Cornyn was right to block Trump's nominee with the blue slip

By Adele Rutherford · Reporting from Atlanta ·

Senator John Cornyn rightly withheld his blue slip for T. Elliot Gaiser, proving that procedural rules must stand even when party loyalists demand a hasty lifetime appointment.

Procedure is the only armor we have left against raw will

Procedure is where power actually lives. When the executive forgets that truth, the system breaks down into a contest of raw will. President Donald Trump nominated T. Elliot Gaiser to a lifetime seat on the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas. Gaiser is an Ohio native and the assistant attorney general for the Office of Legal Counsel. His only tie to the Lone Star State is a one-year clerkship in Houston. He has no trial experience. He has never tried a case in the district where he seeks a lifetime appointment. Senator John Cornyn did what any self-respecting process person should do. He withheld the blue slip, the Senate custom allowing home-state lawmakers to block unvetted judicial nominees. Cornyn told CNN he refuses to be jammed by a non-Texan. As reported by CBS News, Cornyn stated that the Senate is not supposed to be a rubber stamp. He added that the White House made no attempt to consult.

That is the system working as intended. The blue slip is not a courtesy; it is the constitutional brake on executive overreach. The tension between executive desire for rapid judicial filling and Senate procedural norms defines the administrative state. This mirrors the broader debates surrounding judicial nominations under Donald Trump. We saw this same friction during the judicial nominations of the 115th Congress. We saw it during the nomination of Neil Gorsuch. The White House wanted a loyalist on the Dallas bench before the Senate majority shifted. They bypassed consultation. Cornyn stopped them cold.

A shouting match on the floor reveals the rot beneath the party

The strongest opposing case comes from Senator Ted Cruz. Cruz argued on the Senate floor that blocking Gaiser hands the seat to Democrats who will keep it vacant in perpetuity. He warned that the people of Texas will pay the price. That argument has superficial appeal to partisans who view the courts as mere spoils of war. But it fails on the merits of institutional design. A lifetime appointment given to an unvetted operative with zero trial experience is worse than a vacancy. It permanently degrades the judiciary.

The dispute boiled over into public view when Cornyn and Cruz engaged in a verbal altercation on the Senate floor. According to The New Republic, Cornyn told Cruz, “I don’t find you credible. I’m mad at you!” and called his position bullshit. Axiom Strategies, a political consulting firm associated with Cruz, previously assisted Ken Paxton in defeating Cornyn in the Texas Senate Republican primary. The personal bitterness runs deep. But personal animus does not make Cornyn wrong on the law.

Senator Richard Blumenthal and Senator Cory Booker used the Judiciary Committee hearings on Wednesday to question nominees about the January 6 attack. Blumenthal called it a sad day when nominees ducked the question. Booker denounced the proceedings as a cynical effort at short-term political gain. Both Democrats are right about the degradation of the confirmation process. Yet Democrats spent decades eroding these exact norms when it suited their own policy ends. Executive branches of both parties will always attempt to bypass local vetting when they hold the machinery. To differ this time, we would have to pretend that executive appetite for control is a new phenomenon. It is not. It is the oldest temptation in Washington.

The nominee's record shows why the blue slip remains vital

T. Elliot Gaiser is not just any outsider. He is a partisan architect of aggressive executive power. As head of the Office of Legal Counsel, Gaiser authored a memorandum opinion providing justification for U.S. military strikes on alleged drug-smuggling boats. He concluded that the Presidential Records Act is unconstitutional. He issued an opinion declaring that presidential communications with private outside advisers are covered by executive privilege. He worked as legal counsel for Donald Trump's 2020 presidential campaign. In that role, he assisted with post-election litigation and produced a speech rejecting the election results. That speech floated the theory that Vice President Mike Pence could refuse to recognize electors.

This is the man the administration tried to slide onto a district court without proper vetting by local counsel. Senator Chuck Grassley, chair of the Senate Judiciary Committee, has maintained the blue-slip tradition for district court and U.S. attorney nominations. He did so despite immense pressure from the White House to abolish it. Grassley deserves credit for holding the line. A rule that only works while your people hold power was never a rule. If Republicans abolish the blue slip today to seat Gaiser, a future Democratic Senate will use that exact precedent. They will pack every district court from coast to coast. Cornyn understands that a lifetime appointment demands local knowledge, trial competence, and actual consultation.

John Cornyn was entirely right to withhold his blue slip, and the Senate must let this nomination die.

Sources

  1. CNN: Sen. Cornyn blocks judicial nominee because Trump didn’t choose Texas
  2. CBS News: Cornyn blocks Trump's nomination of top DOJ official to federal district court in Texas
  3. The New Republic: “That’s Bullsh*t”: John Cornyn and Ted Cruz Get Into Shouting Match