Trump's Shenzhen summit is a photo op for Xi and Putin's gain

By Tom Beckwith · Reporting from Washington ·

Donald Trump will meet Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin in Shenzhen to reassert his authority, but the summit is merely a stage for authoritarian optics over real policy.

President Donald Trump believes a plane ride to Shenzhen can erase a midterm defeat. He is wrong. By agreeing to a trilateral summit with Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin, Trump is not reasserting his authority. He is providing his rivals with a stage to project strength while he seeks a narrative shift. The White House's belief that China should "step up to the adult table" is a delusion of grandeur. In reality, Xi is the one setting the table, choosing the menu, and deciding who gets to eat.

The theater of the adult table

The interests in Shenzhen are mismatched. Trump wants to project the image of a global arbiter. He intends to open discussions on nuclear weapons and raise the U.S.-Israeli war against Iran. His capability is limited to the pomp of the presidency. As CNN reports, this trip is a way to remind observers that the presidency is his bailiwick.

Xi Jinping's interest is status. He wants to showcase a rising China without making commitments. He is the host, and that capability is everything. The 2023 Xi Jinping visit to Russia showed how Beijing and Moscow manage their unequal partnership to project a united front. This diplomatic theater cements their standing at the top table.

Vladimir Putin's interest is the exit from Ukraine. He proposed the summit to negotiate an end to the conflict. He has the capability of the initiator. He has already met with U.S. envoys Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff in Moscow. He told them that Europe should "figure out" whether "they want peace or war."

A collision of divergent agendas

The capabilities of these leaders do not align with their stated goals. Trump wants nuclear reduction. However, the US and Russia each possess an estimated 5,000 nuclear warheads. China has built an arsenal of more than 600 nuclear warheads. According to CNBC, China has no interest in disarmament talks until it achieves parity with the U.S. in about 10 years.

The agendas are further split on Ukraine. Putin wants a settlement. Trump’s aides state that Ukraine will not be on the agenda. This gap is a feature, not a bug. The G20 Osaka Summit saw leaders manage a fragile trade truce on the sidelines of a major forum. It proved that such meetings contain frictions without delivering structural breakthroughs.

Xi is playing the long game. He has met with Putin more than 40 times since becoming president in 2013. He has met with Trump three times since October last year. He knows how to manage both.

The high cost of symbolic diplomacy

This summit is a study in atmospherics. Trump is accompanied by Elon Musk, who spent $445 million in political spending. This is a domestic entourage for a foreign trip. Trump is on a trip to Asia. He is trying to ignore a scandal involving AI chips and a suspected Chinese spy in the very city where he will meet Xi.

The Singapore Summit prioritized the symbolic optics of an unprecedented first-meeting over concrete policy breakthroughs. It yielded a photo op but little lasting change. Shenzhen is the same play. The Moscow Times notes that China's Foreign Ministry calls the meeting of "groundbreaking significance." This is the language of propaganda, not diplomacy.

History warns us about this pattern. Authoritarian capitals utilize high-level diplomatic summits for domestic propaganda when facing an American president burdened by domestic political vulnerabilities. The July 1974 Moscow summit followed this exact script. Soviet leaders focused on atmospherics to project stability while the U.S. president struggled with his own right flank.

The Shenzhen trilateral summit will conclude without any formal joint statement or concrete agreement on nuclear non-proliferation or the war in Ukraine, producing only carefully stage-managed photo opportunities. Trump will return home with a set of photos. Xi and Putin will return to their capitals with the knowledge that the American president is more interested in the appearance of power than the exercise of it.

Sources

  1. Egypt Independent: How Trump is hoping to use an Asia trip to reassert his authority
  2. CNBC: China confirms Xi-Trump-Putin historic summit. What will be on the agenda?
  3. CNN: How Trump is hoping to use an Asia trip to reassert his authority
  4. The Moscow Times: China Says Xi-Putin-Trump Meeting Has 'Groundbreaking Significance'