Corporate greed collapsed a Brooklyn building, killing eight

By Alma Cordero · Reporting from El Paso ·

Reckless excavation and unpunished landlord neglect collapsed a Flatbush building into a pit, killing eight people and demanding real accountability.

When profit digs too deep and leaves families in the dirt

On Wednesday afternoon, the ground gave out on Flatbush Avenue. A residential building at 1321 Flatbush Avenue in Brooklyn collapsed into an adjacent construction pit. People were working in the pit at the time, according to reporting by the BBC, CNN, and the New York Post. Eight human beings died in that pile of brick and wood. Adults and children lost their lives when the earth swallowed their home.

We are not talking about an act of nature or a twist of fate. As CNN and the New York Post report, the building had 98 open housing violations. Its owner, Olufemi Falade, had a record of negligence stretching back decades. The record shows he was jailed in 2006 for failing to repair violations across multiple properties. Next door, developers had permits for excavation and foundation work for a new building. But the Department of Buildings had previously issued a stop-work order due to dangerous conditions. Work continued anyway. They kept digging to squeeze every dollar from a working-class immigrant neighborhood. This is the exact mechanism of the Sampoong Department Store collapse. Corporate greed and cut corners turn homes into death traps. Seoul inspectors looked away while columns were compromised in 1995. Here, municipal machinery permitted a dangerous excavation next to a decaying tenement. You do not get this disaster without people deciding human safety is negotiable.

Names we must carry into the room when we demand justice

The human cost of this failure is staggering. We must name the dead so nobody treats them as statistics. The NYPD and NBC New York identified the residents who died as Nicole Daniela Salvada Rodriguez, Juan Daniel Salvada Guzman, Kevin Santiago Reyes Gonzalez, Barry Mamadou, and Ndiaye Mamadou. Other victims include Gabriel Siguencia of the Bronx, Edgar Sapon of Hell's Kitchen, and Jose Luis Caguana Cosquillo of Bushwick. Children died in that collapse. Construction workers earning a living in that pit died too. Eighteen others were injured, including firefighters. Mayor Zohran Mamdani told reporters that these were "our friends and our neighbours. Our parents and our children. Young families building their lives in our city, and immigrants from Mexico, Colombia, Ecuador, Trinidad and beyond." We heard testimony from survivors like Anderson Velez, who lived there with his family. We heard from community members at the Bethesda Church of God in Christ. Psychologist Florence Saint-Jean noted that when crisis hits an immigrant neighborhood, "there’s only one language – love." Residents voiced fury that officials ignore their warnings. Brooklyn District Attorney Eric Gonzalez stated they are working with the Department of Buildings to see if criminal conduct contributed. Mayor Mamdani vowed to hold every entity accountable. Officials are sweeping 100 other locations linked to these developers. A fine is not justice. A stop-work order after the roof falls in is not justice. True justice means seizing assets of developers who treat human lives as business costs. It means stripping properties from landlords with 98 open violations. It means holding every official accountable who signed off on permits next to a crumbling tenement.

No more handshakes across the fence while the foundations crack

Real estate apologists will tell us that accidents happen in a dense metropolis. They say construction is complex and we must wait for final reports. That defense comes up after every tragedy. We heard it after the 2013 Rana Plaza collapse in Bangladesh. We heard it after the 2021 Surfside condominium collapse. They tell us to trust a system that failed to keep walls standing. But there is no mystery here. When you allow landlords to neglect repairs while excavation roars outside, you write an obituary before pouring foundation. We have watched this pattern play out for generations. The people doing the hardest work have the least standing to complain. Ahmed Tigani's Department of Buildings oversees over a million structures. Yet self-certification and lax oversight protect the powerful while putting immigrant families in danger. As Sumathy Kumar of the New York State Tenant Bloc and Housing Justice for All pointed out, we need faster tools to hold landlords accountable. We do not need another press conference in front of rubble. We need indictments reaching every corporate entity that traded safety for profit. Those eight people did not die because a building simply fell down. They died because an unpunished landlord and a reckless construction operation turned their home into a crater. City hall only asks questions after coffins are ordered. We owe it to Nicole Daniela Salvada Rodriguez, Kevin Santiago Reyes Gonzalez, Gabriel Siguencia, Jose Luis Caguana Cosquillo, and their families to make responsible parties pay. If we let them hide behind permits, walls will keep falling on us.

Sources

  1. BBC: What we know about Brooklyn building collapse that killed eight people
  2. NBC New York: Recap: 2 kids among 8 dead in NYC collapse; FDNY concludes search for survivors
  3. CNN: Immigrant neighborhood in Brooklyn demands accountability for building collapse
  4. New York Post: Harrowing video shows inside view of moment Brooklyn building collapses, killing at least 8: report
  5. ABC News: What we know about victims of deadly Brooklyn building collapse
  6. France 24: Eight killed, including two children, in New York building collapse