House Republicans pick Jim Jordan to lead a caucus of defiance
By Adele Rutherford · Reporting from Atlanta ·
By choosing Jim Jordan as minority leader, House Republicans elevated a record of procedural obstruction over governance, signaling that institutional defiance now outweighs public accountability.
The elevation of denial
House Republicans selected Representative Jim Jordan of Ohio to lead their party as minority leader, according to Defector reporting. This choice tells you precisely where the party’s heart lives after losing more than 40 seats in the midterm elections, as CBS News noted. They did not look for a builder. They looked for a cudgel.
Mr. Jordan is a founding member of the House Freedom Caucus and a former college wrestling coach. Per CBS News, he has never been a primary sponsor of legislation that passed in the House. That is not a resume for lawmaking. It is a rap sheet for motion without momentum.
As former House Speaker John Boehner observed to CBS News, "I just never saw a guy who spent more time tearing things apart, never building anything, never putting anything together." Yet Representative Nicole Malliotakis told CBS News that "Jim's a fighter" and that he can "bring everyone together."
That logic requires a peculiar definition of unity. It is the unity of the barricade, where everyone agrees to lock the door from the inside.
We have seen this script before. During the Tea Party movement (2010-2011), the Republican Party discovered the short-term thrill of elevating factional leaders who prioritized ideological purity and confrontational tactics over legislative achievement. That wave swept dozens of hardliners into office on the promise of stopping government. They soon discovered that stopping government leaves you with nothing to govern with when your own turn comes.
Mr. Jordan’s elevation also recalls his central role during the first impeachment of Donald Trump (2018-2023). In that proceeding, he established a pattern of using procedural tools to block inquiries rather than facilitate them. He defended executive power by denying oversight.
He then ignored a subpoena from the House panel investigating the January 6 United States Capitol attack (2018-2023). In doing so, he demonstrated a consistent refusal to comply with investigative oversight when it touches his own allies.
This brings us directly to the parallel that illuminates his entire career: the Ohio State University sexual abuse scandal. The mechanism is identical: the elevation of a leader who consistently denies documented allegations of misconduct to signal a commitment to defiance over accountability.
Team physician Richard Strauss sexually abused at least 177 male student-patients, according to investigative reports. Mr. Jordan served as an assistant wrestling coach at Ohio State during that period.
Former wrestlers and staff have stated repeatedly that Mr. Jordan knew what was happening. Former wrestler Dunyasha Yetts stated that coach Russ Hellickson told him he would defend Mr. Jordan until forced to tell the truth on a Bible. Whistleblower Mike DiSabato, the first wrestler to speak publicly, stated: "I considered Jim Jordan a friend. But at the end of the day, he is absolutely lying if he says he doesn't know what was going on."
Mr. Jordan has consistently denied knowing about the sexual abuse, dismissing his accusers as political pawns. But whistleblower Mike DiSabato recently renewed his call for Mr. Jordan to testify under oath. When the party chooses a leader under such a cloud, it is not merely looking the other way. It is declaring that denial of the unpalatable is a prerequisite for leadership.
The lame duck barricade
The consequences of this bunker mentality were on immediate display during the lame-duck session. Even as Republicans retained a narrow majority before a Democratic majority takes over the House in January, House Republicans voted 211 to 204 to send an impeachment resolution against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth to the Judiciary Committee, derailing a floor vote, as reported by SBS News.
The impeachment articles, introduced by outgoing Republican critic Thomas Massie, accused Mr. Hegseth of violating the War Powers Resolution regarding the Iran war and conducting extrajudicial killings through strikes on drug-smuggling boats in the Caribbean and eastern Pacific. Mr. Hegseth dismissed the push as a farce, a stunt, slander, and sabotage, while President Donald Trump praised him and called Mr. Massie a "TOTAL LOSER!"
Mr. Jordan’s new caucus is designed precisely for these kinds of procedural entanglements. When the minority party’s primary skill is obstruction, governance becomes an exercise in running out the clock. Representative Andy Harris told CBS News he wants to see Mr. Jordan go head-to-head with incoming Democratic leaders, predicting Mr. Jordan will hold his own. Holding your own is not the same as passing a budget, securing a border, or maintaining infrastructure. It is simply standing in the middle of the room and daring anyone to move you.
When you test this procedural shortcut against the day your opponents hold the tool, the danger is glaring. If the minority's sole purpose is to weaponize committee rooms against executive branch actions, then the opposition will do precisely the same thing the moment power shifts back. We are building a legislative branch made entirely of tripwires.
The Republican conference has chosen a leader whose entire career is an argument against institutional norms. By placing Jim Jordan at the helm, House Republicans have traded the hard, boring work of legislation for the performative theater of the permanent campaign. They have told the country that fighting matters more than functioning, and that loyalty to a faction outweighs fidelity to the truth.