Pete Hegseth trades military readiness for a culture war
By Daniel Okafor · Reporting from New York ·
Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth is purging officers and mocking leadership to instill a warrior ethos, a move that ignores the human cost of war and risks force readiness.
Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth is treating the United States military like a political club. By purging qualified officers and mocking the leadership of the force, he is dismantling the professional standards that keep soldiers alive. He claims to seek a "warrior ethos," but his actions target the people who execute the mission rather than the threats they face. Hegseth is wrong to prioritize ideological purity over the stability of the command structure.
The cost of a curated force
Hegseth has spent his tenure removing people he dislikes. He fired female officers without cause and stripped qualified women from promotion lists. He argues that women should not serve in combat roles, according to MS NOW. This is not a strategic shift in capability. It is a purge.
The Pentagon briefly removed a webpage about the military service of Jackie Robinson. It is now considering removing Doris Miller’s name from a ship under construction.
The Secretary does not hide his contempt for the current leadership. In September 2025, Hegseth and President Donald Trump summoned commanders to Quantico, Virginia. Hegseth mocked "fat generals," facial hair, and "dudes in dresses," MS NOW reported. He delivered a similar rant to 600 junior officers months earlier.
While Hegseth focuses on facial hair and dresses, he oversees a Defense Policy Board focused on trade strategy. This disconnect suggests a leadership more interested in the image of strength than the mechanics of it. He shut down an Army unit that studied lessons from the war in Ukraine. He describes respect for international law as an "example of weakness."
Long deployments strain the ranks
The "warrior ethos" Hegseth promotes does not ease the burden on the soldiers in the field. The war in Iran has created a punishing operational tempo. The aircraft carrier USS Abraham Lincoln deployed for more than 300 days. The destroyer USS Spruance deployed for 342 days, which is a post-World War II record.
A brigade from the 82nd Airborne Division spent eight months in the region. They recently received notice that their deployment extends into next year.
Hegseth acts as a "hype man" for the president, as he did during a speech aboard the USS George Washington. But the people in the ranks feel the gap between the rhetoric and the reality. A recent poll indicates many military personnel feel abandoned by society and politicians. Many plan to leave the service.
Why do military medals matter?
Veterans Day is not a victory celebration. It is a day to remember the cost of conflict. In New Brunswick, 91-year-old retired lieutenant-colonel Alan Kennedy recently had his home invaded. Three people tied him to a chair with zip ties and stole his military medals, according to CBC News.
For a soldier, losing those medals is a "stab in the heart," said David Hughes, a retired captain. Hughes arranged for replica medals so Kennedy could wear them on November 11. These medals represent 32 years of service and tours in Cyprus, India, and Pakistan. They are not trophies of a culture war. They are records of sacrifice.
This is the same mechanism at work in World War I. National memorials commemorate the shared tragedy and the human cost of global conflict. In New Zealand, more than 18,000 people died in the First World War, said Neill Atkinson, the chief historian for the Ministry of Culture and Heritage. RNZ reported that thousands more returned with psychological scars.
The lesson of the First World War is that governments must take decisions about armed conflict seriously. They must recognize the impact on their people. When a leader mocks the officers who manage that impact, he erodes the trust required to lead them into battle.
Hegseth's focus on appearance and ideology will accelerate the exit of seasoned leadership. Recruitment numbers may stay high because the civilian job market is cooling. But the military cannot survive on new recruits alone. It needs the mid-grade officers and senior NCOs who understand how to fight and how to lead. If the Pentagon continues to prioritize political loyalty over professional competence, it will face a crisis of readiness that no "hype man" speech can fix.