Kennedy Family Joins Effort to Block Construction of Trump’s Arch

By Adele Rutherford · Reporting from Atlanta ·

Nine members of the Kennedy family sued to block a 250-foot arch, arguing it lacks congressional approval and ruins Arlington National Cemetery, a claim the administration cannot defeat.

The Trump administration is wrong. It is not wrong because a gilded arch is an eyesore. It is not wrong because the Kennedy family finds the design distasteful. It is wrong because the administration has attempted to bypass the basic machinery of the law to build a 250-foot structure on hallowed ground.

The fiction of the 1925 plan

The administration claims it does not need congressional approval. It relies on a 1925 plan for 166-foot columns that were never built. The White House argues this century-old ghost of a project grants them the power to erect a massive arch today.

This is a procedural fiction. A dead plan for columns is not a license for a triumphal arch. To argue otherwise is to say that any executive can reach back a hundred years to find a scrap of paper that justifies a modern whim.

The administration also avoided the public eye in its early steps. It used an existing AECOM contract to begin site survey work. This allowed them to bypass the public bidding process. This is not leadership. It is administrative plumbing used to evade oversight.

The disruption of sacred space

The legal battle now involves nine members of the Kennedy family. They are children and grandchildren of Senators Robert and Edward Kennedy. Represented by Norm Eisen and Steve Jonas, they filed a motion to block the project. They argue the arch would "fundamentally disrupt" the relationship between the Lincoln Memorial, the Kennedy gravesites, and the Eternal Flame.

The family's filings are heavy with sentiment. They speak of "solace" and finding time to "pray and reflect." While these feelings are personal, the legal injury is spatial. The plaintiffs allege the structure would permanently cast shadows over and damage historically significant sightlines.

The Vietnam Veterans Memorial shares the same mechanism of conflict over the legal authorization and aesthetic disruption of a national memorial's sacred space. In both cases, the fight is about who decides what a national space means and who has the legal right to change it.

The damage is not just a matter of opinion. A National Park Service review released in August acknowledged the arch would have "adverse" effects on as many as 42 historic sites. CNN reports that opponents argue the monument would break the solemnity of funerals at Arlington National Cemetery.

The failure of the process

The administration's justifications have shifted like sand. It first claimed the 1925 authority. Later, it suggested the arch would be a "top-grade military complex" with drone storage and sniper facilities on the roof. The Guardian reports this claim was made by Donald Trump himself.

When the justification for a project changes from a monument to a sniper nest, the process has failed. The National Capital Planning Commission approved the structure by a vote of 8-4. But an hour later, U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan blocked construction for 14 days.

Judge Chutkan, an Obama appointee, ruled that the administration is prohibited from "initiating, making or otherwise effectuating" any construction-related activity. This is a necessary pause. The court must decide if the executive branch can resurrect a dead statute to avoid the people's representatives.

The administration's best case is that the executive has broad discretion over federal lands. They will argue that the 1925 plan provides a sufficient legal hook. But that hook cannot hold a 250-foot arch. If this reasoning survives, any future president could find a forgotten 19th-century decree to justify any construction they desire.

The Kennedy family is right on the law, even if their plea is rooted in grief. The rule of law is not a suggestion. It is a set of boundaries. When an administration uses a century-old plan and a pre-existing contract to avoid Congress, it is not exercising authority. It is avoiding it.

The court should convert the temporary block into a permanent injunction. The administration cannot use a 1925 plan to bypass the constitutional requirement for congressional authorization. To allow this would be to trade the rule of law for the rule of the architect. The arch must not be built because the process used to authorize it was a fraud.

Sources

  1. Politico: Kennedy family seeks to block construction of Trump’s arch
  2. CNN: Kennedy family sues to block Trump’s arch
  3. ABC News: Kennedy family members ask a judge to block Trump's Arlington memorial arch
  4. The Guardian: Kennedys sue to block Trump’s gilded arch, saying it would ‘cast shadow’ over JFK grave site