Judge Reyes rightly holds Trump to procedure at East Potomac
By Adele Rutherford · Reporting from Atlanta ·
Judge Reyes properly halted the closure of East Potomac Golf Links, establishing that executive directives require a formal administrative record rather than social media declarations.
A historic municipal property falls silent under a federal order
The tee boxes were empty on Monday morning, the greens were bare, and no golfers were in sight on the 124-year-old property. East Potomac Golf Links sat technically open under a federal judge’s order, yet the clubhouse was locked and golf carts were stowed away. This quiet followed a weekend where the National Links Trust lease was terminated and the Trump administration moved to close the park. WTOP News reported that demonstrators gathered Sunday near Hains Point with signs reading “Hands off Hains Point,” “Not Another Vanity Project,” and “Keep Hains Point For The People.” Chip Taylor, a D.C. resident, told WTOP News he is “concerned that it will just be temporary.” Carolyn Eliza, daughter of Chip Taylor, said, “They’re destroying our property, and we have a slogan: ‘Keep hands off.’” Kalli Krumpos of the Washington Area Bicyclist Association stated, “We have 14 more days that the public will be able to continue to access East Potomac Park. However, there’s still a lot more that is at risk.” The legal mechanism that brought this quiet was a temporary restraining order issued by U.S. District Judge Ana Reyes, delaying redevelopment for two weeks. NPR reported that President Donald Trump called the order a “highly destructive and political decision” and stated on social media that his administration would “immediately appeal, on an expedited basis.” RTÉ noted the course is a public amenity with affordable rates, while President Trump wrote on Truth Social that “The judge has absolutely no right to hold up this very important and beautiful Project.”
Procedure is where power actually lives in disputes over public lands
The strongest opposing case for the administration rests on the undeniable physical decay of the municipal asset. The National Park Service condition assessment recorded 110 deficiencies at East Potomac Golf Course, with 69 rated Critical or Urgent. The inspection noted that the driving range building and a leaning retaining wall presented severe fall, collapse, and injury hazards. In addition, the East Potomac Park seawall was documented as severely deteriorated, flooding more than thirty times per year. Through its Federal Register filings, the administration argues that the unfenced, open landscape cannot be safely managed without an authorized operator. It asserts that immediate closure is a public safety necessity rather than an arbitrary political maneuver. This is the exact mechanism shared with the Trump administration's efforts to limit access to National Monuments, where executive policy shifted to rescind established regulations through administrative decisions. But this defense of executive authority collapses when tested against the administrative record required by law. As Judge Reyes noted, President Trump's social media posts indicated the redevelopment plan was final. The National Park Service then moved to close the park to implement it. If an executive can bypass statutory review simply by declaring a project final on a digital platform, procedure is dead. Any future administration could then seize any municipal asset overnight. A rule that only works while your people hold power was never a rule.
The courts must hold executive power to the written record
The DC Preservation League and local golfers initiated a legal challenge, arguing the plan would change the character of the accessible course and make it unaffordable. The plaintiffs trace their organizational lineage to the 1971 grassroots battle against the demolition of the Old Post Office building, establishing an institutional playbook for fighting federal development in the District. When the administration commits $20 million to $49 million in federal contracts without notifying Congress, it invites the exact kind of judicial scrutiny that Judge Reyes applied. The rule of law requires that safety justifications in condition assessments be processed through proper administrative channels. They cannot be invoked post-hoc to justify decisions already announced on social media. If the D.C. Circuit dissolves this temporary restraining order on appeal, it must do so on the strength of the agency's formal record, not the president's impatience.
The judiciary must sustain the temporary restraining order and require the administration to submit its redevelopment plans to proper statutory review. An executive shortcut that bypasses public notice today becomes the weapon your opponents use to dismantle your own priorities tomorrow.
Sources
- The Washington Post: After one last Sunday, a beloved D.C. golf course is closed. For now.
- WTOP News: Demonstrators opposed to Trump’s East Potomac Links redesign cautiously celebrate judge’s restraining order
- NPR: Trump blasts judge for halting his Washington golf project and says he will appeal
- RTÉ: Judge blocks Trump plan to close park for golf project