Mary Peltola leads Alaska Senate vote count as lawsuits stall

By Adele Rutherford · Reporting from Atlanta ·

As lawsuits target Alaska's Senate race over a second candidate named Dan Sullivan, adherence to statutory counting processes must outweigh partisan demands to alter election rules.

The geography of the count

The machinery of an election is never more honest than when it relies on a twin-engine otter climbing through a pass in the Lynn Canal. Reporting by the BBC notes that Democratic challenger Mary Peltola leads incumbent Republican Senator Dan Sullivan in Alaska. That lead leaves her near the 50 percent threshold required for an outright win under the state’s ranked-choice voting system. Yet before any tally can settle, the physical reality of the state reasserts itself. Juneau, the state capital, is accessible only by plane or boat, with no connecting roads. Regional carriers like Alaska Seaplanes fly ballot boxes from remote villages. As election lawyer Scott Kendall noted, individuals run the process for their family and neighbors. Andy Kline of Alaska Seaplanes described the work as routine boxes. He noted that carriers feel pride in moving ballots across thousands of miles. Charles Stewart of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology observed that officials chose to err on getting it right rather than rushing the count. Mail ballots may arrive up to 10 days after the election if postmarked by election day. The final ranked-choice tabulation is scheduled for November 18. Under Bush v. Gore, a contested election pending a final tally in a jurisdiction requires the counting process to run its course under established rules.

The politics of the spoiler

The strongest case for intervention rests on the argument that voter confusion over two candidates named Dan Sullivan demands extraordinary legal remedies. As detailed by Democracy Docket, a second candidate named Dan Sullivan appeared on the ballot alongside the incumbent, alongside candidate Gerald L. Heikes. President Donald Trump alleged that the election was rigged. He demanded that votes cast for minor candidates be given to Senator Dan Sullivan, calling the second candidate a spoiler. This mirrors the 2020 United States presidential election, where litigation sought to halt certification based on allegations of rigged processes. But the legal mechanism fails the fundamental test of process. Courts cannot reallocate votes after an election simply because a candidate shared a surname, absent a proven statutory violation. As reported by Alaska Public Media, the Justice Department sued to block certification if Senator Sullivan lost, pending an investigation into voter confusion. A federal judge dismissed the lawsuit. While the administration is appealing, it did not seek an expedited schedule. U.S. Attorney Michael Heyman and Governor Mike Dunleavy are investigating the second Sullivan's recruitment. But an investigation is not a judicial holding. Invalidating votes cast for a candidate because an incumbent dislikes the ballot discards the rule of law for political convenience.

The parallel of 1876

The situation resembles the Tilden-Hayes Presidential Election of 1876, where legal challenges and political negotiation contested the certification of a narrow result. The shared mechanism is turning routine administrative friction into a pretext for executive intervention. The current attempts by federal authorities to stall certification in Alaska rely on political pressure rather than statutory command. If election rules are valid only when your candidate wins, you have a provisional truce rather than law. Mary Peltola’s lead places her ahead of the incumbent and the minor candidates combined. If she crosses the 50 percent mark or captures sufficient second-preference reallocations, she will win the election. Ranked-choice voting, which eliminates the last-place candidate and reallocates ballots to second choices, handles multi-candidate fields. The statute does not disqualify a candidate because his name matches an opponent's.

The final verdict

The process must be judged by its adherence to statute rather than outcome. The ongoing count in Alaska has met every procedural test despite federal lawsuits and partisan recriminations.

Sources

  1. BBC: Why midterm vote-counting is taking so long in America's largest state
  2. Democracy Docket: Democrat Peltola widens lead over both Sullivans combined in Alaska Senate race
  3. Alaska Public Media: Peltola leads in U.S. Senate race, nearing 50% mark with almost all ballots counted