Trump calls his cruelty too tough after voters shut the door
By Alma Cordero · Reporting from El Paso ·
Donald Trump admits his mass deportation crackdown went too far after a midterm drubbing, but promoting Stephen Miller proves the machine will keep breaking families.
A television confession over broken lives
The man who built a political career on cruelty sat down with CBS News. He discovered, right on time, that rounding up working people was bad for business at the ballot box. Donald Trump confessed on 60 Minutes that his immigration crackdown was "too tough." He claimed an "A plus for closing up the border" and high marks for getting "the bad ones out." Yet he admitted the dragnet hurt him politically. As he put it, "we also took people that had good jobs, that created one violation, or breaking of the law, and that was that they came into the country illegally."
Let us be entirely clear about who was hurt and who owes. The people who got hurt were not abstract statistics in a briefing book. They were the landscape workers, hotel housekeepers, and long-term residents who lived and paid taxes here for years. They raised their children in our communities. Yet an aggressive Immigration and Customs Enforcement agency hunted them down. As ICE sources told CBS News, agents were instructed to aim for approximately 2,700 arrests of illegal immigrants per day. In battlegrounds like Texas, Latino voters pivoted toward Democrats over this brutal crackdown. Their votes helped seal Democratic landslide majorities in Congress, as reported by The Guardian and MyJoyOnline.
This political shell game relies on a familiar mechanism of systemic punishment. Operation Streamline pioneered this cruelty. That joint program criminally prosecutes border crossers with zero tolerance, turning administrative infractions into courtroom spectacles with shackled defendants. Today, the administration's mass deportation regime treats basic human survival as a criminal enterprise. But when the midterms delivered a resounding defeat, the architects of this misery suddenly wanted to play the moderate. Trump told 60 Minutes that he would "love to do something on immigration" with congressional Democrats, without offering details.
The hand on the tiller is the hand that swings the club
You cannot weep on television about cruelty while handing the keys back to the arsonist. On Friday, Trump promoted Stephen Miller to White House chief of staff. The BBC, The Guardian, and MyJoyOnline detailed the promotion just as the midterm post-mortem began. Stephen Miller is the architect of the administration's hardline immigration policy, who pushed aggressive arrest quotas. A White House spokeswoman told the BBC that "the administration will not slow down its efforts to arrest and deport criminal illegal aliens who terrorise our communities." A Department of Homeland Security spokesperson added that "ICE is NOT backing away or slowing down."
We have watched this exact two-step dance for decades. The 1996 Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act locked families in administrative cages and stripped judges of discretion. The strategy echoes the hardline legislative push of the Sensenbrenner Bill. That measure criminalized undocumented status and sparked massive nationwide protests before politicians panicked over their poll numbers. The machinery does not care about television interviews or crocodile tears. It is greased by federal procurement awards, including a $598,444,871.04 contract to Acquisition Logistics LLC, according to USAspending records. And it is fortified by the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, which raised the enforcement fee to $5,300 for inadmissible aliens and those ordered removed in absentia, with zero waivers allowed, as documented in the Federal Register.
The human cost of this bipartisan theater is paid in blood and terror. Enforcement sweeps this year sparked anti-ICE demonstrations in Los Angeles, Chicago, and Minneapolis. In Minneapolis, immigration agents fatally shot two US protesters, Renee Good and Alex Pretti, as reported by the BBC and MyJoyOnline. Meanwhile, Vice-President JD Vance signaled a tactical retreat. In an online post, he wrote that he is "open to the idea that we should change enforcement - by focusing more on businesses that hire illegal labour, for instance." They want to shift the blame to bosses while the enforcement engine keeps churning out misery for workers.
Justice requires an end to the cage economy
Donald Trump and his inner circle owe a debt that no Sunday night television interview can wipe clean. Real justice demands an immediate halt to all ICE arrest quotas. It requires dismantling private logistics contracts that profit off human banishment. It means repealing predatory penalties and regularizing status for the millions of working people who keep this country afloat. Instead, they install Stephen Miller in the West Wing and wink at Democrats about a grand bargain. They hope we forget the families shattered in the dark and the blood spilled on the pavement in Minneapolis.
If this administration were serious about repentance, it would stop hunting the cook, the cleaner, and the builder. It would tear down the apparatus of extortion that turned the borderlands into an armed camp. The ledger of the last thirty years tells us what comes next. When the election cycle turns, the rhetoric softens, but the cage remains open for business.
Sources
- BBC: Trump says after midterms defeat his immigration crackdown was 'too tough'
- CBS News: 10 takeaways from Trump's 60 Minutes interview: Why GOP lost the midterms, what went wrong on immigration and more
- The Guardian: Trump tells 60 Minutes that deportation policy was ‘too tough’
- MyJoyOnline: Trump says after midterms defeat his immigration crackdown was ‘too tough’
- Free Malaysia Today: Trump says deportation policy was ‘too tough’ in CBS interview