Howard Lutnick failed the state by stalling Megaspeed controls

By Nikhil Raghavan · Reporting from San Francisco ·

Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick delayed export restrictions on Megaspeed while Nvidia lost $550 billion in value, proving that administrative friction is a national security risk.

The Commerce Department is the single point of failure here. For months, the Treasury, Defense, and State departments, along with the U.S. Trade Representative, agreed on one thing: Megaspeed needed to be on the entity list. Instead, Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick stalled. As Scott Bessent told CNBC, the Treasury has wanted these restrictions for months. This is not a policy debate. It is a failure of implementation. When the state decides a company is a security risk, the administrative machinery should move. Under Lutnick, it stopped.

The cost of administrative friction

The result of this delay is a corporate and geopolitical disaster. Jensen Huang, the former CEO of Nvidia, resigned on Thursday morning. He left following a "spy-sex scandal" involving Alice Huang. According to the BBC, Alice Huang was an executive at Megaspeed and is suspected of being a Chinese intelligence asset.

The fallout was immediate. Nvidia's market value dropped $550 billion in five days. This is the price of "leakage." Scott Bessent expressed frustration that President Trump was clear: China should not receive Nvidia chips above H100s. Yet, the chips kept moving.

The mechanism of the failure is simple. The Commerce Department holds the keys to the entity list. If the Secretary refuses to turn them, the policy is sellable but not shippable. The state gets rolled by the entities it regulates when its own internal processes are broken.

A pattern of slow-walking the spec

This is not a new habit for Howard Lutnick. If you read the Federal Register, you see how he handles administrative systems. In February 2025, the President issued proclamations for steel and aluminum tariffs. Lutnick had to certify that the systems to collect this revenue were adequate. He did not sign that certification until March 11, 2025.

Lutnick treats national security controls like a tariff ledger. He focuses on process rather than urgency. The current crisis shares a historical backdrop with Huawei export restrictions. That policy tracked the Huawei MateBook series of laptops from their release on 21 February 2016 through September 2019, when selected models offered Deepin as a preloaded operating system in China. The historical pattern predicts that export controls are only as effective as the people who manage them. When the manager stalls, the adversary wins.

Who answers the page

Now, the Senate Banking Committee is stepping in. Senator Tim Scott has summoned both Lutnick and Jensen Huang to testify in December. Lutnick will likely argue that his "internal processes" were necessary. This is a classic bureaucratic shield.

In reality, the question is simple: who gets paged at three in the morning when a restricted chip ends up in a Beijing data center? It is not the Secretary. It is the analysts at the Bureau of Industry and Security. They are the ones who have to enforce a spec that the leadership refused to ship.

Mao Ning, a spokesperson for China's Ministry of Foreign Affairs, told Euronews that the U.S. is fabricating narratives. The best response to that claim would have been a timely export restriction. Instead, the U.S. provided a window of opportunity for Alice Huang and Megaspeed.

Lutnick's failure is operational. He managed the entity list as a political tool rather than a security firewall. Based on his record with tariff certifications, he will likely miss any new timeline for finalizing the Megaspeed rules. He will cite procedural backlogs while the chips continue to leak. The state cannot protect its technology if the person in charge of the lock prefers to keep the key in his pocket.

Sources

  1. CNBC: Bessent: Treasury has wanted Megaspeed restrictions for months, but Commerce is in charge
  2. BBC: Ex-Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang summoned to testify before Congress about affair with alleged Chinese spy
  3. BBC: Ex-Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang summoned to testify before Congress about affair with alleged Chinese spy
  4. Euronews: Ex-Nvidia CEO Huang and US Commerce Secretary Lutnick summoned to testify before Congress