House effort to impeach Pete Hegseth makes a farce of the law
By Adele Rutherford · Reporting from Atlanta ·
By seeking to impeach Pete Hegseth over the Iran war, House lawmakers are abusing a constitutional remedy to perform an electoral autopsy rather than enforcing the rule of law.
The Republican Party is treating the House's most solemn power as a campaign autopsy. By moving to impeach Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth, the GOP is not seeking justice or constitutional clarity. They are seeking a lightning rod. After a midterm rout reported by CNN, the party has decided that the war in Iran is a liability too heavy to carry. They have chosen to sacrifice the man who executed the policy to shield the man who ordered it. This is not a legal proceeding. It is a political exit strategy.
The statutory breach
The resolution, led by outgoing Representative Thomas Massie, contains eight articles of impeachment. According to The Guardian, these articles accuse Hegseth of violating the War Powers Resolution of 1973. That statute is a federal law intended to check the executive's power to commit the United States to an armed conflict without congressional consent.
Under Hegseth, the Pentagon did not just change its strategy. It changed its name. Department of Defense records show the agency operating under the style "Department of War." This was more than a branding exercise. It signaled a shift toward a military-led foreign policy. A former senior Pentagon official said that the Iran conflict was a "Department of War-led effort" used to resolve a foreign policy matter.
Hakeem Jeffries, the House minority leader and favorite for Speaker, has called himself a "hard yes" on the resolution. He argues that Hegseth "abused his power" and "engineered this reckless and costly war of choice." Jeffries is correct about the abuse, but he is participating in a process that has become a farce. When impeachment is used to settle a midterm score, it ceases to be a check on power and becomes a tool of convenience.
The electoral autopsy
The timing of this move is the only thing that matters. For months, President Donald Trump insisted that Hegseth was "doing a very good job" and called him "my best guy." That confidence lasted exactly until the Tuesday after the midterms. Now, Republicans close to the White House are telling CNN that if anyone must take responsibility for the war, it is Hegseth.
By targeting Hegseth, Massie is attempting to signal a return to institutionalism. But you cannot reclaim the rule of law by using a constitutional tool as a scapegoat mechanism. The party does not suddenly find a statutory violation; it finds a political necessity.
The pattern of choice
The current crisis shares a mechanism with the Iraq War. Both involve the initiation of a "war of choice" based on flawed narratives that eventually become a long-term political liability for the administration.
Hegseth's defense is a mirror of the administration's rhetoric. He posted a video calling the articles "sham" and "the politics of personal destruction." He compares his situation to the two impeachments of Donald Trump. He is attempting to frame a statutory violation as a partisan witch hunt.
The record, however, is not about politics. It is about the redesignation of the Department of War and the disregard for the War Powers Resolution. The GOP is not defending the law; they are defending their remaining seats. They are using the House to perform a surgery they should have performed in the voting booth.
The House will likely pass this resolution before the new Congress is sworn in. Outgoing Republicans will vote for it to cleanse their records. The Senate, however, will likely fail to convict. President Trump will use his remaining authority to protect his appointee, and the two-thirds threshold will hold. This outcome will not restore legitimacy. It will only confirm that impeachment has been downgraded from a legal remedy to a theatrical performance. The process is broken because the parties have decided that the score is the only thing that counts.