Los Angeles council pivots to Nithya Raman out of self-interest

By Dana Whitfield · Reporting from Washington ·

After unanimously opposing Nithya Raman during the mayoral campaign, Los Angeles City Council members now offer forced cooperation, proving that self-interest trumps old grudges.

From campaign venom to calculated pragmatism in City Hall

Every single one of Nithya Raman's fourteen council colleagues opposed her run for mayor, preferring incumbent Mayor Karen Bass. During the bitter race, Councilmember Monica Rodriguez called Raman's decision to challenge Bass "disgusting" and "backstabbing." Imelda Padilla dismissed Raman's time running the Housing and Homelessness Committee as "unproductive." Traci Park even questioned whether Raman "stands for anything at all." Then the ballots were counted, Raman won, and the tone in City Hall shifted with remarkable speed. At her first council meeting back, those same critics offered gracious welcomes and promises of full backing. Councilmember Curren Price summed up the new mood with neat candor, stating, “Full disclosure, you know that I didn’t support you last week. But you’ve got my full support now.”

As Pomona College politics professor Sara Sadhwani noted in the Los Angeles Times, politicians are rational actors. They make a calculated pivot to play nice because the mayor approves the budget and spotlights local priorities. This dynamic echoes the 1990s realignment, sharing the exact mechanism of a sharp shift in the structure of power within a government. The institutional reality of Los Angeles governance under the city charter leaves little room for permanent feuds. The city council operates with fifteen members earning $218,000 per year, tied directly to judicial pay, making self-preservation the ultimate legislative guide. Mike Bonin, former council member and head of the Pat Brown Institute of Public Affairs at Cal State Los Angeles, pointed out that most members want to get things done for their districts. They avoid a combative relationship with the executive.

The limits of political amnesia and legislative math

The strongest opposing case argues that this sudden warmth signals genuine institutional healing after a grueling campaign. Proponents of this view point to Council President Marqueece Harris-Dawson introducing Raman as the embodiment of what Los Angeles is. They point to soothing words from Raman herself about how their political differences are just getting "spicy." LAist reported a surge of optimism among transit and safer street advocates who see Raman's victory as a mandate for change. But this optimistic reading ignores the long record of deep-seated fractures inside City Hall. That includes the 2022 council scandal where leadership conspired to gerrymander Raman's district to suppress her base. The sudden harmony is not conversion; it is arithmetic.

Raman herself acknowledged the friction, noting that their passion makes them get spicy about policy differences. Yet Harris-Dawson, Bass's closest ally on the council, previously removed Raman as chair of the Housing and Homelessness Committee during the campaign. Raman called the move political retaliation. ABC7 Los Angeles covered the warm welcome at the council chambers, but polite words on a Tuesday morning will not survive the hard trade-offs of the spring budget cycle.

The hard arithmetic of municipal governance ahead

The magical thinking on display comes from both flanks. Insurgents believe a mayoral win erases entrenched council parochialism, while the old guard imagine they can pocket a photo-op and return to business as usual. Neither camp has priced in the fiscal reality of running a city of fifteen districts across 501 square miles under a strong mayor-council framework. Councilmember Monica Rodriguez warned that where they align they will work together, and where they do not she will fiercely oppose. That is the honest baseline every citizen should carry into the voting booth.

Raman takes office next month facing severe structural headwinds, a skeptical legislative body, and high expectations from grassroots voters who want safer streets and reliable services. The workable answer is neither perpetual war nor naive harmony, but the gritty institutional trade-offs that make municipal budgets pass on time. If Raman uses her executive veto and her seat on the Metro board to force fiscal discipline, her former critics will keep playing nice out of raw self-preservation.

Sources

  1. Los Angeles Times: Raman’s colleagues all opposed her run for mayor. Now some promise ‘full support’
  2. LAist: Raman’s win triggers surge of optimism among advocates of transit and safer streets in LA
  3. ABC7 Los Angeles: Nithya Raman receives warm welcome from Los Angeles City Council at 1st meeting after election win