosure within the next three to six months. They will use the same logic they used after the death of Harambe. They will fix the gap because the public is watching. But the zoo waited for a death to find the hole in the fence. They traded the safety of a 9-year-old hippo for the convenience of a viewing gap. Fiona survived a miracle birth only to die from a child's hat. The zoo's negligence killed her.

Sources

  1. The Guardian: Fiona the hippo dies after ingesting knitted hat at Cincinnati zoo
  2. WLWT: Fiona, famed Cincinnati Zoo hippo, dies after swallowing child’s hat
  3. CNN: Globally adored hippo Fiona dies after eating a visitor’s hat at Cincinnati Zoo
  4. WVXU: Cincinnati Zoo continues to monitor Fiona the hippo's health
  5. BBC: Fiona the hippo dies after swallowing a hat at Cincinnati Zoo
  6. ABC News: Fiona the hippo dies at Cincinnati Zoo after swallowing hat