Supreme Court surrenders Big Bend to Trump's bulldozers
By Alma Cordero · Reporting from El Paso ·
By lifting an injunction in Big Bend, the Supreme Court endorsed executive lawlessness and cleared the path for contractors to dynamite an irreplaceable Texas landscape.
The paper shield and the dynamite
We have lived with the machinery of this fence for decades down here, watching men in suits draw lines across the desert they have never walked. On Monday, the Supreme Court handed Donald Trump the key to dynamite the canyons of West Texas. In an unsigned, five-page decision, the high court lifted an injunction that had briefly paused construction in the remote Big Bend region. It ruled that the administration was "extremely likely to prevail." Only Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson stood up to dissent. The majority declared that the government has "compelling interests" in border security. Those interests outweigh any aesthetic, recreational, or environmental harm. As NBC News and The Guardian reported, the court held that a lower federal judge lacked the authority to even look at the question. James Percival, general counsel for the Department of Homeland Security, celebrated on X with a gloating dispatch about their 8-1 win. But the people who actually live along the river know what comes next. They include river guide and property owner Danny Miller and the nonprofit Friends of the Ruidosa Church. Contractors are already poised to bulldoze pristine desert and blast ancient rock. The Supreme Court has decided that federal convenience trumps the earth itself.
This is the exact same mechanism built into the Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act. That 1996 law gave the executive branch the power to wipe away environmental and conservation protections with the stroke of a pen. It is the legislative engine that traces right back to the Secure Fence Act of 2006 signed by George W. Bush. Congress wrote a blank check for executive overreach, and every administration since has cashed it. When Kristi Noem served as Homeland Security Secretary in February, she issued the initial waivers. She moved to evade bedrock laws like the National Environmental Policy Act and the Endangered Species Act. Her successor, Markwayne Mullin, issued two more in May and July to keep the project moving. Solicitor General D. John Sauer argued in court that Congress gave them broad authority to build without red tape. The courts keep nodding along. They pretend that statute is a magic wand that vaporizes the rule of law whenever a politician wants a photograph at the border.
The lowest numbers and the loudest bulldozers
The rationale for this destruction crumbles the moment you look at the government’s own ledgers. The Trump administration claimed in court filings that 89,000 people have been detained trying to enter the U.S. in this sparsely populated segment. Yet federal data analyzed by U.S. District Judge Kathleen Cardone reveals the truth. The Big Bend sector has the lowest apprehension rates and the lowest number of encounters of any section of the southern border. As Al Jazeera and El País noted, Cardone pointed out that Big Bend accounts for migrant apprehensions. If Big Bend is an area of high illegal entry, she wrote, then every place on earth is. That is why Judge Cardone invalidated Kristi Noem’s waivers on October 2. She found that the secretary lacked sweeping powers to bypass Congress. The administration panicked, begged for a stay, and when Cardone refused, ran straight to Washington to get their way. They are pushing a massive project funded by a Republican-controlled Congress that voted last summer to scar the earth. Customs and Border Protection is currently erecting barriers, aiming to finish before this presidential term expires.
We have seen this script before. The human and ecological cost is always paid by those with the least power to stop it. Consider the cruel hubris of the Family Separation Policy, where officials hid behind "compelling interests" to inflict trauma on children. This wall project hides behind border security to justify vandalism. The Center for Biological Diversity warns that the project threatens wildlife like the endangered Mexican long-nosed bat. It destroys the planet's largest dark sky reserve and wrecks the protected river corridor of the Rio Grande. Laiken Jordahl, a lawyer for the Center, called the ruling a horrific decision. It clears the way to dynamite canyon walls before the courts even decide if the destruction is legal. Local residents and conservationists, including some Republicans, have raised bipartisan opposition because they know the damage will be permanent. The administration even backed off plans for a wall directly inside Big Bend National Park after a firestorm of local outrage in August. Now the heavy machinery is marching right back to the edge. They are trading our natural heritage for political theater, treating a living river like a construction site.
This court order is an abdication of judicial duty and an endorsement of executive lawlessness. The Supreme Court had a chance to check an administration running roughshod over local communities and foundational statutes. Instead, it chose to clear the path for the bulldozers. The judges who signed that opinion share direct responsibility for the permanent scarring of an irreplaceable American landscape. Justice requires a border policy rooted in human dignity and respect for the earth. It cannot be a system of unchecked waivers that treats the Rio Grande as collateral damage.
Sources
- NBC News: Supreme Court paves way for Trump to build a section of his border wall in the Big Bend area of Texas
- The Washington Post: Supreme Court allows major part of Trump’s border security project in Texas
- The Guardian: US supreme court clears way for Trump’s border wall in Texas’s Big Bend
- Al Jazeera: US Supreme Court allows border wall in Big Bend National Park to proceed
- El País: El Tribunal Supremo permite la construcción del muro fronterizo en el parque natural de Big Bend, en Texas