A judge's error let Rony Gomez-Alberto threaten a United flight
By Adele Rutherford · Reporting from Atlanta ·
A judge's 2020 decision to release Rony Gomez-Alberto pending removal allowed a repeat offender to threaten a United flight, proving that judicial shortcuts destroy public safety.
The judge who ordered the release of Rony Alexander Gomez-Alberto in January 2020 is the one responsible for the terror on United Airlines flight 2174. When a court ignores a criminal record to grant a release, it is not practicing mercy. It is gambling with the lives of strangers. In this case, the gamble failed in midair.
The anatomy of a midair crisis
On Monday night, November 9, a plane flew from Newark to New Orleans. According to Fox News, Rony Alexander Gomez-Alberto allegedly claimed he had a bomb. He then rushed toward the cockpit. Air Traffic Control audio indicates he changed into all black before his attempt.
The flight carried 46 passengers and six crew members. The crew detained Gomez-Alberto in the rear of the aircraft. The plane landed at Louis Armstrong New Orleans International Airport around 11:15 p.m. As reported by the New York Post, the Jefferson Parish Sheriff’s Office arrested him without incident.
Gomez-Alberto now faces charges of communicating false information of planned arson and terrorizing. He is held without bail at the Jefferson Parish Correctional Center. The Department of Homeland Security confirmed that "criminal illegal aliens are NOT welcome in the United States."
A record the court ignored
The tragedy of this event is that it was scripted years ago. Gomez-Alberto is a Honduran national with a history of defying the law. Border Patrol arrested him near El Indio, Texas, in September 2011. He was deported. He was arrested again near Columbus, New Mexico, in October 2014. He was deported a second time.
He entered the United States a third time near San Ysidro, California. This is where the process broke. An immigration judge ordered his release from ICE custody in January 2020 pending removal proceedings.
That judge had the record. Gomez-Alberto's history includes felony bomb threat, felony threat—terroristic state offenses, and disorderly conduct. To release a man with a history of bomb threats is a failure of judicial discretion.
The government had the tools to stop this. The 1996 United States Attorney's Bulletin notes the IDENT system. This system uses fingerprints and photographs to identify repeat offenders. The state knew exactly who Gomez-Alberto was. The failure was not one of intelligence, but of the bench.
The mechanism of border authority
We must distinguish between the power to search and the power to release. In United States v. Flores, the Supreme Court held that customs agents may remove a gas tank from a vehicle at the border to look for contraband. The mechanism in Flores is the absolute authority of the state to protect the interior from external threats.
The border is where the state's power is at its peak. Yet, that power is useless if a judge opens the gate once the suspect is inside. When a judge grants a release to a repeat offender, they dismantle the very security the Flores ruling sought to protect.
This failure is magnified by the nature of the target. United Airlines is not just a commercial carrier. According to federal records, it holds substantial contracting relationships with the Department of Defense and Department of Transportation. A threat to a United flight is a threat to federal logistical infrastructure.
The strongest argument for the judge's action is the right to due process. An advocate would say that every alien is entitled to a bond hearing and a fair chance to contest removal. This is a noble principle in a vacuum. But due process is not a suicide pact. A record of terroristic threats should outweigh the convenience of a pending hearing.
The cost of a broken process
Legitimacy is a capital stock that spends fast and refills slowly. Every time a judge treats a criminal record as a suggestion, the public's trust in the law drops. The 2008 United States Attorney's Bulletin states that the integrity of a nation's borders is fundamental to its security. That integrity does not end at the courtroom door.
The federal government will likely use a fast-track prosecution system to handle this case. This is a common tactic to secure a rapid guilty plea and avoid a public trial over the 2020 release order. It is a way to bury a judicial error under a pile of paperwork.
The result is a predictable failure. The state identified the threat, the agents detained the threat, and a judge released the threat. We are left with a man in a black suit rushing a cockpit and passengers and crew wondering why the law failed them.
The law is not a set of suggestions. A rule that only works when the judge feels merciful is not a rule at all. The judge who freed Rony Gomez-Alberto traded the safety of passengers and crew for a procedural shortcut, and the bill for that decision was nearly paid in blood.
Sources
- New York Post: Twice-deported illegal immigrant ID’d as United flier accused of bomb, hijack threat — and was sprung by judge after ICE bust
- FOX 8 Local First: Man arrested after alleged bomb threat on United flight to New Orleans, deputies say
- Fox News: Twice-deported illegal immigrant accused of trying to storm United cockpit, threatening bomb: DHS
- WDSU: Man arrested at Louis Armstrong International Airport after claiming he had a bomb