Putin offers no ground in Moscow as Starlink speeds fall
By Tom Beckwith · Reporting from Washington ·
While US envoys meet Vladimir Putin in Moscow as Starlink speed limits hit Ukrainian defense, Washington risks trading long-term strategic credibility for empty diplomatic statements.
Interests first, capabilities second, statements last
Let us read the diplomatic cable before we read the press releases. The interests of the capitals involved have not shifted by an inch. Vladimir Putin demands full control over four Ukrainian regions that Moscow claims to have annexed. In The Guardian, he ruled out foreign peacekeeping troops, describing them as a "continuation of war." He wants the surrender of the entire eastern region of Donbas, as Daily Maverick reported. Across the table, the capabilities deployed by Washington are personal and informal. US envoys Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff have made numerous visits to Russia. As Daily Maverick noted, this marks the 10th time Steve Witkoff has met Vladimir Putin in person. But capability is not just shuttle diplomacy; it is also infrastructure. Volodymyr Zelenskyy accused Elon Musk’s Starlink satellite service of damaging Ukraine’s ability to defend against Russian drone attacks. He reported that Starshield, a Pentagon-funded military version of Starlink, has faced speed limits of 100mph along the frontline. The restrictions have applied in Russian-occupied territory for several days. Daily Maverick observed that US President Trump has expressed public optimism while no sign of major compromises has emerged. The statements come last. Steve Witkoff spoke to reporters at Vnukovo Airport, as Ukrinform reported. "I think progress was made," he told them. "I think it was made earlier today." Statements are cheap. Speeds on satellite terminals are expensive.
The Minsk II parallel and the architecture of a frozen trap
Some argue these bilateral sessions allow personal diplomacy to cut through bureaucratic inertia, much like the Abraham Accords. That case fails on the historical record. The proper parallel is Minsk II. The Minsk agreements were international agreements seeking to end the Donbas War. The conflict pitted armed Russian separatist groups, backed by Russian regular forces, against the Armed Forces of Ukraine. By August 2014, Ukraine had re-taken most of the territory seized by separatists. Russia then covertly invaded the Donbas to support the separatists, inflicting a heavy defeat on the Ukrainians at Ilovaisk. Peace talks took place in Minsk, Belarus. They involved the Trilateral Contact Group, with mediation by France and Germany in the Normandy Format. The mechanism shared with today's talks in Abu Dhabi and Moscow is identical. It uses ceasefire agreements and territorial concessions in the Donbas. This manages a frozen conflict while the stronger power digests its gains. Vladimir Medinsky leads Russia's negotiating delegation. As DW.com reported, he stated there was "no possibility whatsoever for such exchanges" regarding territorial concessions. The negotiators in Minsk similarly found themselves boxed in by immovable Russian demands. Pretending Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff can bypass this structural reality through real estate optimism is a mistake. It misreads every cable filed from the region over the past decade.
The European reaction and the price five years out
The friction between Washington and its allies exposes the cost of bypassing institutional channels. As reported by The Guardian, EU foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas stated, "We already have a European security architecture in place." She cited the Helsinki accords and the Budapest memorandum as existing guarantees for the territorial integrity of Ukraine. Kallas described focusing on a European security architecture as a "distraction" without a ceasefire. She added that "the problem is that Russia is not keeping to those agreements, so right now the focus should be that Russia actually keeps to their obligations." Yet Steve Witkoff confirmed European representatives will join the next round of talks. According to The Guardian, he stated, "They’re our partners, and it’s important for them to be involved." Meanwhile, French president Emmanuel Macron noted the limits of the current mediation, as The Guardian recorded. He stated that "There is no more US support. So there [are] some mediations, fine." But he added, "At the end of the day we will be the one to define and decide for our future security as Europeans." Price this move five years out. Washington might trade Ukrainian territory for a signed piece of paper without enforcement mechanisms. If so, the credibility of every American security guarantee from the Baltic to the Pacific is discounted to zero. The prisoner exchanges agreed to in Abu Dhabi brought welcome relief for families involved. DW.com reported the event as a significant humanitarian release. Yet those exchanges do not alter the strategic balance. A state's word in foreign capitals must be a firm commitment, not negotiable theater. When it is treated as theater, allies look elsewhere for insurance, and adversaries stop listening altogether.
Sources
- The Guardian: Putin takes hard line in US talks as Ukraine says Starlink disrupted again
- DW.com: US, Russia and Ukraine wrap up Abu Dhabi talks with teams agreeing to a prisoner exchange
- Daily Maverick: US envoys arrive in Moscow for latest round of Ukrainian peace talks with Putin
- Ukrinform: Witkoff, Kushner hope Europe will join next round of peace talks after meeting with Putin