Pete Hegseth faces impeachment, and Thomas Massie is right
By Adele Rutherford · Reporting from Atlanta ·
Rep. Thomas Massie introduced articles of impeachment against Pete Hegseth, and while the defense secretary dismissed the move as personal politics, the House is right to enforce the constitutional process.
Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth is wrong because he believes the results of war justify the abandonment of the law. In his own words, he prefers "maximum lethality" over what he calls "tepid legality." To a lawyer, there is no such thing as tepid legality. There is only the law and the violation of it. Rep. Thomas Massie is right to introduce articles of impeachment. He is not doing this as a favor to the Democrats or as a final act of a defeated congressman. He is doing it because the process of starting a war belongs to Congress, not to a single man at the Pentagon.
The cost of maximum lethality
Rep. Massie introduced eight articles of impeachment on Monday. According to CNN, these articles accuse Secretary Hegseth of waging war in Iran without congressional approval. They also allege he ignored laws meant to minimize civilian casualties and directed the Department of Defense to carry out extrajudicial killings. The record shows the cost of this approach. Since last September, US operations in Iran, Venezuela, Yemen, and the Western Hemisphere have destroyed at least 80 vessels and killed 243 people.
The BBC reports that Secretary Hegseth engaged in hostilities in Iran for more than 90 days without authorization. The articles describe a US strike on an elementary school in Iran as a foreseeable result of his choices. He also allegedly treated the capture of Nicolás Maduro in Venezuela as a narcotics matter to hide an act of war. This is not a policy disagreement. It is a systemic rejection of the War Powers Resolution.
The mechanics of a privileged resolution
The process now moves to the House floor. Rep. Massie used a privileged resolution. This means Speaker Mike Johnson must schedule a vote within two legislative days. ABC News reports that the House is under Republican control, but the math has shifted. A simple majority is required for the resolution to pass. House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries is a "hard yes." If three Republicans join the Democrats, Hegseth will be impeached.
The procedural path mirrors the Impeachment of Alejandro Mayorkas (2024). In that case, the House used its power to censure a secretary's execution of the law. The Mayorkas case showed how a determined faction can force a floor vote. The charge of abusing power for political gain also echoes the First impeachment of Donald Trump (2019). The Trump 2019 articles similarly focused on the misuse of official authority. Secretary Hegseth claims these are "sham articles" and "the politics of personal destruction." He is wrong. The politics are messy, but the process is the only tool left when a secretary treats the law as a suggestion.
A history of failed removals
The House has impeached two cabinet members in US history. The Senate did not remove either. This pattern is the Impeachment of William Belknap. In that case, the House initiated impeachment proceedings against a cabinet secretary for alleged abuses of office and violation of the law. The mechanism is the same here. The House acts as the grand jury, and the Senate acts as the judge.
The Senate is under Republican control. A two-thirds supermajority is required to convict. The Guardian notes that Pete Hegseth is a key part of Donald Trump’s administration. President Trump has stated he has "every intention to keep" his secretary. This makes a conviction unlikely. However, the impeachment itself serves a purpose. It creates a formal record of the breach. It forces the Senate to decide if "maximum lethality" is a valid substitute for statutory authority.
The House of Representatives will likely pass the resolution. They will use a simple majority aided by Democratic unity and a few Republican defectors. The Senate will probably decline a full trial. They will likely refer the matter to a committee or dismiss the charges before January. President Donald Trump will almost certainly retain Pete Hegseth as Defense Secretary. He will assert executive authority over the operations in Iran and Yemen. This outcome would be a failure of the Senate, but the House is doing its job. Legitimacy is a capital stock that spends fast and refills slowly. By treating the law as a "stupid rule," Secretary Hegseth has spent a fortune of that stock. The impeachment is the bill coming due.