Stephen Miller cannot win back the working class he broke

By Alma Cordero · Reporting from El Paso ·

After midterm losses, Donald Trump named Stephen Miller chief of staff to win back young men, but a record of executive cruelty makes him the wrong man for the job.

The young men who walked away from the GOP in the midterms did not do so because they forgot how to be "real men." They left because they cannot afford their rent. They left because the tariffs they were promised would protect them instead drove up the price of everything in their carts. They left because they are tired of a government that views their families as a security threat. Now, Donald Trump has installed Stephen Miller as White House chief of staff to "win them back." It is a delusion. You cannot court the working class with the same man who spent years designing the machinery to crush them.

The math of the abandoned

The numbers are not a fluke; they are a scream. According to a Tufts University study cited by Axios and The Daily Beast, Democrats won young men by 22 points in the midterms. That is a 36-point shift. For young Latino men, the collapse was even steeper, favoring Democrats by 37 points.

These men are not drifting; they are fleeing. More than half of voters cited jobs and the economy as top issues. Specifically, 73% of young voters who felt they were falling behind financially backed Democratic House candidates. They are reacting to the real-world cost of a war in Iran and a trade agenda that treats the dinner table like a chessboard. Miller thinks he can fix this with "permitting reform" and a crackdown on "woke" policies in colleges. He is offering a paint job to a house that is currently on fire.

The architect of the skull-crack

To understand why this will fail, you have to look at who Stephen Miller actually is. He is not a policy wonk; he is a demolition man. MS NOW reports that Trump wanted someone who "will crack skulls." Miller has already proven he is happy to do it. He authored every executive order Trump signed this term. He pushed to declare an "invasion" on the southern border to unlock emergency powers. He even tried to overrule the birthright citizenship clause of the Constitution.

This is the same mechanism used in the Muslim Ban. In both cases, Miller uses executive orders to target specific demographic groups through restrictive policies that cause real human harm. The cruelty is the point. MS NOW notes that Miller engineered missile strikes on alleged drug boats that ended more than 200 lives. He pressured Department of Homeland Security officials to meet arrest quotas immediately after the election. When you spend your career treating people like targets, you cannot suddenly pretend to be their champion.

The myth of the populist fighter

The most ardent defenders of Miller will tell you he is a necessary fighter. They will argue that his focus on lowering prescription drug prices and rooting out government fraud proves he cares about the little guy. They will say that his loyalty to the MAGA base is the only way to save the country from a "woke" bureaucracy.

But loyalty is a two-way street, and Miller’s loyalty is only to the man at the top. He pledged "absolute loyalty" and "total devotion" to Trump at Mar-a-Lago. He does not make deals with people. Even his own side knows this. A House Republican told MS NOW that Miller is "the last step to burning down the Republican Party." If the man in charge of the White House is viewed as a liability by his own party, he has no hope of convincing a disillusioned 22-year-old Latino man that the GOP has his back.

Incoming House speaker Hakeem Jeffries has "zero interest" in working with Miller. That is a rational response to a man who views the separation of powers as a nuisance. Miller and Russell Vought are already charting an agenda of executive actions that bypass Congress entirely. They want the power of a king without the accountability of a representative.

Stephen Miller is the wrong man for this moment because he believes strength is found only in force. He thinks the working class can be bullied back into the fold with rhetoric about "beta" men and "woke" colleges. But the people doing the hardest work in this country are not fooled by the performance. Justice would require an immigration system based on visas instead of cages and a wage floor that actually sustains a family. Instead, we have a man who views the border as a battlefield and the worker as a tool. Miller will not win back the working class; he will only finish the job of alienating them.

Sources

  1. Axios: Scoop — Stephen Miller's post-midterm focus: MAGA and men
  2. The Daily Beast: Stephen Miller’s Secret Scramble to Stop MAGA Exodus Revealed
  3. MS NOW: Opinion | Stephen Miller will go too far