Trump envoys trade European security for empty deals in Abu Dhabi

By Tom Beckwith · Reporting from Washington ·

As American mediators sideline allies to negotiate with Russian hardliners, the Abu Dhabi talks threaten to carve up European security behind closed doors.

The grand bargain over empty chairs

Great powers do not discuss borders out of charity. They gather when the ledger gets too heavy and the line stops moving. According to Al Jazeera and DW, delegations from Russia, Ukraine, and the United States met in Abu Dhabi for trilateral talks. They seek an exit from a conflict that has lasted nearly five years. Presidential envoys Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff lead the U.S. team. They sit across from a Russian delegation under Vladimir Medinsky and a Ukrainian team led by Rustem Umerov. But the most revealing chair in the United Arab Emirates is the one left empty by Europe.

As reported by CNN and CBC News, Moscow demanded strictly trilateral negotiations. It rejected direct European participation in the core room. Officials from France, Germany, and the European Commission held separate meetings with Kyiv and Washington. Yet they were barred from the bargaining table. This exclusion is not a protocol dispute. It is the core mechanism of the negotiation. The parallel to the Yalta Conference is exact. Great powers gather to negotiate territorial lines and security architecture over the heads of smaller states, risking a de facto partition of Europe.

The mechanism shared with Yalta is the imperial prerogative of the strong to dispose of the sovereign space of the weak. Roosevelt, Churchill, and Stalin drew lines across maps in Livadia Palace without the representatives of the nations they partitioned. Today, American intermediaries and Russian ideologues treat European security as a divisible asset. President Donald Trump took office in January 2025 promising to end the war quickly. He has urged Kyiv to cede territory for a deal. When Washington bargains bilaterally with Moscow on defense architecture, it revives the fear in National Security Decision Memorandum 108. Great-power horse-trading risks trading away allied interests for a transient diplomatic receipt.

Interests, capabilities, and the price of stalemate

To understand Abu Dhabi, look past the public maneuvering to the ledger of interests and capabilities. Moscow's interest remains the subjugation of Ukrainian sovereignty. Vladimir Putin demands full control over the Donbas, recognition of occupied land as Russian, a permanent bar on Ukrainian NATO membership, and the lifting of sanctions. Kyiv's interest is survival and the restoration of its original borders. It rejects ceding territory not captured on the battlefield. Washington's interest under the Trump administration is a rapid transactional exit, driven by domestic political exhaustion.

Capabilities determine how far each capital can press its demands. Russia occupies roughly 20 percent of Ukraine, including Crimea and eastern Donbas. It relies on stamina for a protracted conflict. Kyiv relies on battlefield attrition, inflicting heavy Russian losses and launching long-range strikes on oil facilities inside Russia. Yet Ukraine faces severe material constraints as U.S. mediation pushes for resolution. Washington retains diplomatic and economic leverage. Special envoys Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff bring a transactional approach to statecraft. Kushner previously secured a $2 billion investment from the Saudi Public Investment Fund through Affinity Partners.

Statements reveal how the parties position their leverage. Kremlin spokesperson Dmitry Peskov stated that talks focus on security guarantees in a trilateral format. Delegation head Vladimir Medinsky warned that the war will continue unless Ukraine caves to Russian demands. Meanwhile, President Volodymyr Zelenskyy stated that recent battlefield gains genuinely strengthen Ukraine's negotiating position. He urged Washington to convince Russia to end its war. President Donald Trump told reporters he saw a very strong inclination toward ending the war. He added that both sides were tired of fighting.

The five-year cost of a modern Yalta

As reported by NPR and DW, European officials view Washington's bilateral security talks with acute suspicion. They understand what five years of war have demonstrated: paper guarantees negotiated by outside intermediaries offer little protection. A U.S. official noted that security guarantees could include a defense commitment modeled on Article 5 of NATO's founding treaty. Yet European capitals fear a settlement negotiated over their heads. This recalls the bitter lessons of the 2014 annexation of Crimea. Initial territorial seizures established a permanent baseline for subsequent Russian aggression.

Medinsky's presence as chief negotiator embodies the Kremlin's reliance on historical stamina. In previous talks, Medinsky invoked the twenty-one-year Russo-Swedish War. He signaled that Moscow is prepared to fight for as many years as necessary. By refusing European participation and insisting on maximalist territorial demands, Moscow uses the Abu Dhabi format to institutionalize its gains. The U.S. special envoys may believe they are crafting a permanent settlement. Yet trading Ukrainian land for a temporary cessation of hostilities merely defers the explosion.

The Abu Dhabi trilateral talks will founder on Moscow's insistence on full territorial capitulation. This will lead Washington to pivot toward a bilateral security arrangement with the Kremlin that bypasses European objections. The empty chair in the UAE capital will prove to be the most honest place at the table. It represents the precise price of a grand bargain bought at the expense of allies.

Sources

  1. Al Jazeera: Russia, Ukraine and US officials hold talks in Abu Dhabi
  2. CNN: Ukraine peace talks restart after 9 months. What makes them different this time?
  3. NPR: U.S.-mediated talks on ending Russia-Ukraine war begin in Abu Dhabi
  4. CBC News: U.S.-mediated talks between Russia and Ukraine begin in Abu Dhabi
  5. DW: US, Russia and Ukraine start talks in Abu Dhabi