Los Angeles failed street vendors in North Hollywood crash

By Daniel Okafor · Reporting from New York ·

A white SUV killed three people near a Metro station, exposing the city's failure to provide physical barriers for street vendors working on the sidewalk.

The city of Los Angeles left its most vulnerable workers exposed to a known hazard. On Tuesday, a white SUV drove onto a sidewalk and crushed a group of pedestrians and street vendors. Three people died. At least three others were critically injured. While the police search for a cause, the failure is already visible. The city allows people to build their livelihoods on strips of concrete with nothing but a curb to protect them from two-ton machines.

The anatomy of a rush hour crash

The crash happened around 5:55 p.m. in the 5300 block of North Lankershim Boulevard. It was the height of the Tuesday rush hour. According to ABC7 Los Angeles, the vehicle struck people near a Metro station entrance. The SUV headed southbound before it jumped the curb.

The impact was sudden. Gian Barbarona said he felt the wind of the whoosh on his left shoulder. Luis Luna-Guzman, who works at a burger stand, heard a loud boom. He saw food and cups scattered across the ground. Luna-Guzman found an injured woman near bike racks with blood on her face, arms, and legs. He told her help was coming. Nearby, he saw a woman's body and another woman lying unmoving on the station stairs.

The vehicle ended up under a food vendor’s tent, the Dallas News said. The driver, a man in his 60s, had to be extricated from the SUV. He was conscious but appeared to be in shock. He was transported to a hospital in critical condition.

The victims were not random passersby. At least two of the dead were food vendors who had operated outside the Metro station for years. NBC Los Angeles said two women selling hot dogs were thrown in the air by the impact. One vendor was a fixture of the neighborhood.

A known mechanism of death

The police are now treating the sidewalk as a crime scene. LAPD Chief Jim McDonnell said investigators will review video frame-by-frame. Captain Warner Castillo said they do not know if the act was intentional or an accident. The police are testing the driver for substances.

This debate over intent is a distraction. The mechanism of the tragedy is the use of a vehicle to strike a crowd in a public space. This is the same mechanism seen in the 2016 Nice attack, where a cargo truck drove into crowds on the Promenade des Anglais. Whether the driver is a terrorist or a confused senior, the result is the same. The sidewalk offers no defense.

The world has seen this pattern repeat. In the 2017 London Bridge attack, a van struck pedestrians in a busy urban area. In the 2019 Toronto pedestrian attack, a vehicle drove onto a sidewalk and killed 11 people.

Each of these events proves that a curb is not a barrier. When a city encourages high-density pedestrian activity and street commerce, it assumes the risk of vehicle incursions. The North Hollywood intersection of Lankershim and Chandler is a constantly active place. To leave it open to a speeding SUV is a policy choice.

Heartbreak is not a safety measure

Mayor Karen Bass said she is heartbroken for the families. Her words carry a weight the public record does not show. In 2006, Bass lost her daughter and son-in-law in a car crash. She knows the suddenness of vehicle-driven death.

Still, heartbreak is not a safety measure. The city's response has been to coordinate departments and review footage. This is the standard reaction to a disaster, but it does not prevent the next one.

The strongest case for the city is that such crashes are rare and unpredictable. An advocate for the current layout would argue that installing heavy barriers would obstruct the flow of pedestrians and the setup of vendors. They would say the city cannot put a wall around every Metro entrance.

That argument fails because it prioritizes convenience over survival. The victims in North Hollywood were not just pedestrians. They were workers. They spent their days in a fixed location, making them stationary targets for any driver who loses control or finds a motive. A worker should not have to gamble their life on the sobriety or health of every driver on Lankershim Boulevard.

The long record of urban planning shows a clear solution. Cities that value pedestrian life install bollards. These steel or concrete posts stop a vehicle while allowing a person to pass. They turn a potential massacre into a fender-bender.

The police will eventually finish their "prolonged but very deliberate investigation," as Chief McDonnell called it. They will find a medical reason or a criminal one. They will determine if the man in his 60s suffered a stroke or a lapse in judgment.

None of those facts change the geography of the sidewalk. The driver's condition is a medical or legal matter. The lack of bollards is a municipal failure. The city of Los Angeles knows that vehicles can and do jump curbs. It knows that street vendors are a permanent part of the transit landscape. By failing to separate the two with physical steel, the city accepted the risk on behalf of people who had no say in the matter.

Sources

  1. ABC7 Los Angeles: 3 dead after car crashes into street vendors, pedestrians near Metro station in North Hollywood
  2. Dallas News: Minivan crashes into people outside Los Angeles metro station, killing 3
  3. CNN: At least 3 people dead after vehicle strikes pedestrians in North Hollywood, officials say
  4. NBC Los Angeles: 3 dead, at least 3 injured after vehicle strikes pedestrians in North Hollywood
  5. CNA: 3 dead after vehicle crashes into people in North Hollywood