Western Springs crash proves BNSF grade crossings remain deadly

By Daniel Okafor · Reporting from New York ·

An Amtrak train collision in Western Springs killed two elementary students, showing that open grade crossings along the busy BNSF corridor create an unacceptable fatal risk.

Two elementary students are dead because a driver drove through closed gates. The village of Western Springs confirmed the crossing gates were functioning and engaged at the time of the collision. The driver is wrong for ignoring the signals, but the BNSF railway is wrong for maintaining a corridor that allows a single mistake to kill two children.

The fire at Wolf Road

The crash happened shortly after 8 a.m. on Wednesday. An Amtrak train traveling from Chicago to Quincy struck a vehicle at the Wolf Road crossing. The impact left the car engulfed in flames.

Witness Mike Struglinski said he heard a loud bang and saw the car up in flames. He noted the "look, listen, live" signs at the crossing. Kristen Potterton saw the driver, a woman, try to climb out of the vehicle. Potterton said the woman's top half started to catch on fire as the flames spread down her body. A group of men used a fire extinguisher to help her escape.

The woman was taken to Loyola Hospital with severe injuries. Two children in the car died. None of the 35 people aboard the train was injured. ABC7 Chicago reported that Metra halted BNSF service for most of the morning. Ten BNSF trains did not operate.

Is this an isolated crash?

Some may argue that the driver suffered a medical emergency or that the gates failed. The village of Western Springs rejected this. Preliminary reports from the village and People.com show the gates worked. The facts leave no room for mechanical excuse.

The crash shares a pattern with the Chatsworth train collision, where a collision on a rail line causes a mass casualty event. This is not an isolated incident on this line. On May 11, 2022, a Metra train collided with a box truck at the Prospect Avenue grade crossing in Clarendon Hills. That crash killed one person.

The BNSF and Amtrak run up to 130 trains a day through Western Springs. This includes Metra trains and freight rail traffic. BNSF owns the tracks and operates the BNSF Line under a purchase-of-service agreement with Metra. The volume of traffic makes every single crossing a point of failure. When so many trains pass through a village daily, the risk of a vehicle entering the rail line becomes certain.

The morning commute carries a heavy cost

The deaths have left Pleasantdale School District 107 in mourning. The district encompasses kindergarten through eighth grade. Dave Palzet, the superintendent, said the loss will affect everyone in the school family.

School social workers informed staff and homeroom students on Wednesday afternoon. Palzet told parents to tell their children the truth. He told them to talk about death rather than "going to sleep." He urged parents to watch for aggression or withdrawal in their children.

NBC 5 Chicago reported that counselors and crisis staff will be at Pleasantdale Elementary on Thursday. Social workers will also be at Village Hall to assist witnesses. The district is not releasing the names or ages of the students.

The driver’s choice to bypass the gates caused the fire, but the infrastructure allowed the tragedy. The BNSF corridor is a high-speed artery that cuts through residential neighborhoods. The village of Western Springs and the railroad have known the risks of the Wolf Road crossing. They have seen the record of fatalities on the BNSF line. They have seen the volume of trains that make these crossings dangerous.

The driver is responsible for the act, but the authorities are responsible for the environment. To keep a grade crossing at Wolf Road is to accept that another driver will eventually ignore a gate. The only way to stop these deaths is to remove the cars from the tracks entirely. Until the village and BNSF fund grade separation to eliminate the crossing, the corridor remains a trap.

Sources

  1. NBC 5 Chicago: Two west suburban elementary students killed in fiery crash with train, district says
  2. ABC7 Chicago: Western Springs train crash: 2 Pleasantdale School District 107 elementary students killed, 1 hurt; Metra BNSF service halted
  3. People.com: 2 Children Killed, Driver Severely Injured After Vehicle Is Struck by Amtrak Train in Illinois