Judge Reyes checks executive branch candor with a special master

By Adele Rutherford · Reporting from Atlanta ·

When an administration removes hundreds of trees before the court can rule, appointing a former prosecutor to investigate the record is the right tool to demand honesty.

An empty promise on the grass and a bench pushed too far

The bench does not exist to take your word for it when the chainsaws start humming before the ink is dry on the docket. According to reporting from The Washington Post and NBC News, U.S. District Judge Ana C. Reyes announced her intention to appoint Jessie K. Liu as a special master. Liu is to investigate potential ethical violations by Justice and Interior Department lawyers. The inquiry concerns the administration’s plans for East Potomac Golf Links. More than 400 trees were removed earlier this month, as detailed by CNN. Judge Reyes opened the formal ethics inquiry after questioning whether government lawyers provided misleading or incomplete information regarding the administration’s plans to close and redevelop the course.

The case stems from a lawsuit initiated in February by the DC Preservation League and golfers challenging the renovation. The administration plans to close the East Potomac Golf Course and park on November 15. The plan is to construct a world-class, championship-level golf course capable of hosting major events, according to NBC News and The Seattle Times. Last month, Judge Reyes issued an injunction barring the government from removing or damaging additional trees. The order required ten days’ written notice before making any irreparable modification to the course while the lawsuit remains active. Yet the trees came down anyway. The justifications offered by the executive branch left the court searching for basic candor. Judge Reyes spoke during a hearing reported by CNN. She was beyond disappointed and skeptical of the administration's claims, asking directly whether she had been lied to in declarations about plans and timing.

The choice of an independent investigator preserves the integrity of the record

The strongest opposing case against the appointment is that an independent investigator intrudes upon the executive branch's internal disciplinary authority and risks turning routine trial management into an inter-branch feud. Georgetown University Law Center professor David Super noted that a formal investigation into trial participants can be a precursor to holding someone in contempt of court. The probe reflects the sheer difficulty the judge faced in determining who initiated the tree-cutting in defiance of prior assurances. But this objection mistakes executive convenience for constitutional separation of powers. The judiciary possesses the inherent authority to police its own proceedings and ensure that officers of the court do not mislead the tribunal. When the Department of Justice gives the court less than one day's notice before leveling a grove of trees while litigation is pending, the court cannot simply shrug and move the docket along. Judge Reyes does not have the time to keep holding long, complex hearings to untangle conflicting agency representations. That makes the appointment of an outside investigator not an overreach, but a necessity of basic case management.

The choice of Jessie K. Liu is itself an interesting test of institutional memory. Liu, a partner at Liu Shur Kravis who previously served as the U.S. Attorney for the District of Columbia, brings deep familiarity with how the Justice Department operates. Like the Plame affair, this inquiry hinges on the fundamental premise that government lawyers cannot tell one story to a judge in a robe and another to the public on social media. Donald Trump posted on Truth Social beginning October 18 regarding plans for the course, stating the park would be closed for work. The Department of Justice only formally filed notice on October 28 that the renovation plans were real.

A rule that only works when your friends hold power is no rule at all

We have seen this movie before, and we know how the script reads depending on who occupies the White House. If we are to have a legal system that survives changes in administration, the rule requiring candor to the tribunal must apply with equal force. It must apply whether the lawyers answering the summons were appointed by a Republican or a Democrat.

Judge Reyes was nominated by President Joe Biden, and her courtroom has already seen fierce disputes over executive power, including the 2025 dismissals of U.S. inspectors general and challenges to military transgender bans. But the issue here is not the substantive merits of a golf course renovation or the wisdom of presidential priorities. The issue is whether the lawyers representing the United States lied to a federal judge about when and why hundreds of trees were felled in defiance of an active injunction. The government has until 10 a.m. Friday to respond to the proposed selection of Liu. It may object to her appointment without forfeiting its ability to argue that the underlying ethics investigation should not proceed at all.

If the Justice Department wishes to contest the appointment, let it make its arguments in briefs rather than through back-channel evasions and truncated notices. A rule that only works when your own party holds the levers of power was never a rule to begin with. Judge Reyes is right to demand an exact accounting of who said what and when. A court that accepts half-truths from the powerful soon ceases to be a court at all.

Sources

  1. The Washington Post: Judge taps ex-prosecutor to probe lawyer conduct in Trump golf course fight
  2. NBC News: Judge wants former U.S. attorney to investigate whether the government misled her in Trump golf case
  3. CNN: Judge expected to tap former US attorney to investigate possible ‘ethical violations’ by Trump admin lawyers in case
  4. The Seattle Times: Judge wants former U.S. attorney to investigate whether she was misled in Trump golf case