Trump's attacks on judges turn the rule of law into a tool

By Adele Rutherford · Reporting from Atlanta ·

By sanctioning judges and overriding legal bounds, Donald Trump replaces the independent judicial process with executive authority, reducing the rule of law to a mere political tool.

President Donald Trump is wrong to treat the judiciary as a hurdle to be cleared rather than a boundary to be respected. Across three continents and multiple jurisdictions, he has signaled that the law is a nuisance when it obstructs his policy goals. This is not a disagreement over legal interpretation. It is an attack on the process of judicial independence. When an executive treats the courts as subordinates, the law ceases to be a rule and becomes a tool.

The cost of judicial independence

The Trump administration has turned economic sanctions into a weapon against the bench. Sanctions are economic penalties used to pressure a target. In August 2025, the administration sanctioned Kimberly Prost, a Canadian judge at the International Criminal Court in The Hague. CBC News reports these sanctions froze her bank accounts and cancelled her credit cards.

Judge Prost authorized a 2020 investigation into alleged war crimes in Afghanistan. The ICC investigates genocide and war crimes when its 125 member states are unable to do so. The administration claims the court is a "rogue institution." Secretary of State Marco Rubio threatened to dismantle it "brick by brick."

This is a direct attempt to coerce a judge. Prost filed a lawsuit in June 2026. She alleges the sanctions are designed to exert extra-judicial pressure. She argues the goal is to force judges to prioritize private interests over the law. This mirrors the American Service-Members' Protection Act of 2002, where the executive used legislation to shield personnel from international tribunals.

The administration argues that American agents should not be at the mercy of foreign judges. This is the strongest case for the policy: the executive must protect its citizens from biased foreign courts. But that argument fails when the remedy is to bankrupt the judge. You do not protect the rule of law by punishing the people who administer it.

Categorical rejection and the border

The attack on process continues at the southern border. Asharq Al-Awsat reports the Supreme Court is considering a Trump executive order that bans asylum requests. Federal law grants people the right to seek asylum if they fear persecution. The administration argues it has the authority to categorically reject these requests.

They claim that long processing periods encourage migration. This is an attempt to unilaterally undermine legal safeguards. It echoes the logic of Trump v. Hawaii in 2017, where the executive argued for broad authority to exclude individuals based on national security.

The executive's goal is to remove the judge from the equation entirely. If the administration can categorically reject a request, there is no longer a case for a court to hear. This is the same mechanism at work in the court-packing plan of 1937. In that instance, Franklin D. Roosevelt attempted to restructure the Supreme Court to remove legal obstacles to his New Deal. Both strategies seek to neutralize the judiciary to ensure a favorable outcome.

The double standard of clemency

The administration's view of judicial process is selective. On November 5, 2026, California Governor Gavin Newsom commuted the death sentences of prisoners to life imprisonment. Donald Trump called this a "desastre para la justicia" on Truth Social. He described Newsom as "incompetente" for impeding the legal system.

Newsom's move was a blunt instrument. He acted on "values" rather than individual case reviews. This is a failure of process. Under California law, the Supreme Court of California must approve commutations for individuals convicted of more than one felony. This requirement applies to 382 of the prisoners in Newsom's order. The court is the necessary check on the governor's impulse.

Yet Trump's outrage is a performance. ABC Color notes that more than 1,700 people received pardons or commutations during Trump's second term. This included people accused of assaulting law enforcement on January 6, 2021. He does not object to the executive bypassing the courts; he only objects when someone else does it.

The law is only a rule if it applies when your opponents hold the tool. If the executive can sanction judges in The Hague, ignore asylum laws at the border, and pardon allies while condemning enemies, the process is dead.

The California Supreme Court will likely limit Newsom's order to enforce the requirement for judicial approval. That is how the system is supposed to work. The tragedy is that the executive branch now views such checks as obstacles to be dismantled. When the judiciary is neutralized, the only thing left is the will of the person in power.

Sources

  1. CBC News: Trump's attempts to intimidate the International Criminal Court are 'futile,' says Canadian judge
  2. ABC Color: Trump critica la conmutación de las penas de muerte en California y espera que se revoque
  3. Asharq Al-Awsat: المحكمة العليا ستنظر في أمر ترمب بتعليق منح اللجوء على الحدود الجنوبية