El Niño waves prove Pacifica and Ventura are unprepared

By Daniel Okafor · Reporting from New York ·

Massive swells flooded streets and closed piers across California, showing that local officials and residents still underestimate the destructive power of a strong El Niño.

The ocean does not negotiate. It simply takes what it wants. The failed pumps in Pacifica are a warning that California's coastal defenses are a fiction. Residents and officials treat the Pacific as a neighbor they can manage with a few machines and a seawall. They are wrong. The water is reclaiming the land, and the people watching the "drama" from the shore are ignoring the risk.

Why the pumps failed in Pacifica

The water did not just lap at the shore in Pacifica. It invaded. Water pushed hundreds of feet inland every 30 minutes. Nearly a foot of floodwater accumulated along Highway 1.

The city tried to fight back with technology. Recently installed pumps failed to drain floodwater at the end of Elder Lane. Erin Shea, a renter on that street, said the water damaged personal belongings in her garage. Adam Drake, a beachfront homeowner on the same lane, said only 2023 brought more furious flooding.

Some visitors saw this as a show. Richard Delameter has visited Point Reyes since 1967. He said he likes the drama of watching the earth when she is angry. The ocean answered that drama with a sneaker wave. The wave knocked down spectators, including a mother and toddler, in the parking lot in front of the Pacifica City Council Chambers.

A record for November

The scale of the swell was not a fluke. A buoy offshore Point Reyes measured significant wave heights of 31.2 feet on Saturday, the San Francisco Chronicle said. This measurement was the second largest in 30 years of records.

The timing is the real anomaly. Maximum waves are often 1.8 times larger than the significant wave height. The Scripps Institution of Oceanography said that only once in the 27-year record of the Point Reyes buoy have forecast wave heights been this large in November.

This event shares a mechanism with the 1997-1998 El Niño. Strong El Niño events shift tropical weather patterns to drive more powerful storms and larger waves to the California coast. Wave power is 32% stronger during strong El Niños than in a typical year.

The coast from San Diego to Malibu

The destruction moved south. ABC7 Los Angeles said that high surf and dangerous rip currents closed the Ventura, Hermosa Beach, and Manhattan Beach piers. Waves between 10 and 14 feet reached the top of the Ventura pier.

The water was not just high; it was moving. Ben Black of Ventura said a rip current was launching swimmers southward toward the rocks.

The risk extends to the administrative level. The Santa Cruz County Sheriff’s Office issued an evacuation warning for low-lying coastal areas. The office enforces these orders across the county's vulnerable 29 miles of coastline. Infobae said that the swell affected the coast from San Diego to Malibu. Rachel Kennedy, a meteorologist for the National Weather Service, said to the Los Angeles Times that onlookers could expose rescue teams during an emergency.

The current El Niño pattern generates repeated storm trains in the North Pacific. This atmospheric setup forced widespread evacuations in January 2023. Local authorities will likely extend evacuation orders as subsequent swells arrive this week. Municipalities will rush to build emergency berms to protect infrastructure, as they did in Ventura after 2015. But these are reactive measures for a predictable cycle.

The evidence shows that climate change is making wave-producing storms larger. Rising sea levels are increasing the damage. We are building homes and parking lots on a temporary lease from the Pacific. When the pumps fail and the seawalls vanish, the verdict is simple: the ocean always wins.

Sources

  1. San Francisco Chronicle: Video: Dangerous waves, biggest in a decade, flood Bay Area streets and threaten homes
  2. ABC7 Los Angeles: Ventura, Hermosa Beach and Manhattan Beach piers close as high surf and dangerous rip currents batter Southern California coast
  3. Infobae: Olas de hasta 18 metros golpean California: cierran playas y muelles y activan una alerta de evacuación