Xi greets Trump in Shenzhen to frame a great-power bargain
By Tom Beckwith · Reporting from Washington ·
Xi Jinping met Donald Trump on the Shenzhen tarmac to signal a trilateral bargain that risks codifying spheres of influence at the expense of European security.
The mechanics of protocol and the weight of a tarmac greeting
Diplomacy relies on signals between leaders who understand the price of every word. Chinese leader Xi Jinping greeted US President Donald Trump on the tarmac at Shenzhen Bao'an International Airport, according to CNN and the BBC. In doing so, he broke a strict rule of contemporary Chinese protocol. Vice presidents or top diplomats traditionally meet visiting state guests. Han Zheng met Trump during his May visit to Beijing. Cai Qi, Xi’s chief of staff, met Russian President Vladimir Putin. Xi had not greeted a visiting US president at the airport since welcoming Barack Obama in 2009. Xi served as vice-president during that state visit, establishing an early precedent for personal receptions. Nations have interests, not friendships. A leader of Xi’s standing does not stand in the Shenzhen heat for mere theater.
The immediate interests driving this reception rest in geography and timing. Shenzhen is a city of 18 million people. It houses tech giants like Huawei, BYD, Tencent, and DJI, boasting more skyscrapers than New York City. The city served as the engine for Deng Xiaoping’s 1980s free-market experiments. Against a backdrop of strict traffic controls, school closures, and public transport subsidies, the APEC Economic Leaders Summit opened. Xi told business executives that Asia-Pacific economies show "openness, synergy, and spillover effects." He warned that "growth lacks momentum and unilateralism and protectionism are rampant," as reported by The Guardian. Beijing seeks to project stability to global trade. Its trade truce with Washington expires in January. Meanwhile, new US export restrictions on advanced chips in Brazil, Thailand, and Malaysia strain supply chains. This pressure echoes the US-China trade war that began in 2018 when the first Trump administration levied tariffs on Beijing.
The capability to alter the board lies in the upcoming trilateral meeting between Washington, Beijing, and Moscow. US Secretary of State Marco Rubio defended the engagement. He noted that Trump "has never viewed meeting and talking to someone as a concession." Rubio asked, "How are you going to solve problems with people you have disagreements with if you don't speak to them?" Yet those outside the room will bear the five-year cost of this maneuver. Ukrainian Foreign Minister Andriy Sybiga warned that a meeting of US, Chinese, and Russian leaders will "only encourage Putin to continue this war." Putin arrived in Shenzhen after a two-hour bilateral talk with Xi. There, relations were described as "unshaken by storms and steady as a mountain." Putin told the summit that traditional tools of economic dominance have lost their intimidating power. The alignment between Beijing and Moscow solidifies a parallel economic and security architecture. This structure blunts Western sanctions and diplomatic isolation for the Kremlin, mirroring realignments seen in the Russia-Ukraine War since 2022.
The shadow of history and the mechanics of the Yalta Conference
The parallel to this moment is the Yalta Conference of February 1945. Franklin D. Roosevelt, Winston Churchill, and Joseph Stalin gathered in Crimea to carve out postwar zones of occupation and spheres of influence in Europe, largely ignoring local sovereign claims. The shared mechanism is precise. Great powers gather at a geographic periphery to carve up spheres of influence and manage global security over the protests of smaller states. Today’s capitals face structural fatigue. Washington under Trump seeks transactional exits from peripheral security commitments. Moscow aims to institutionalize its territorial gains. Beijing desires a recognized great-power management system that excludes middle powers. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy explicitly warned against holding another Yalta with a redistribution of influence.
The strongest opposing case views this summit as procedural pageantry. Beijing and Washington remain locked in a bitter technological Cold War over artificial intelligence and semiconductor supply chains. Advocates of this view point to recent moves. The US administration introduced strict export rules on AI chips in Southeast Asia. China restricted rare earth exports. Meanwhile, Taiwan remains a founding member of APEC, with President William Lai insisting on participation on an "equal basis." Critics contend that deep structural divergences make a grand bargain impossible.
This objection misreads transactional diplomacy. Trade wars and chip controls form the baseline friction, yet both superpowers find domestic utility in managed deals. Trump arrived in Shenzhen after visiting Manila. There, he met Philippine President Ferdinand Marcos Jr., approved $5 billion in arms sales, and touted trade measures for farmers and energy. Yet in trilateral talks, including Putin alongside Xi and Trump elevates Russia's standing. It shifts discussion toward a broader great-power bargain over European security. This trilateral framework will likely produce a non-binding declaration on strategic stability. Such a statement codifies a de facto sphere of influence, sidelining European and Ukrainian interests just as Yalta did eight decades ago.
The cost of theater and the verdict on great-power management
The record of great-power summits predicts a divergence between optimistic communiques and ground realities. For this time to differ, foundational security interests would need to converge. That would require alignment between a declining revisionist state, an autocracy seeking technological dominance, and a superpower eager to offload entanglements. Nothing in the records of Ukraine, artificial intelligence, or the South China Sea suggests such convergence. Instead, leaders like Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney and Brazilian President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva urge caution against abandoning multilateral rules. Smaller European and Asian nations watch nervously from the periphery.
Professionals in the room know that trading security concerns for short-term trade truces is an illusion bought on credit. Trump said he "may meet" with North Korean leader Kim Jong Un if he travels to China. This adds improvisational diplomacy to a summit heavy with history. Secretary of State Marco Rubio insists that engagement solves problems. Yet engagement without leverage is merely capitulation dressed as pragmatism. The cost of this theater comes due when international law is dismantled to accommodate men who view borders as temporary suggestions.
Beijing secured its primary objective. It demonstrated that neither domestic midterm elections nor global espionage scandals surrounding firms like Nvidia have shaken its status as an equal architect of global order. Xi and Putin have institutionalized their authoritarian axis through regularized coordination. They present a united front against what they term unilateralism and protectionism. By greeting Donald Trump on the tarmac, Xi offered no gesture of friendship. He claimed a seat at the head of a reorganized world.
Sources
- CNN: APEC summit latest: Xi breaks precedent by meeting Trump on arrival in China
- BBC: China's Xi JInping greets Donald Trump at airport in rare move ahead of trilateral talks with Putin
- The Guardian: Apec summit live: Xi welcomes Trump on China visit as Putin claims Europe in ‘humiliating decline’ in speech
- CNA: Trump arrives in China ahead of trilateral summit with Xi, Putin
- franceinfo: Xi Jinping accueille Donald Trump à son arrivée en Chine avant un sommet tripartite inédit avec Vladimir Poutine pour évoquer les crises internationales
- France 24: Trump arrives in China ahead of historic three-way summit with Putin, Xi