Townhouse Builders and city officials enabled Flatbush collapse
By Maya Ellison · Reporting from Detroit ·
By ignoring active warnings and lifting a stop-work order, city officials and Townhouse Builders enabled a predictable Brooklyn collapse that killed eight people, demanding criminal accountability for real estate developers.
The death of eight people in Flatbush was not an accident. It was a calculation. When a building collapses into a construction site, we are told to wait for the investigation. But the records already tell the story. This was a crime of negligence committed by Townhouse Builders and enabled by the New York City Department of Buildings. They traded the lives of immigrant families for the convenience of a developer's timeline.
The cost of the American dream in Flatbush
The victims were people who lived in the shadows to survive. Juan Carlos Zabala told Gothamist that his family stayed shut inside because they feared being deported. They were following the American dream. Instead, they found a nightmare. Juan Daniel Sabala and his daughter Nicole are among the dead.
The wreckage claimed eight lives. Eighteen people were injured. Among them is Pablo Alvarez, who is recovering from surgery for a severe head injury. His father, Anderson Velez, told CBS News that the building had no reason to fall on its own. He is right. Buildings do not just fall. They are pushed.
This tragedy echoes the Rana Plaza collapse. That disaster showed how corporate greed and failed safety rules kill workers. It proved that ignoring structural warnings is a lethal choice. In Brooklyn, the victims weren't garment workers, but the result was the same.
A blueprint for a massacre
The paper trail is a map of indifference. According to CBS News, the collapsed building had 98 open violations. The city knew it was failing. Next door, Townhouse Builders was digging a hole for a new mixed-use building. This project, owned by an LLC run by Robert Fischman and his associates, planned to dig down 14 feet.
The contractor did not play by the rules. The Department of Buildings ordered Townhouse Builders to stop demolition work earlier this year. The contractor ignored the order. The city issued a violation in April. By May, the city lifted the stop-work order and let the work continue.
NBC New York reports that a pre-construction inspection for the site noted cracks in the adjacent building. The report called the north wall "poor" and cited "major deficiencies." Despite this, the work continued. The project included rock blasting. They blasted rock next to a wall they knew was failing.
Townhouse Builders has been sued at least 67 times. This is not a company that makes mistakes. This is a company that treats lawsuits as a cost of doing business. This is the same reckless risk-taking that triggered the 2008 financial crisis. The financial elite gambled with homes. Here, Robert Fischman and his associates gambled with lives. The vulnerable always pay the price for the greed of the powerful.
The machinery of managed neglect
The strongest case for the city is that the building was old. They will argue that the 98 violations were the building's own fault. They will say the collapse was an unfortunate result of ancient masonry.
That argument is a lie. A building's age does not give a contractor a license to blast rock next to it. Knowing a wall is in "poor" condition makes the excavation a weapon. The Department of Buildings did not protect the residents. It cleared the path for the developer.
The Surfside condominium collapse shared the same mechanism. Known structural deficiencies and ignored warnings are weaponized by negligence to kill the vulnerable. In both cases, the warnings were in the files. The officials chose to look away. The developers chose to push forward.
This is the long record of New York real estate. Developers use LLCs to hide their assets. They treat city fines as small fees. They know that the Department of Buildings is often a rubber stamp for those with the right connections. This systemic failure is cruelty scaled up to a routine.
The 2008 financial crisis showed us that regulatory failure is a choice. It happens when the government serves the market instead of the people. When the city lifts a stop-work order for a contractor with 67 lawsuits, it is not managing a site. It is subsidizing a disaster.
Piercing the veil
Justice for the Sabala and Velez families requires more than an emergency relief fund. It requires the Brooklyn District Attorney's Office to pierce the corporate veil of Robert Fischman's LLCs. We must stop letting shell companies absorb the liability for manslaughter. The personal assets of the developers should be seized to compensate the survivors.
The Department of Buildings must be stripped of its power to allow self-certification. We cannot trust the people who profit from the construction to report the danger. Mayor Zohran Mamdani has ordered an investigation into 100 sites connected to these entities. That is a start, but it is not enough.
The ledger for this collapse is clear. The cost was eight lives and the destruction of a community's hope. The profit was a building that will never be worth the blood spilled to build it. If the city only issues misdemeanors and small fines, it sends a clear message. It tells every developer in Brooklyn that killing tenants is a viable business strategy. True accountability means felony charges for the decision-makers and a total overhaul of how this city protects its poorest residents.
Sources
- CBS News: Man whose wife, son were injured in Brooklyn building collapse wants answers: "The building had no reason to fall on its own"
- NBC New York: What was the work being done at construction site next to Brooklyn building collapse?
- Gothamist: Families devastated by Brooklyn building collapse came to NYC for a new life
- SBS News: Mayor orders investigation following Brooklyn building collapse that killed eight people
- SVT Nyheter: Dödssiffran stiger efter husras i Brooklyn