Alaska must follow its election rules as Trump demands vote shifts

By Adele Rutherford · Reporting from Atlanta ·

As Mary Peltola leads Dan S. Sullivan in Alaska, Donald Trump demands that minor candidate votes be handed to the incumbent, but election procedure and state law must govern the count.

Counting the ballots as they come in off the street

Mary Peltola leads incumbent Senator Dan S. Sullivan 49% to 47.2% in Alaska's United States Senate race, according to figures from Alaska Public Media. The Alaska Division of Elections added ballots to the state tally on Tuesday night, as reported by the Alaska Beacon. Counted ballots continue to accumulate, according to Alaska's News Source. The Associated Press estimates that 84% of votes have been counted. The division is scheduled to declare unofficial winners on November 18.

Cheryl Bruce, campaign manager for Mary Peltola, stated her team is exceptionally confident Peltola will be elected. Bruce stated that today's ballot drop makes it abundantly clear that Mary is on her way to a decisive victory. She added that there is not a viable path to reelection for Senator Sullivan. But the arithmetic of the first-choice count leaves the incumbent trailing.

The legal fantasy of reallocation

On Saturday, President Donald Trump claimed that adding the votes of minor candidates put Senator Dan Sullivan ahead. Trump demanded that votes cast for those candidates be awarded to the Republican incumbent. The Trump administration has sued to block certification if Senator Sullivan loses. The New York Times reported allegations that Peltola's campaign recruited Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. as a spoiler. Peltola denied the claim.

The Trump administration filed suit to block certification if Senator Sullivan loses. The suit asserts he would have won if votes for Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. were credited to the incumbent. But that reasoning is contrary to how Alaska’s ranked choice system and election law works. The threshold for Senator Sullivan to win by including those votes would not be met. Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. of Petersburg received 4,027 votes. The margin between the front-runners exceeds that total by about 200 votes. An election official initially attempted to remove the Petersburg candidate's name from the ballot for lacking a good-faith candidacy. The Alaska Supreme Court reversed the decision and permitted his inclusion. A rule that only works while your people hold power was never a rule. Demanding that losing candidates' totals be handed to an incumbent ignores state statute.

The machinery of ranked-choice redistribution

The 2020 United States presidential election demonstrated the playbook of an incumbent executive attempting to use legal challenges and claims of fraud to overturn a certified or near-certified election result. In Alaska, voters rank candidates in order of preference, and a candidate wins outright by securing more than 50% of first-choice votes. If no candidate clears that bar, the candidate with the fewest first-choice votes is eliminated. Their votes are transferred to second choices until two candidates remain. Preliminary data shows nearly 30% of voters for Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. ranked Peltola as their second choice, far more than ranked Senator Sullivan second.

The Alaska Division of Elections is scheduled to perform the official ranked-choice tabulation on November 18. State law governs how the division processes state ballots. The mechanics of the count grind forward according to established procedure, undisturbed by lawsuits seeking to rewrite the arithmetic after ballots are cast.

Legitimacy is a capital stock that spends fast and refills slowly. Legal challenges brought against the Alaska Division of Elections spend that capital with both hands. When an administration attempts to discard rules because a preliminary tally displeases them, it attacks election machinery. The federal courts should dismiss these post-election lawsuits. They must allow the Alaska Division of Elections to complete its tabulation on November 18. Procedure is where power actually lives, and state election law must govern state ballots.

Sources

  1. Alaska Public Media: Peltola and JKT strengthen leads in latest Alaska election results
  2. Democracy Docket: Trump demands every Alaska vote against Peltola be awarded to Republican incumbent in latest assault on Senate race
  3. Alaska's News Source: The Useless Clown Party, Petersburg Dan Sullivan and waiting
  4. Alaska Beacon: With 25,000 more votes counted, Peltola, JKT and Begich near victory in Alaska election
  5. CNBC: Mississippi Senate: Scott Colom lead over Hyde-Smith pops to more than 4,400 votes