Mary Peltola wins Alaska as the "rigged" claim fails the data

By Adele Rutherford · Reporting from Atlanta ·

Mary Peltola expanded her lead in the Alaska Senate race despite claims of voter confusion, proving that ranked-choice voting protects the process from the "spoiler" tactics both sides employ.

The assertion by Donald Trump that the Alaska Senate race was "rigged" lacks a basis in the reported data. He claims on Truth Social that a second candidate named Dan Sullivan confused the voters. He characterizes Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. as the "fake Dan Sullivan." The data does not support this conclusion. The process did not fail. The Republican side failed to understand the tool they use to contest the result.

The mechanics of the mistake

Alaska employs ranked-choice voting. This system allows voters to rank up to five candidates. If no candidate receives a majority, the last-place candidate is eliminated. Officials reallocate those ballots to the voters' next choices. This process continues until one person clears the 50% threshold.

The Anchorage Daily News reports Mary Peltola reached 49.98% of first-choice votes. A candidate wins outright by staying above 50%. This bypasses the redistribution of second-choice votes.

The "rigged" narrative assumes voters accidentally chose the wrong Sullivan. The system is designed for this exact risk. Richard Pildes noted unsure voters could rank both Sullivans first and second. The mechanism absorbs the error. Calling this "rigged" confuses a tactical nuisance with a systemic failure. This mirrors the 2020 United States presidential election and its "rigged" allegations.

The spoiler's price

The presence of Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. and Gerald Heikes was intentional. The New York Times reported Democratic operatives tried to recruit "spoiler" candidates. This is a gamble on voter ignorance. This strategy treats the ballot as a puzzle to be manipulated.

The record shows this is not a one-sided game. The group Right for Alaska spent $1.2 million promoting Gerald Heikes. The goal was to draw support away from Dan S. Sullivan. This mechanism appeared in the 1968 United States presidential election. In that race, George Wallace acted as a spoiler.

This recurred in the 2016 United States presidential election. Third-party candidates siphoned votes in a tight race. Recruiting a "spoiler" bets the voter will not rank a second choice. They are betting on a failure of the citizen.

The evidence of intent

Data from BBC Verify shows the "confusion" did not help the incumbent. Only 15% of Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. voters ranked the incumbent second. Meanwhile, 29% ranked Mary Peltola second. Another 38% recorded no valid second choice.

The "fake Sullivan" did not steal votes from the incumbent. He drew voters who preferred Peltola or no one. This varies the 2004 United States presidential election strategy of similar names.

The legal record is clear. Ruth Greenwood noted no law prevents people with the same name from running. Alaska used its regulations to list the candidates clearly. Ballots listed "Sullivan, Daniel J. Jr." and "Sullivan, Dan S. (Registered Republican) Incumbent."

The fallout is moving into the courts. Gerald Heikes reported receiving a federal grand jury subpoena from the FBI. This suggests the federal government is investigating candidate coordination.

The process worked. The voters had the tools to avoid confusion. The candidates tried to use the rules to trick the voters. The incumbent lost because his lead was too small for the field.

The result is a victory, but the method is a warning. Treating the ballot as a "scheme" spends the legitimacy of the office. The "rigged" claim is fiction, but recruiting spoilers erodes trust. The FBI inquiry suggests a line regarding illegal coordination was crossed. If courts find illegal coordination, the "rigged" label may find a home.

Sources

  1. BBC: Trump says Alaska voters chose the wrong Dan Sullivan. What does the data show?
  2. Anchorage Daily News: Peltola grows lead further in Alaska’s U.S. Senate race as ballot counting continues
  3. BBC: Trump says Alaska voters chose the wrong Dan Sullivan. What does the data show?