California billionaires buy victory over Prop 40 wealth tax

By Maya Ellison · Reporting from Detroit ·

California voters rejected Proposition 40 after tech oligarchs spent hundreds of millions to protect their hoards with Governor Newsom's help.

How tech oligarchs bought a bailout for billionaires

The math of modern American life is very simple. If you work for a living, you pay for everything. If you own the system, you buy the rules. California voters rejected Proposition 40, according to the Associated Press and BBC. The measure was a modest attempt to ask the state's roughly 200 billionaires to pay a one-time 5% tax on their immense wealth.

Let us name the men who bought this outcome. Google co-founder Sergey Brin deployed his immense wealth to defend his fortune, according to the Desk's dossier. He pumped more than $100 million into a political action committee to crush California's Proposition 40. Brin and his fellow tech titans formed a coalition that included Patrick Collison, Eric Schmidt, and John Doerr. They spent more than $300 million to defeat the measure, according to Business Insider and the Los Angeles Times. They outspent supporters, as reported by CBC News and France 24, flooding the airwaves with an ad campaign documented by Business Insider.

This was not a democratic debate. It was a corporate auction. The coalition opposing the tax framed it as a reckless experiment. But the only experiment here was testing how many millions of dollars it takes to convince voters. They convinced voters that asking billionaires to backfill federal healthcare cuts is a crime against nature. The SEIU-UHW healthcare workers union sponsored Proposition 40 to raise an estimated $100 billion for healthcare and food-assistance programs. NPR, the BBC, and CBC News detailed the plan. They did so because federal healthcare cuts under President Donald Trump left a massive crater in state budgets, according to the BBC.

The people who needed that healthcare were not the ones running ads on every screen in the state. The state's ultra-rich paid to crush Proposition 40. They hold an estimated $2.3 trillion in wealth. That sum is roughly equivalent to the combined annual income of every resident in the state, as UC Berkeley economist Gabriel Zucman noted in Business Insider. That is the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 played out on a state level. The concentration of wealth and political power allows the ultra-rich to use massive spending and legislative influence. They block taxes that would fund essential public services for the vulnerable.

When corporate Democrats carry water for the ultra-rich

The tragedy of Proposition 40 is not just that billionaires opened their wallets. It is that the people elected to protect the public gave the oligarchs their marching orders. Democratic Governor Gavin Newsom opposed the tax from day one. He told Politico that the proposal makes no sense and is really damaging to the state, as cited in the Desk's dossier. Newsom argued that it would be better to have a national tax on the wealthy. Outlets like NPR and the BBC echoed that talking point. Meanwhile, he conveniently aligned himself with Sergey Brin and the corporate donors who crushed the measure.

Let us look at the record of who stood where. Vermont Senator Bernie Sanders and Massachusetts Senator Elizabeth Warren rallied voters for the wealth tax, as reported by CBC News and France 24. But Governor Newsom and Democratic gubernatorial candidate Xavier Becerra opposed it, according to NPR. The SEIU-UHW offered to withdraw the 5% wealth tax if Newsom supported a smaller 2% levy passed by the legislature. Newsom quickly rejected the amended proposal, according to the Desk's dossier.

This is the classic playbook of the corporate wing of the Democratic Party. They offer hollow rhetoric about economic inequality while making sure the machinery of state power never actually touches accumulated capital. Newsom's career has long been marked by ties to elite capital, as detailed in the Desk's dossier. He founded his early business ventures with backing from billionaire heir Gordon Getty and cut deals that protect monied interests. When working-class families faced the loss of vital healthcare funds, Newsom chose to shield the state's centibillionaires from contributing their fair share.

The opposition wasn't just coming from the governor's mansion. A leading teachers union opposed Proposition 40 because it set aside only a small portion of revenue for schools, as reported by NPR. A coalition including Planned Parenthood and the California Medical Association also lined up against it, according to CBC News and France 24. But make no mistake about who held the leverage. As strategist Cooper Teboe told Business Insider, the disparity in money was too high. There was a genuine marketing gap when billionaires could spend hundreds of millions of dollars to confuse voters.

The war on working people is just getting started

The defeat of Proposition 40 leaves working families holding the bag, exactly where the billionaire class wants them. Voters also approved Proposition 42, as reported by Business Insider and the Los Angeles Times. The measure prohibits new taxes on retirement holdings, individually owned assets, and personal savings, successfully hamstringing future attempts to tax financial assets. Sergey Brin and his allies did not just defeat a tax; they rewrote the rules to ensure their fortunes remain untouched forever.

The human cost of this defeat is immediate and severe. Healthcare workers represented by the SEIU-UHW pushed for this tax because California faces a staggering loss in federal healthcare funding. This loss threatens clinics and care for millions of low-income residents, as reported by NPR and CBC News. Yet the billionaires who hoard trillions in stock equity and intellectual property responded by threatening to pack up and leave the state. As Business Insider reported, tech figures like Balaji Srinivasan cheered the departures. He noted that Larry Page, Sergey Brin, Elon Musk, and Peter Thiel had already exited the failed state of California.

We are told we must bow to the mobility of capital, that if we ask a billionaire to pay a single 5% tax on their hoard, they will flee like terrified ghosts. Some critics even moved out of the state to avoid the potential tax, according to the BBC. Meanwhile, Meta's Mark Zuckerberg made a special deal to stay for eight years without losing his ownership stake, as reported by CBC News and France 24. That is the power of concentrated wealth. It turns democratic governments into hostage takers, where the ransom is the basic funding required to keep hospitals open and children fed.

The fight for economic justice in California and across the country does not end. One ballot measure went down under an avalanche of billionaire cash. As Tom Steyer noted in Business Insider, if Proposition 40 is not the way to skin the cat, we cannot accept that there is no way to skin the cat. Working people created the wealth that tech oligarchs like Sergey Brin and Mark Zuckerberg siphon into their private accounts. Working people will eventually reclaim it. Justice requires a system where hardware store owners and teachers pay taxes at the same real rate as centibillionaires. Until we build that system, the war on the working class will continue unabated.

Sources

  1. NPR: California voters defeat billionaire tax proposal that divided Democrats
  2. BBC: Californians reject wealth tax for billionaires
  3. Business Insider: Silicon Valley's billionaires won the tax battle. The war on wealth is just beginning.
  4. Los Angeles Times: California’s ‘billionaire tax’ is still undecided. Here’s where Proposition 40 stands
  5. CBC News: California voters reject proposed billionaire tax
  6. France 24: California voters reject proposed one-time tax on billionaires' wealth