Marc Bennett calls killing two people a mistake, not a crime
By Maya Ellison · Reporting from Detroit ·
Sedgwick County District Attorney Marc Bennett declined criminal charges for a driver who killed two people at Stryker Sports Complex, rewarding fatal negligence with a legal loophole.
When a multi-ton truck plows into a youth soccer game, the result is not a "mistake." It is a catastrophe. Yet Sedgwick County District Attorney Marc Bennett has decided that the woman behind the wheel is not a criminal. He is hiding behind a narrow legal dictionary to shield a driver from the consequences of her own gross negligence. By doing so, he has told the families of the dead that their loss is a civil matter. He has decided that the law exists to protect the person who caused the harm, not the people who suffered it.
The luxury of a legal loophole
The facts are a horror story. A woman drove her husband's truck to the Stryker Sports Complex. She told her children she was going to take a nap. She reclined her seat. A child put up a sunshade. Then she fell asleep with her foot on the gas.
The truck sat against a curb before it surged forward into a youth soccer game. Cole Adrian, 6, and Nicholas Schafer, 35, were killed. Other people were injured.
According to reports from KAKE and KMBC, Marc Bennett says he cannot find a "mental state" for a crime. He argues that Kansas law defines a reckless act as when a person "consciously disregards a substantial and unjustifiable risk." Because the driver thought she was in park, Bennett calls it a "mistake."
Here, the DA uses a technical definition of "recklessness" to erase the reality of the carnage. He claims charging the driver would be "hindsight bias." There is nothing biased about the dead.
A pattern of state-sponsored impunity
This is the East Palestine train derailment all over again. In Ohio, a freight train carrying hazardous materials derailed and burned, yet the state shielded the powerful from criminal accountability. The mechanism is the same: the state labels a disaster an "accident" to stop the clock on justice.
We have seen this script before. During the 2014 Flint water crisis, bureaucratic definitions of "crime" were used to shield officials from accountability while children were poisoned. We saw it during the opioid epidemic, where corporate negligence and a conscious disregard for life were treated as business errors.
In every one of these cases, the state decides that the "mental state" of the perpetrator is more important than the physical state of the victims. Marc Bennett's report focuses on what the driver believed. He ignores the fact that falling asleep in a running vehicle in a parking lot full of children is the definition of a disregard for human life.
The bill for the vulnerable
Now, the burden of justice shifts. Since the state refuses to act, the families of Cole Adrian and Nicholas Schafer must pay for their own closure. Global News reports that DeVaughn James Injury Lawyers is now working with the injured families on civil lawsuits.
This is how the system works for people who don't have power. If you are the one who causes the crash, the state gives you the benefit of the doubt. If you are the one who gets crushed, you get a lawyer and a settlement check. A check is not a conviction. A settlement is not a sentence.
Bennett claims he cannot prove the driver "consciously disregarded a tremendous risk." But the risk was there. The truck was there. The children were there. The driver chose to sleep in a vehicle she did not normally drive, in a place where people were playing.
Justice would require a law that recognizes negligent homicide. It would require a prosecutor who sees a dead six-year-old and refuses to call it a "mistake." Instead, we have a system that treats fatal carelessness as a civil inconvenience.
Marc Bennett has decided that the law is a shield for the negligent. He has left the grieving families to chase a civil payout because he is too timid to challenge a narrow statute. When the state refuses to call a killing a crime, it isn't protecting the law. It is protecting the killer.