Port of New Orleans sues tanker owners to force accountability
By Daniel Okafor · Reporting from New York ·
After a tanker struck a riverboat on the Mississippi River, the Port of New Orleans sued to seize the ship and hold its owners accountable for total public losses.
A sudden blow on the Mississippi
The riverboat American Heritage sat against the Thalia Street terminal on Friday afternoon. It had just finished a cruise through Louisiana and Mississippi, and passengers disembarked with their bags. Then the 520-foot tanker Atlantic Asphalt appeared in the channel. The cargo vessel carried asphalt and bitumen under a Marshall Islands flag, according to Dallas News. A river pilot drove the ship, CNN said. Coast Guard Capt Melanie Burnham said the vessel appeared to have lost steering capabilities. The ship blasted its horn several times, Global News said. It then hit the docked riverboat with massive force.
The impact caused the American Heritage to capsize and partially submerge in the Mississippi River, BBC and WDSU reported. Passenger Joe Knab said the hit was hard and the ship immediately leaned, Global News reported. The roll threw two police officers into the river, Dallas News said. About 197 passengers and crew were on board the American Heritage, The Guardian reported. Passenger Joe Knab thought he was drowning as he kept bobbing underneath. Tugboat operators, police, and rescuers rushed to pull people from the current. New Orleans Harbor Police Chief Melanie Montroll said having passengers put on vests and float upriver while rescuers retrieved them was the best factor of success.
Thirty-two people were brought to the hospital with non-critical injuries, BBC said. No one was unaccounted for. Mayor Helena Moreno called the outcome a miracle on the Mississippi, The Guardian reported. The phrase echoed past survivals, though luck here masked a severe mechanical failure. Like the Ever Given obstruction of the Suez Canal in 2021, a massive commercial vessel lost control and caused significant infrastructure damage and economic loss. The collision left the American Heritage on its side and caused more than one million dollars in damage to the port terminal.
Seizing the vessel before it leaves
The Board of Commissioners of the Port of New Orleans filed a federal lawsuit in the Eastern District of Louisiana court on Friday, BBC reported. The lawsuit names the M/V Atlantic Asphalt, owner Nave Shipping SA, and management company Thome Ship Management Pte Ltd. Nave Shipping SA operates as a subsidiary of the China State Shipbuilding Corporation, Dallas News reported. Thome Ship Management is based in Singapore, CNN reported. The lawsuit alleges the collision occurred from the negligence, gross negligence, fault or carelessness of the operating companies. It states the defendants failed to use all available means to avoid colliding with the riverboat.
Federal Judge Wendy Vitter approved a request on Friday to issue a warrant giving federal officials control of the tanker, Dallas News reported. The lawsuit seeks money for cleanup, inspections, repairs, and other expenses. It requests that the tanker be seized and sold to pay for the damage. Thome Ship Management stated that the crew of the Atlantic Asphalt were safe and accounted for, BBC reported. The company said it is fully complying with local authorities as they carry out necessary investigations.
Some argue that mechanical failures are unpredictable acts that private management cannot prevent. The argument fails because maritime operators assume absolute responsibility for the mechanical integrity of every vessel they steer into crowded domestic ports. Like the MV Wakashio oil spill in Mauritius, a large commercial vessel lost steering or navigation, ran aground on a reef, and subsequently leaked fuel. The American Heritage contains 16,000 gallons of fuel, according to CNN. Coast Guard Capt Melanie Burnham said the first step is to make sure the fuel on the boat is removed safely. The National Transportation Safety Board recovered the tanker’s voyage data recorder. NTSB board member John DeLeeuw said the agency expects to release a preliminary report within 30 days.
Federal investigators will find that a mechanical steering failure caused the collision, clearing the river pilot of direct negligence. Nave Shipping and Thome Ship Management will contest the federal court seizure of the tanker under maritime jurisdictional limits. The salvage operation to remove the American Heritage will require complete channel closures on the Mississippi River. The courts must ensure the seized vessel is sold to cover every dollar of public loss.
Sources
- BBC: New Orleans port sues tanker owners over cruise ship collision for $1m
- CNN: Tanker ‘lost control’ and hit cruise ship in New Orleans, spurring massive evacuation, officials say
- Dallas News: New Orleans port sues to get control of tanker that crashed into cruise ship on Mississippi River
- WDSU: Investigation underway into collision; Coast Guard working to recover capsized ship
- The Guardian: New Orleans officials file $1m lawsuit after ‘Mississippi miracle’ tanker crash
- Global News: New Orleans port sues to get control of tanker that crashed into cruise ship