Judge Ana Reyes checks executive overreach at East Potomac Park
By Adele Rutherford · Reporting from Atlanta ·
A federal judge rightly blocked the Trump administration's pretextual closure of a historic D.C. golf course, proving that procedure still checks power.
Procedure is where power actually lives
When a government lawyer stands in a federal courtroom and offers an explanation that does not square with the public record, the damage is not just to their own standing. It is to the entire machinery of state.
We watched this happen on the banks of the Potomac River in a dispute over a municipal golf course. The legal battle centers on the historic East Potomac Golf Links, situated south of the White House. The 106-year-old course was designed in the 1910s by Walter Travis. It is a public course run by the National Park Service in Washington, D.C.
Donald Trump planned to close the course starting 15 November for extensive renovations. He stated his plans would convert the course into a championship venue. He selected architect Tom Fazio to redesign the course into a single 18-hole venue.
To achieve this, the administration terminated the lease of the golf course operator and announced the park would close. The government cited the need to repair the park's deteriorating seawall as the primary justification for the closure.
U.S. District Judge Ana Reyes saw right through it. In a 30-page decision issued on Saturday, Judge Reyes temporarily blocked the closure. According to CNN, she characterized the Justice Department's claims as pretextual. According to the BBC, she stated the government violated federal law to meet an arbitrary deadline.
The parallels to United States v. Nixon are exact and unyielding. In that landmark 1974 decision, the Supreme Court unanimously ordered President Richard Nixon to surrender subpoenaed materials, affirming that executive claims of necessity and privilege are subordinate to the rule of law. Just as Nixon could not wave away subpoenas with broad assertions of power, this administration cannot manufacture safety emergencies to bypass federal statutes.
Judge Reyes wrote that the government's hands are tied, but the government tied the knot itself. She called the National Park Service's insistence that the park close irrational.
The cost of treating public parkland as a personal instrument
The administration's defense of its timeline strains credulity. The government argued that a crumbling seawall required closing the entire park for potentially as long as three and a half years.
As reported by Politico, 30,000 runners traversed the park last month for the Marine Corps Marathon. Judge Reyes rightly noted the absurdity of the government's safety claims. It cannot be that the Park Service permitted 30,000 runners to risk life and limb on a road near the seawall.
The administration's actions mirror the pattern seen in Trump v. Hawaii, where courts were forced to interrogate whether stated executive motivations matched the actual administrative record. Here, the record tells a tale of haste. In October, the National Park Service began cutting down hundreds of trees on the course. They notified Judge Reyes shortly before work commenced. Over 400 trees were removed.
Judge Reyes previously issued a preliminary injunction blocking further mass cutting of trees. She also required the administration to provide notice before making permanent changes. During the hearings, she stated she was beyond disappointed with the government.
The court is now pursuing the matter further. Judge Reyes opened an inquiry into whether Justice Department attorneys made misrepresentations to the court and violated ethical rules. According to NPR, the inquiry examines if late notice was done in bad faith and if attorneys withheld information or failed to correct false statements. She will conduct this inquiry with a special master, an independent third party.
When an executive branch treats notice-and-comment rulemaking as an inconvenience rather than a statutory mandate, it invites judicial correction. As Free Malaysia Today noted, the judge held that the administration's reasons for closure were pretextual. The temporary restraining order extends through 28 November. It requires the administration to keep the park open, though it does not force them to actively manage golf operations.
A rule that only works when your people hold power was never a rule
The loudest objections to Judge Reyes's order come from those who confuse executive desire with statutory authority. The Department of Justice argued vociferously that the Park Service can limit access where the public faces harm. They maintained that nothing in the order precludes planning for a world-class golf course.
That argument misses the point entirely. The issue is not whether Washington deserves a better golf course. The issue is whether an administration can terminate leases, fell hundreds of trees, and shut down public parkland by executive fiat without adhering to federal environmental regulations and procedural guardrails.
If an administration of one party can manufacture an emergency to bypass the Administrative Procedure Act today, an administration of the opposing party will use that exact mechanism tomorrow. Procedure is the armor of the citizen. When we cheer shortcuts because we like the proposed outcome, we strip that armor away.
Judge Reyes understood this. She is a judge appointed by Joe Biden who has shown she will hold the current administration to the letter of the law. Her skepticism of executive overreach is not partisan maneuvering. It is the judiciary doing its constitutional duty.
The DC Preservation League and local golfers sued because the law requires public input before historic municipal assets are radically altered. They are right to demand adherence to the text. We cannot allow administrative convenience to swallow statutory limits.
The temporary restraining order must hold, the ethics inquiry must proceed to its logical end, and executive power must remain subordinate to the laws enacted by Congress.
Sources
- BBC: Judge temporarily blocks Trump from closing Washington DC golf course for renovation
- Politico: Judge rejects Trump’s bid to immediately close East Potomac golf course
- CNN: Judge halts Trump plan to redevelop Washington, DC, golf course
- BBC: Judge temporarily blocks Trump from closing Washington DC golf course for renovation
- NPR: The government says it will close a beloved D.C. park Sunday. Will a judge step in?
- Free Malaysia Today: US judge again blocks Trump’s makeover plan for DC golf course