Michael Comer tried to kill his son after probation failed
By Daniel Okafor · Reporting from New York ·
Michael Comer buried his 11-month-old son alive for 24 hours, an act of attempted murder that reveals the danger of leaving violent offenders on probation.
Michael Comer is a man who viewed his own child as a disposable object. He did not suffer a lapse in judgment. He did not have a momentary break from reality. He took his 11-month-old son, Koah Sharp, and placed him in a hole in the ground. Comer is 25 years old. He is now charged with attempted murder, unlawful conduct toward a child, custodial interference, and burglary.
The facts of the case do not leave room for a softer interpretation. Comer did not leave the child in a place where he could be found. He did not leave him in a safe environment. He buried the boy in a dog crate.
The physics of survival
Koah Sharp survived for approximately 24 hours under the earth. He was found Tuesday afternoon in Lexington County, South Carolina. Searchers heard the baby crying from beneath the soil. CNN said the infant was "clinging to life" and "screaming at the top of his lungs" when he was unearthed.
The rescue was a desperate race against time. This mirrors the Tham Luang cave rescue, where searchers fought a similar race against time to extract a trapped person from an underground enclosure using specialized search efforts. In South Carolina, the race ended when searchers found freshly disturbed dirt in pine straw near the home of Michael Comer's father.
The baby was inside a 2-foot-by-2-foot dog crate. The crate was wrapped in a towel. Sheriff Jay Koon said the towel likely created an air pocket that allowed the child to breathe.
The weather also played a role. Temperatures in the Batesburg-Leesville area dropped to roughly 40 degrees Fahrenheit from Monday night into Tuesday morning. Sheriff Koon said the cool weather may have helped the boy survive.
The search for the child was massive. Over 100 law enforcement officers and personnel searched central South Carolina. The effort included the FBI, firefighters, and the federal Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives.
Michael Comer has a history of violence
The survival of Koah Sharp was a fluke of physics and temperature. It was not an act of mercy by the father. Michael Comer has a history that predicted this violence. South Carolina court records show he pleaded guilty earlier this year to assault and battery and domestic violence.
The state had already identified Comer as a danger. He was placed on probation about a month before this arrest following a guilty plea for aggravated breach of peace. He also had arrests earlier this year for a weapons-related charge.
The timeline of the abduction shows a calculated disappearance. Koah Sharp's mother told a sheriff's deputy that Comer threatened her over Facebook Messenger that he would keep the child. She allowed him to have the boy briefly, expecting it to last a day or two.
The disappearance happened quickly. A missing persons case was reported at 12:28 p.m. Monday. By 12:30 p.m., Patricia Comer returned home and found that both her son and grandson were gone.
Why did supervision fail?
The state's supervision of Michael Comer failed. He was on probation for violent behavior. He was a known domestic abuser. Yet he had access to a child.
The sequence of Monday morning shows a man preparing for a crime. At 5:45 a.m., Patricia Comer saw him preparing formula for the baby. At 8:30 a.m., video showed him walking through the house.
By 11:30 a.m., formula left by a friend remained at the home. The child was gone.
Comer did not flee with the baby. Surveillance footage from Monday afternoon showed him at several businesses without the child. He had already put the boy in the ground.
He then hid. At 6:30 p.m. Monday, Comer entered a shed in the Batesburg area. Investigators found him in that outbuilding at 10 p.m. Monday.
The defense will likely argue that Comer was in a mental health crisis. His mother told authorities he made previous suicidal statements. He told her he planned to take the boy to New York to find work.
This argument fails. A mental health crisis does not result in the precise act of wrapping a crate in a towel and burying it in the woods. That is a method of execution. It is a choice to remove a human being from the world of the living.
The Lexington County Sheriff's Department now handles the case. The agency has a history of institutional instability. In 2015, longtime county sheriff James Metts pleaded guilty to conspiring to harbor and conceal illegal aliens and accepting bribes.
The department has spent years recovering from that corruption. Now it must answer for how a man on probation for domestic violence was able to abduct and bury his son.
Koah Sharp was released from the hospital Tuesday night. A family member told WIS News 10 that the boy came home "exhausted and hungry." His medical team says he is expected to make a full recovery.
Michael Comer is in custody. He faces a bond hearing. The facts of his history and the facts of the burial prove that he is a predator.
The state failed to protect Koah Sharp by leaving a violent offender on a loose leash. Probation is a tool for rehabilitation, but it is a failure when it ignores a pattern of domestic abuse. When a man is known to be violent and is given the opportunity to take a child, the state shares the blame for the result. Michael Comer attempted to murder his son, and the system gave him the chance.
Sources
- NBC News: Father charged with attempted murder after baby survives being buried in crate
- CNN: Clinging to life and crying, a baby was found buried alive a day after his father took him, investigators say
- WIS News 10: Father of baby found buried alive in Lexington County facing new charges
- CBC News: Father of baby who was rescued after being buried alive is charged with attempted murder
- Infobae: Un bebé de 11 meses fue rescatado tras ser enterrado vivo en una jaula para perros