Atlantic Asphalt steering failure is no Mississippi miracle
By Daniel Okafor · Reporting from New York ·
After the Atlantic Asphalt struck the American Heritage in New Orleans, officials declared a miracle, but steering and stability failures require investigation rather than praise.
The rescue of passengers from a sinking cruise ship is not a miracle. It is a successful emergency response to a preventable mechanical failure. Governor Jeff Landry called the event a "miracle on the Mississippi." Mayor Helena Moreno agreed. The BBC reported that officials focus on the fact that no one died. They ignore the fact that a massive tanker lost control in a crowded channel and flipped a passenger ship. When a moving vessel destroys a stationary one, the result is not a miracle. It is an allision.
Steel and the river
The Atlantic Asphalt tanker struck the American Heritage at 12:30 p.m. near the Port of New Orleans. The impact was violent. Witness Jamie Holford told CBS News it sounded like "tonnes of steel crunching." He said it looked like something off the Titanic.
The American Heritage is a paddlewheeler built in 2015. It has four decks and can carry 150 guests. It features a fitness centre and a glass-enclosed restaurant. After the hit, the ship listed and tipped. Mayor Moreno said the vessel "toppled over and flipped." Chief Melanie Montroll of the Harbour Police Department said the boat began to take on water and subsequently capsized.
The US Coast Guard closed the river to all traffic. This is a critical artery. The US Army Corps of Engineers states the Mississippi River carries 669 million tons of cargo across the US every year. The closure halted a massive flow of commerce to save a few dozen people.
A drone tracked the rescue
The rescue succeeded because of proximity and luck. About 87 people left the cruise ship before it sank. Chief Montroll said it took 30 to 45 minutes to move the remaining people into boats. Tug boats, a police boat, and a firefighting vessel pulled survivors from the river. The water temperature was cold.
A police drone provided the first eyes on the scene. Superintendent Anne Kirkpatrick said the drone was tracking a theft nearby. It flew to the crash "within moments" and showed people in the water. This coincidence saved lives.
The human cost was still real. Thirty-two passengers were taken to local hospitals, WDSU reported. Mayor Moreno said none of the injuries were critical.
Why did steering fail on the river?
The Atlantic Asphalt did not drift into the cruise ship. It was under power. MarineTraffic data shows the tanker was docked south of the crash site since November 11. It began traveling up the river at 12:20 local time. It stopped near the cruise ship around 13:30 local time.
Captain Melanie Burnham of the US Coast Guard said there seems to be a "loss of steering." She does not yet know the cause. This is the same mechanism that caused the MV Stockholm and Andrea Doria collision. In that disaster, a moving ship miscalculated its course and struck another vessel. The result was a sinking and a massive rescue operation. Both events prove that when a pilot loses the ability to steer a heavy vessel, the stationary ship bears the entire force of the momentum.
The Governor argues that the river is not a "quiet pond" and that ships have operated safely for years. This is the strongest case for the "miracle" narrative. He suggests the event was an unpredictable accident. But the record of the river suggests otherwise. High cargo volume and narrow channels make steering failure a known risk.
Stability of the fleet
The speed with which the American Heritage sank is the real story. American Cruise Lines is the largest domestic river fleet in the US. They operate 30 vessels built by Chesapeake Shipbuilding. The American Heritage capsized rapidly after a single side impact. This raises a question about the stability of these four-deck ships.
The National Transportation Safety Board launched a Go Team to investigate. They will likely find that a hydraulic steering pump failed on the Atlantic Asphalt. This is a common failure in large tankers. They will also likely find that the American Heritage lacked the hull compartmentation to survive a breach.
The river will likely reopen first to one-way traffic. Captain Burnham said the Coast Guard will use its vessel monitoring service to manage the flow. Normal two-way cargo traffic should resume within 14 days once salvage crews remove the wreck.
The rescue was a triumph of first responders, not a miracle of fate. The facts point to a mechanical failure on the tanker and a stability failure on the cruise ship. We should not thank the heavens for the lack of deaths. We should demand to know why a 2015 vessel flipped so easily and why a tanker lost its way in a known channel.
Sources
- BBC: 'Miracle on the Mississippi' - All passengers accounted for after tanker crashes into cruise ship in New Orleans
- FOX 8 Live WVUE: LIVE: ‘Miracle on the Mississippi’|No fatalities after tanker crashes into river cruiser carrying nearly 150 people near Port of New Orleans
- WDSU: Miracle on the Mississippi: All accounted for after tanker collides with cruise ship
- BBC: 'Miracle on Mississippi' - All rescued after cruise ship hit by tanker in New Orleans