Ohio State must ban Sigma Alpha Epsilon for student safety

By Maya Ellison · Reporting from Detroit ·

After a video showed students on fire, Ohio State University suspended Sigma Alpha Epsilon temporarily, choosing institutional prestige over student safety when justice requires a permanent ban.

I grew up in Flint, Michigan. I know what happens when people in power treat safety as a suggestion and accountability as a PR exercise. I saw it with the water in my city and the houses on my block. Now, I see it at Ohio State University. The image of students engulfed in flames is not a "concerning incident." It is the inevitable result of a culture that treats human beings as disposable. Ohio State University and Sigma Alpha Epsilon are playing a game of temporary suspensions to wait out the news cycle. They are protecting a brand while students get burned.

The theater of the interim suspension

A video circulated over the weekend showing a scene of pure chaos. According to NBC News, a person in a sweatsuit on the ground with pants on fire tackled another person. This ignited the second person's clothing. CNN reports that onlookers in university jerseys watched before some tried to stomp out the flames. A bystander struggled to use a fire extinguisher.

The response from the administration was a textbook exercise in corporate deflection. Ohio State University placed the Sigma Alpha Epsilon fraternity on "interim suspension." They called the event an "extremely concerning incident." The Columbus Police Department only found out about the fire on Sunday after the video went viral. No one called the police on Saturday.

This is the "interim" dance. It is a temporary pause designed to shield the university from liability. As reported by WSYX, frats operate on a rotating basis of being suspended and not suspended. Once they are unbanned, it is only a matter of time before something like this happens again.

A brand built on systemic violence

This is not a case of a few "rogue actors." This is the Sigma Alpha Epsilon record. It reveals a pattern of lethal and systemic violence masked by institutional prestige and corporate-style rebranding.

The history is a ledger of blood. A Bloomberg report called Sigma Alpha Epsilon the "deadliest frat." That report noted 9 deaths. The report also found that universities disciplined the group and shuttered 15 chapters.

In 2014, the fraternity tried to scrub its image. It eliminated the pledge system and launched the "True Gentleman Experience." They defined a true gentleman as a man with an "acute sense of propriety." But you cannot rebrand systemic cruelty with a fancy title. When members faced hazing charges in New Hampshire, a judge acquitted key defendants because the conduct did not meet the legal definition of hazing.

The high cost of institutional shielding

The university will argue that it is following due process. They will say that the "True Gentleman" guidelines provide a framework for accountability. They will claim that the investigation is ongoing.

That argument is a lie. It ignores the long record of how these institutions operate. Ohio State University has a history of institutional shielding of abusers. The Richard Strauss abuse scandal shows a pattern of protecting prestige over victims. When the university protects a fraternity, it is protecting alumni donation pipelines and the real estate of Greek life.

The legal system helps them. Elite networks use expensive lawyers to exploit loopholes. They turn dangerous misconduct into a technicality. They ensure that the people who light the fire never feel the heat of a prison cell.

Justice requires more than a temporary ban. It requires the total removal of a culture that views violence as a rite of passage. The system that put students in danger is still standing.

Ohio State University must permanently revoke the charter of Sigma Alpha Epsilon. Any outcome less than a total ban is a signal that student safety is secondary to institutional image. The university should stop treating these chapters like a revolving door. It must stop trusting the "True Gentleman" corporate playbook. Until the university prioritizes human lives over the prestige of the Greek system, students will continue to be the fuel for these rituals.

Sources

  1. NBC News: Ohio State University investigating fraternity after video appears to show two people on fire
  2. WSYX: Video shows men on fire at OSU fraternity event
  3. CNN: Ohio State fraternity placed on interim suspension after video shows two people on fire