Republicans abuse lame-duck procedure at their own peril

By Adele Rutherford · Reporting from Atlanta ·

As Congress returns for a lame-duck session after midterm losses, Representative Thomas Massie forces an impeachment vote against Pete Hegseth, abusing procedural shortcuts that future majorities will inevitably weaponize.

The clock runs out on a razor-thin majority

Congress returned to Washington for a lame-duck session, according to AP News. A lame-duck session occurs when Congress meets after an election but before the next congressional term begins. Following midterm losses that swept Democrats into majorities in both chambers, the Republican majority must navigate a calendar of expiring authority. As Axios reports, lawmakers face a potential government funding lapse in December. NBC News notes that the first order of business is funding the government to avert a shutdown. Meanwhile, Senate Republicans work under pressure to confirm judicial nominees and Trump administration officials before January.

The structural parallel to this moment is found in the 2006 United States midterm elections. There, a Republican president faced a Democratic wave that ended unified GOP control of both chambers, leaving a lame-duck session to manage the transition of power. Just as in 2006, the current majority finds its leverage evaporating. As NPR reports, the Republican majority in the House faces narrow margins where absenteeism can jeopardize leadership plans.

Senatorial Republicans are calling for a delay in leadership elections scheduled for tomorrow morning to discuss contenders' plans, as NBC News reports. Meanwhile, the executive branch is hardening its posture. President Trump appointed Stephen Miller as White House chief of staff to replace Susie Wiles, a move NPR notes signals the administration's readiness to confront an opposition Congress directly.

Impeachment arrives from inside the house

The most disruptive pressure on the lame-duck calendar comes from within the Republican caucus itself. Representative Thomas Massie has reintroduced privileged articles of impeachment against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, according to NBC News. A House vote is expected as early as this week. Under House rules, a privileged resolution bypasses committee bottlenecks to force a floor vote.

Massie's resolution charges Secretary Hegseth with extrajudicial killings regarding drug boats and kidnapping Nicolás Maduro. It also charges Hegseth with waging unlawful wars in Yemen and Iran without congressional authorization. Massie represents Kentucky's 4th congressional district and holds degrees from MIT. He stated his effort is a "much gentler version of what’s coming when the Democrats assume control of the House and Senate next year."

This confrontation recalls the Government shutdown of 2018-2019 (2018-2019), where a lame-duck session was consumed by a funding dispute over a policy priority. Using a privileged resolution against a cabinet secretary of one's own administration breaks standard partisan containment. When backbenchers deploy procedural shortcuts against their executive, they establish precedents opponents will wield tomorrow.

The machinery of transition grinds on

Beyond the impeachment fight and government funding, the final weeks are crowded with unfinished litigation. The Supreme Court lifted an injunction imposed by a federal judge in Texas, allowing border wall construction in the Big Bend region, per NBC News. An injunction is a judicial order restraining a party from taking a specified action. Simultaneously, the administration submitted a formal appeal to the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals regarding its lawsuit against Alaska over the Dan Sullivan election. President Trump took to Truth Social to question the voting results, writing: "Does anybody really believe that this ‘Election’ was honest... It’s all about the machines, which are far more important than the voter!"

As remaining lawmakers nurse long memories, the legislative machinery slows to a crawl. The tragedy of the lame-duck session is that parties prioritize immediate score-settling over institutional durability. They forget that every rule bent today will be wielded by their opponents tomorrow. The Republican majority's final weeks should focus on necessary appropriations that keep the government functioning past December. Instead, floor fights over cabinet impeachments and speculative litigation spend down remaining institutional legitimacy. When procedure is treated as an obstacle rather than a safeguard, the collapse of governance becomes a design feature.

Sources

  1. NBC News: Trump administration live updates: Congress returns with government funding atop its to-do list
  2. AP News: Congress returns to a changed Washington after GOP’s election wipeout
  3. Axios: Republicans' final weeks in power may be consumed by fights they don't want
  4. NPR: Congress is back after GOP's midterm defeat. And, Trump appoints new chief of staff