Storm Brings Torrential Rain and Floods to the San Francisco Bay Area
By Imani Sutton · Reporting from Atlanta ·
When the rain starts falling in the Bay Area, Pacific Gas & Electric (PG&E) reaches for the same script. They call it "adverse weather." They blame the trees. They act as if a storm is a surprise and not a predictable stress test. But when 14,311 customers are sitting in the dark on a Wednesday evening, the problem isn't the rain.
When the rain starts falling in the Bay Area, Pacific Gas & Electric (PG&E) reaches for the same script. They call it "adverse weather." They blame the trees. They act as if a storm is a surprise and not a predictable stress test. But when 14,311 customers are sitting in the dark on a Wednesday evening, the problem isn't the rain. The problem is a utility that treats a brittle grid as an acceptable cost of doing business.
The "adverse weather" script
According to SFGATE, power outages peaked at 18,000 customers on Wednesday morning. By evening, 14,311 people were still without power. The East Bay took the hardest hit. SFGATE reports 11,731 customers there were left in the dark.
PG&E spokesperson Megan McFarland said "adverse weather can result in trees, limbs and other debris falling into powerlines." This is the corporate version of "it just happened." It ignores the fact that the company knows exactly where the trees are. It ignores the failure to harden the lines before the first drop fell.
We have seen this play before. This isn't a weather event. It is a maintenance event. ABC7 Bay Area reports that over 16,000 customers were without power. The company is not fighting a storm. It is fighting its own ledger.
Robotaxis and sewage geysers
While the grid failed, the "smart city" failed too. The Guardian reports that San Francisco saw 2.28 inches of rain. This broke the record previously set in 1918. The city's infrastructure did not just leak. It collapsed.
The Guardian describes "sewage geysers" in the Ocean Beach neighborhood. One geyser stood 15 feet tall. In the middle of this, Waymo paused its service. A self-driving vehicle stalled in flooded streets and blocked traffic.
Waymo is owned by Alphabet Inc. Alphabet Inc. finances these autonomous experiments through massive cash reserves. They can afford to let a car stall in a puddle. The people in the Oakland Hills, where 3,625 customers lost power, cannot afford a grid that quits during a rainstorm. There is a cruel irony in a city that can deploy robotaxis but cannot stop its sewers from erupting or its lights from going out.
The Texas blueprint
This is not an isolated failure. It is a mechanism. The Texas power outages of February 2021 shared the exact same mechanism as this storm. In both cases, severe weather events exposed the fragility of energy infrastructure. Both showed a failure of utility companies to harden the grid against predictable environmental stressors.
The pattern is clear. The company under-invests in the physical load. The storm hits. The grid breaks. The company then uses the disaster to justify more spending.
The bill always goes to the renter
PG&E Corporation manages these outages as standard operating expenses. They factor storm repairs into their baseline costs. But those costs do not stay with the shareholders.
The hypothesis is simple. Within 90 days, PG&E will likely file for a rate-base adjustment. They will ask the California Public Utilities Commission to let them recover these storm-response costs from the ratepayers. They will bill the people who sat in the dark for the privilege of having a brittle grid.
The people of the Bay Area are paying twice. They pay for the "weather hardening" that didn't work. Then they pay for the repairs after the lines fall. The only thing that is actually "smart" about this system is how it shifts the cost of corporate neglect onto the people who can least afford it.