New York City DOB failed Flatbush residents in deadly collapse

By Maya Ellison · Reporting from Detroit ·

A building collapse in Flatbush killed at least two people after the Department of Buildings ignored safety warnings, proving that developer profit still outweighs human life in Brooklyn.

The blood on the pavement in Flatbush is not the result of an accident. It is the result of a choice. When a three-story building at 1321 Flatbush Ave. pancaked into a construction pit on Wednesday, it didn't just crush bricks and wood. It crushed the lives of a predominantly Black and Afro-Caribbean community. At least two people are dead. One of the dead is a child. This tragedy was predictable. It was written in the city's own records months ago. The New York City Department of Buildings (DOB) is responsible. They let a developer treat safety codes as suggestions and a stop-work order as a nuisance. In my hometown of Flint, we learned that when the state ignores the warnings, the poor pay in poison. In Brooklyn, the poison is greed, and the cost is a child's life.

The rubble of regulatory failure

The collapse happened when a mixed-use building fell into an open construction site at 2625 Bedford Ave. According to CNN, construction workers were "digging down" inside the site when the ground gave way. The violence of the event was absolute. Muhammad Aziz, a store owner, heard a "blast" and saw "full fog" of dust. He saw people standing on top of a building while their walls vanished.

The human toll is staggering. Lillian Bonsignore, the FDNY Commissioner, reported 19 total patients. Seven of these victims are children. The rescue was a nightmare of "precarious wreckage," as Mayor Zohran Mamdani described it. Firefighters spent hours pulling people from the debris.

But we must look past the "heroic work" of the FDNY. We have to follow the money downward. ABC News reports the construction site was approved for a three-story building. However, plans for a nine-story building had been floated. This is the classic developer's gambit: push the limits of the land to squeeze out more profit. The ghosts of the Surfside condominium collapse haunt this scene. Like in Florida, the warnings were there. They were just ignored by people who didn't live in the building.

The loophole that kills

The Department of Buildings didn't just miss the signs. They saw them and did nothing. Spectrum News NY1 reports that the DOB recorded multiple issues in May at the project next door. The developer was working while under a stop-work order. They failed to provide proper overhead protection for neighboring properties. They ignored approved construction drawings.

This is not a case of a few "bad apples." It is a systemic failure. The DOB, led by Commissioner Ahmed Tigani, relies on a self-certification program. This system allows private architects and engineers to bypass full plan reviews. It is a gift to developers. It lets the people making the profit vouch for their own safety. I spent years organizing in union halls where we fought this kind of corner-cutting. When you remove the government's role as a counterweight, you aren't "streamlining" bureaucracy. You are outsourcing public safety to the highest bidder.

The building at 1321 Flatbush Ave. was already fragile. City records show 98 total violations dating back to 1972. The city knew this building was a risk. The city knew the neighbor was a rogue operator. Yet, the excavation continued. New York City has a long record of letting developers gamble with the lives of tenants. The house always wins, and the tenants always lose.

A global ledger of greed

The most capable advocate for the city would argue this was an unforeseeable event. They would claim a geological anomaly or an unpredictable structural failure caused the collapse. They would say the DOB did its job by issuing the stop-work order in May.

That argument is a lie. A stop-work order is only as good as the enforcement behind it. If a developer can ignore a legal order and keep digging, the order is just a piece of paper. The failure is not the "anomaly." The failure is the lack of a boot on the ground to stop the machines.

This is the Rana Plaza collapse in a Brooklyn zip code. The mechanism is identical: prioritizing rapid expansion and industrial profit over basic structural safety and worker protections results in mass casualty events. In Bangladesh, it was garment factories. In Flatbush, it is mixed-use real estate. Both are driven by the same hunger for growth at any cost. It is the same logic that fueled the Turkey-Syria earthquake deaths, where "construction amnesty" laws let developers ignore codes for a fee.

My generation's ledger is full of these "accidents." We saw the 2008 crash take the houses on my block because banks lied about the risk. We saw the water in Flint turn brown because officials lied about the lead. Now we see a building in Brooklyn fall because the DOB let a contractor lie about the safety. The pattern is a straight line. Concentrated wealth buys concentrated power, and that power is used to deregulate the things that keep us alive.

The city will call this a "devastating collapse." They will hold our neighbors in their hearts. But hearts do not stop buildings from falling. Inspections do. Enforcement does. Ending the self-certification loophole does.

Ahmed Tigani and the Department of Buildings must answer for why a stop-work order in May didn't stop a collapse in November. Justice for the families in Flatbush requires more than a Red Cross center at the YMCA. It requires the immediate end of the self-certification program. We cannot allow private profit to certify public safety. Until the city treats a stop-work order as a mandate rather than a suggestion, more children will end up under the rubble. The DOB didn't just fail to inspect a site; they failed to protect the people. They traded the lives of Brooklyn residents for the convenience of a developer.

Sources

  1. ABC7 New York: Brooklyn building collapse: At least 2 people dead, more than a dozen hurt in Flatbush
  2. CNN: Massive rescue effort underway after NYC building collapse leaves at least 1 dead, 12 injured, officials say
  3. Spectrum News NY1: People trapped in collapsed Brooklyn building, FDNY says
  4. ABC News: At least 2 dead, multiple injured after building collapses in Brooklyn: Mayor
  5. El País: Al menos dos muertos y varios heridos tras derrumbarse un edificio en un barrio residencial en Brooklyn
  6. The Guardian: Brooklyn building collapse kills at least one and traps others in wreckage