Democrats failed the law by treating Hegseth as a political poll
By Adele Rutherford · Reporting from Atlanta ·
House Democrats failed to advance the impeachment of Pete Hegseth due to absenteeism and strategic hesitation, proving they value political optics over the rule of law.
The cost of a missing vote
The House of Representatives failed to advance the impeachment of Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth. The failure was not a lack of evidence. It was a failure of discipline. Eleven Democrats were absent for the vote, according to NPR. Among them was former speaker Nancy Pelosi, who was attending a veterans' event in San Francisco.
In this house, we treat the process as the point. Impeachment is the constitutional tool to remove an officer for "high crimes and misdemeanors." That term refers to an abuse of official power that threatens the state. The record here is not a political disagreement. It is a ledger of deaths.
The Guardian reports that Hegseth is accused of ordering strikes on boats in the Caribbean and Pacific. These strikes killed people. Former army intelligence officer Kevin Carroll calls these clear violations of the law of war. He notes that the U.S. hanged Nazis for doing the same to shipwrecked sailors. Then there is the strike on a girls' school in Minab, Iran. That event killed people, including children.
When the evidence suggests negligent homicide and war crimes, the process must move. To treat a vote on such matters as optional is to treat the law as a suggestion. The Democrats are wrong. They have mistaken a mandate for governance for a license to ignore the record.
The temptation of the poll
The Democratic leadership is currently seduced by the data. A Reuters/Ipsos poll found respondents believe the focus should be on the cost of living. It found they want lower health care costs and lower gas prices. Only 40% of respondents believe investigating the Trump administration should be a priority.
The strongest case for Hakeem Jeffries is that of the responsible steward. His advocates would argue that a leader must prioritize the material needs of the many over the legal accountability of the few. They would say that pursuing Hegseth while voters worry about groceries is a strategic error that risks the majority's longevity.
That argument is a shortcut. It assumes that the law only applies when it is popular. Legitimacy is a capital stock that spends fast and refills slowly. If a party only defends the rule of law when the polls align, they are not defending a rule. They are practicing a preference.
The Mueller Investigation showed the danger of this rift. It created a deep divide between those seeking immediate legal accountability and those favoring a broader political strategy. The Democrats are repeating that error. Hakeem Jeffries told PBS NewsHour that they will "cross that bridge when we get to it" regarding more impeachments. The bridge is the law. You do not wait for a favorable poll to cross it.
A recurring failure of nerve
This hesitation is a pattern. The impeachment of Donald Trump shares the same mechanism: the risk of failure when a party is strategically misaligned with public priorities or lacks unified support. In both cases, the process was treated as a political instrument rather than a legal necessity.
The current Democratic approach is the opposite. Politico reports that some leaders suggest allowing investigations to proceed through committees instead of a floor vote. Adam Smith, the ranking member of the House Armed Services Committee, says the party needs to think "instead of just shooting from the hip."
This is a retreat into the passive virtues, but it is the wrong kind of patience. There is a difference between a methodical investigation and a strategic delay. The former builds a case; the latter waits for the wind to change.
The dossier on Pete Hegseth shows a man who has already survived a narrow Senate confirmation. He is a man who utilized unsecured messaging via Signal for war plans. He is a man who presided over a purge of senior admirals. He is not a man who will be moved by a "measured approach."
The Democrats now hold a large majority. They flipped Republican-held seats, according to ABC News. They have the power to act. Yet they allowed a vote to fail because they were looking at a poll instead of the record.
The Democratic leadership believes they can trade accountability for affordability. They believe they can ignore the deaths in Minab to focus on the price of gas. This is a failure of the lawyerly mind. A rule that only works while your people hold power was never a rule. By treating the impeachment of a suspected war criminal as a political calculation, Hakeem Jeffries has signaled that the process is secondary to the score.
The Democrats have the numbers to hold the executive branch accountable, but they lack the discipline to do it. They are treating the Constitution as a menu, picking the items that fit the current mood of the electorate. If they continue to treat "high crimes" as a matter of timing, they will find that the law has no memory and no loyalty. The failure to advance the Hegseth articles is not a strategic victory for the center; it is a surrender of the only tool that actually limits power.
Sources
- NPR: Hegseth's failed impeachment was a warning to Democrats. Where will they go from here?
- The Guardian: Hegseth survived impeachment bid but reprieve may be temporary: ‘He can’t escape justice forever’
- Politico: Hegseth’s future splits Dems
- ABC News: Republicans dazed by midterm election defeats grapple with what went wrong
- NRK: Republikaner fremmer riksrettsforslag mot forsvarsminister Pete Hegseth