Pope Leo brings prayers to Peru when stolen lands demand repair

By Alma Cordero · Reporting from El Paso ·

As Pope Leo XIV returns to Peru to lament rural poverty, apologies cannot replace the material restitution and land rights that justice demands.

The bishop who came home to a ghost town

Pope Leo XIV stepped out of a helicopter onto the dusty ground of Santa Cruz de Succhabamba. He was not visiting a foreign country. As bishop of the Diocese of Chiclayo, Robert Francis Prevost walked these northern Peruvian tracks. About 6,000 people live in Santa Cruz de Succhabamba, an isolated Andean village in Cajamarca. The Vatican reports that a crowd of about 20,000 gathered to see him. These citizens know what it means to be left behind.

Reporting by the BBC and The Washington Post traces the pageantry of his tour through Argentina, Uruguay, and Peru. Yet gold vestments and the popemobile cannot hide the ledger of what was done to this land. At an outdoor Mass, the Pope spoke of "declining birth rates that are emptying villages" and unequal resource distribution. He was describing a catastrophe manufactured by policy. Official data shows the Cajamarca region suffers the highest poverty in Peru. Cajamarca has lost the most people to internal migration, with 729,000 born there now living elsewhere in Peru.

From Zaña to Chiclayo, the debt remains unpaid

The mechanism here is the same one that wrote Inter caetera. In that 1493 papal bull, Pope Alexander VI granted lands to foreign crowns. The institutional legitimization of colonial conquest by the Church created systemic poverty and displacement. The current Pope must now apologize for that legacy. In the Lambayeque region, the Pope traveled to Zaña. He denounced the "suffering and humiliation" endured by African enslaved people. He acknowledged a debt the Vatican accumulated over five centuries.

His encyclical, Magnificent Humanity, asks pardon for past popes who authorized sovereigns to conquer lands and enslave non-Christians. Apologists argue that a pontiff born in Chicago has severed the chain of complicity. They claim the Vatican transformed from an imperial power into a moral referee of global inequality. That defense is a lie built on silence. The plunder authorized centuries ago mutated into mining concessions, land grants, and rural neglect. Those policies empty Cajamarca today while local officials scramble to cash in on tourism.

Down in Zaña, a former colonial sugar center built by slave labor, history carries a heavy cost. Susana Baca, the three-time Latin Grammy winner and former Minister of Culture, serenaded the Pope on Lima's Plaza Mayor. Her presence brought Afro-Peruvian dignity to the center of power. Rev. Kevin Noriega spoke of the "enormous hope and emotion" felt by residents welcoming "Father Robert" as the Holy Father. Yet emotion is not restitution. Forgiveness is a grace offered by victims, not currency spent by the institution that held the whip.

The Vatican expects us to marvel at a Chicago-born friar returning to Chiclayo. They treat his tears in Zaña and his helicopter ride to Santa Cruz de Succhabamba as absolution. A homily cannot undo structural displacement. As the Pope travels to Cusco and the Amazon rainforest, regional actors exploit the moment. Regional governor Jorge Pérez Flores moved to declare the Immaculate Conception as regional patron saint. He turns spiritual devotion into a branding exercise for tourism. The church cannot wash its hands in holy water while soil remains unreturned.

Pope Leo XIV owes the people of Cajamarca and Zaña more than poetry. He owes more than apologies for a slave trade his predecessors blessed. Until the Vatican turns moral authority into land restitution and material reparations, prayers will not restore what was taken. Every sermon remains a bell ringing over empty houses.

Sources

  1. BBC: Pope Leo speaks of community 'suffering' on visit to remote Andes town
  2. BBC: Pope Leo speaks of community 'suffering' on visit to remote Andes town
  3. KCRA: Pope denounces ‘suffering and humiliation’ of African enslaved people during Peru visit
  4. The Washington Post: More than 1.5 million people welcome Pope Leo XIV in northern Peru
  5. Vatican News: A look at Cusco and its devotions as Pope Leo travels to the Imperial City
  6. OSV News: Pope Leo entrusts Chiclayo and his papal ministry to Mary at coronation ceremony