Jim Jordan's election proves the GOP rewards destruction

By Maya Ellison · Reporting from Detroit ·

By electing Jim Jordan to lead their shrunken minority, House Republicans proved they value performative obstruction over governing while working people foot the bill for their destruction.

The Republican Party has finally decided that the arsonist is the best person to lead the fire department. By electing Rep. Jim Jordan as their top leader, House Republicans have signaled that they value the act of breaking things over the act of governing. Jordan is not a legislator. He is a disruptor who has spent his career treating the House of Representatives like a demolition site. For the people in my hometown of Flint, who need a government that actually functions to fix poisoned pipes and failing schools, this is a disaster. It is a victory for a faction that views the basic operations of democracy as an obstacle to be overcome.

The reward for legislative failure

Jim Jordan is the co-founder and first chair of the House Freedom Caucus. House Republicans chose Jordan to lead them despite their losses. His record is a void. Jordan has never been a primary sponsor of legislation that passed in the House. He does not build policies. He does not compromise. He simply destroys.

Former Speaker John Boehner told CBS News that Jordan is a political "terrorist." Boehner noted that Jordan spent more time "tearing things apart" than "building anything." Politico reports that the GOP is on track to hold the smallest House minority any party has had in more than 30 years. Jordan is now the leader of a shrunken army, yet he is the only one they trust to lead the charge.

A blueprint for institutional sabotage

The GOP's most loyal advocates call this "fighting." Rep. Nicole Malliotakis says Jordan is a "fighter" who can "bring everyone together." Rep. Ralph Norman argues that Jordan represents the side of the party "willing to fight." They frame his inability to govern as a virtue. They claim that his aggression is exactly what a minority leader needs to challenge the opposition.

This is a lie. Fighting for your constituents means passing laws that lower their rent or protect their health. Jordan does not do that. He specializes in the 2011 budget impasse, a fiscal crisis pertaining to the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. He learned that if you hold the government hostage, you get the spotlight. Jordan is the architect of this wreckage.

The corporate mirror

Democratic Leader Hakeem Jeffries is expected to become House speaker in January. On the surface, this looks like a clash between a builder and a breaker. But if you follow the money, the view changes.

Jeffries has accepted $1 million in campaign contributions from the American Israel Public Affairs Committee. He has also shifted away from his prior support for Medicare for All. While Jordan uses the theater of the right to ignore the working class, Jeffries is backed by the same corporate interests that keep our healthcare bankrupt and our wages flat. The fight between Jordan and Jeffries will be loud, but it will not be for us. It is a battle between two different styles of leadership that both answer to concentrated wealth.

Jim Jordan will use his new post to launch endless performative investigations into federal agencies. He will treat the House as a stage for partisan theater while starving social safety net programs of real oversight. He has spent a decade proving that he prefers a shutdown to a solution. Working people will foot the bill for this obsession with destruction. Justice would require a leader who views a passed bill as a victory, not a betrayal. Instead, the GOP has crowned the man who has never built a single thing.

Sources

  1. Politico: The Freedom Caucus comes to grips with a new reality: They won the war
  2. CBS News: With Jim Jordan as leader, House Republicans signal they're ready to fight
  3. NPR: Rep. Jim Jordan will lead House Republicans next year. What's his leadership style?